Social Profile: 
✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 1961A McCrays Mill Rd, Sumter, SC 29150
Phone: (803) 774-3043
Menu Photos
Related Web Results
Old Guy’s Italian Restaurant | Sumter SC – Facebook
11:00 am to 10:oo pm. The Old Guy says the first 3 families that come in saying saw on facebook gets 1/2 off one entrée per family. 1 large 2 topping pizza …
Old Guy’s Italian Restaurant – CLOSED, 1961 McCrays Mill Rd …
Get more information for Old Guy’s Italian Restaurant in Sumter, SC. See reviews, map, get the address, and find directions.
Old Guy’s Italian Restaurant – Sumter, SC – Nextdoor
13 Faves for Old Guy’s Italian Restaurant from neighbors in Sumter, SC. Connect with neighborhood businesses on Nextdoor.
Reviews
Sid
Quaint place…not real fancy on the decor, BUT the FOOD is great, well prepared and better than I had expected. I rarely pass through this area, but will definitely consider dining here again because the owners and staff are MOST polite and family oriented.
… moreThomas Landrum
Love this place. Very good food great family ambiance. Just all around great place. Owners are fabulous people.
… moreJennifer Walker
So glad to discover this restaurant in our neighborhood! It’s a great place to grab a quality dinner with your family. The tone is casual and friendly and I felt comfortable goofing off with my 3 year while we waited for our food. The food is delicious and classic and the prices are more than fair. Plus, they have “Yummy Tummy” juices for the kids which is a big win for us! Highly recommend!
… moreLori Alexander
We really enjoyed going to Old Guy’s for Sunday dinner. The food is great and the prices are very reasonable. They are also very friendly and the service was exceptional.
We both liked the spaghetti with sausage and meatballs as well as the lasagna. I would definitely recommend going to Old Guy’s for a family dinner. The atmosphere isn’t what you would think of for “date night”.
… moreWe both liked the spaghetti with sausage and meatballs as well as the lasagna. I would definitely recommend going to Old Guy’s for a family dinner. The atmosphere isn’t what you would think of for “date night”.
Robert Mueller
I love eating local.
Old Guy’s Italian is just great.
The food tasted fantastic.
The prices were reasonable.
The restaurant was clean.
The gentleman that served us was very friendly.
I am in town frequently for work. I will definitely be eating here again.
I know it’s nestled in a part of town that may be considered “the bad part” but I highly recommend giving this place a try regardless.
… moreOld Guy’s Italian is just great.
The food tasted fantastic.
The prices were reasonable.
The restaurant was clean.
The gentleman that served us was very friendly.
I am in town frequently for work. I will definitely be eating here again.
I know it’s nestled in a part of town that may be considered “the bad part” but I highly recommend giving this place a try regardless.
Micah Allen
The service was great. There were few people in the restaurant, so we got a lot of attention. The selections were good. It was what we were looking for. The kids menu had good choices (no milk for the kiddos though). The kids pizza was pretty big (you can even get two toppings). I liked the thin crust they use. I read some other comment that their calzone had too much cheese. I can kind of agree with that. It doesn’t seem like too much at first. But, by the end when it has cooled some, it is too much ricotta and mozzarella. We will definitely go back there again.
… moreKrissa Jo Correa
We were very excited to eat here. The locals rave about it and the reviews made it seem wonderful. We ordered quite a bit since we wanted to try everything. It was awful. The cheese was goopy, our very expensive Sicilian pizza was burnt, the calzones tasted microwaved and the spaghetti was INEDIBLE! When the waitress asked what was wrong with the spaghetti we told her we couldn’t eat it. She just said sorry and ignored us the rest of our stay… Didn’t take it away or offer a refund. Our sons fries were good. It was very expensive and we are still mad about it weeks later. Sumter dining in general has not impressed us at all, maybe this is the best they have, hence the great reviews.
… moreRick Jones
Ate there quite a few times. Found food quality to be inconsistent. One day good. One day not so good.I get take out 3 to 4 times a week for supper since we both work late hrs. Subs expensive and kind of small on the general pizza place sub scale. Pizza is fair. Tonys is 5 min away. A lot better to me and consistent.
… moreJennie Coker
Went there tonight with a group of people. The food was awesome and so was the service from the waitress, BUT I will have to say that my husband was not happy cause one of the owners came up to him while I was standing at the register to pay that she wanted our money. While she was standing there before then she was slurring her words, and clearly you could tell she was drunk. We go in there 1 to 2 times a week to eat but my husband doesn’t want to go back now because of this. The food and service has always been awesome but the owner is what ruined it for us tonight. I also noticed how she treated her employee who is always on point. This is the only reason I have it one star was cause of the owner.
… moreGandys Upholstery
We try to eat at Old Guys at least once a week. We always get great service and the food is delicious. The portions are generous so we get our money’s worth. Our favorites are the wings, baked ziti, salads, & onion rings. Their ranch dressing is made in house and is awesome! Old Guys is a small local business we love to support.
… more