Erika Rakar
Food was so good! Meatballs amazing! Sauce was so good. Drinks were on point and we loved the Elliot and White Pie! Isabelle the cashier was so sweet, came by and gave us boxes and pizza stickers for the kids! The bengals game was on so we got to watch some football. Such a great place to eat and enjoy time with your family ❤️
… moreEvan Kaltschmidt
I was looking for a spot for lunch while I was on the road and this place didn’t disappoint! I grabbed the lunch special and the salad and pizza was great. I went with the popular honey spicy pizza and Cesar. The pizza is old fashion brick oven and extremely delicious and unique! Ordering easy and service was great. I suggest it if you are in the area!
… moreJuliet Wittwer
My first time trying this place. It’s probably the best pizza I’ve ever had, and I have eaten many pizzas!!! My partner got the Twister and agreed that it’s the “best pizza I’ve had in my entire life.” It has a nice balance of cheese, sauce, and bread.
… moreAngela Werling
I’ve always loved the pizza at Old Scratch. The variety of options and ability to customize is an added bonus. Great selection of drinks as well. Gluten free crust is amazing. I’m only gluten sensitive, not celiac, so I don’t know about how strict they are with prep. This location was hopping the night we visited, but the line moved smoothly and food arrived in a reasonable amount of time. All the staff were friendly.
… moreA F
Great beer selection and the pizza is phenomenal! The Mr. scratch pizza will surprise you with the subtle heat! Their outdoor space is spacious and they have two gas fire pits and corn hole boards outside. We will definitely be back!
… moreJenna Erlandson
The food here is amazing. This time I got a twister pizza and the pesto was the best pesto I’ve ever had. Both pizzas we ordered were great and cooked perfectly. The customer service went above and beyond. I accidentally put the online order at the wrong place and they made sure everything got taken care of for me. I will recommend this place to anyone that I can.
… moreAbhi D (AB)
I am a regular at Old Scratch Pizza and ordered Mr Scratch Pizza as takeout from this location for first time. This is not Neapolitan pizza and crust was worse than Dominos. This was disappointing.
… moreSkyler Rader
I love the downtown location. I have been there many times. Today was my first time checking out the Beavercreek one. I have to say I was worried the quality and consistency would not be up to par. After my lunch today I realized I didn’t have anything to worry about! I got the Mr Scratch, with the lunch special. It came with a salad, I really enjoyed the creamy Italian. They were fairly busy and my pizza came out pretty quick! I also enjoyed their beer selection. Just as good as downtown. I’ll definitely be back!
… moreKessashun Arthur
This place has a decent menu, and lets you customize a little bit. They also have more vegan pizza options than you’ll see most places. The day I visited, I went with the angry beekeeper. I’m not a thin crust person, but the crust was soft and pretty good overall. The pizza was a little light on the toppings, but still enjoyable. It’s a spacious place with indoor and outdoor seating and a bar. I’d be willing to come back and try more of the menu.
… moreJim Harrell (LarderRoom)
This was my first visit to Old Scratch. I must admit the ordering process was confusing until we went and asked for help. I also thought the prices were a little high. But once we got the food delivered to our table, all concerns were gone. Delicious. We ordered and shared several pizzas, the Meatballs, the Hummus and the fried Olives! All winners. Would go back. Also, they have the cleanest restrooms in town.
… more