Old Colony Pizza

Order delivery or pickup from Old Colony Pizza in Wallingford! View Old Colony Pizza’s March 2026 deals and menus. Support your local restaurants with …

Reviews

Michy

Ordered a medium pepperoni pie for pickup. The pizza was delicious!! It had a nice crunchy thin crust, perfect amount of cheese and pepperoni. The customer service superb!

… more

Sika Amado

They have delicious pizza! Especially the mashed potato pizza. I add hot honey to mine. But it’s amazing without it too. Just ordered a Greek salad with chicken tonight and it was delicious. I ordered a large and it was a good size. What you would expect a large to be. The woman that rung me up was very sweet and very personable. She didn’t think they had Greek dressing when I called but when I showed up, she showed me that they did actually have it and offered it to me. What makes this place stand out above many other places like this, is how well they treat their customers. You feel like they really look out for you and that is so rare these days. The second thing is the food is really really good! I will be giving them a lot of business, including my friends, who I already told they have to try it.♥️

… more

Malek Agha

This is literally as good as conventional oven pizza is going to get, it’s amazing. Somehow the bottom still ends up with a decent char as well.

Also, they make all their bread fresh, some of the best sandwiches I’ve ever had in my life.

This is now one of my favorite restaurants in CT.

… more

kjs123 stanley

1st time @ OCP & it was delicious, wasn’t expensive, the young lady working the counter is super cool, I’ll definitely be jumping on the highway from New Haven on Pizza night in the future. 1 thru 10 its a solid 9, if U rank it higher, i hav no argument lol

… more

Kelly Pryor

Wow, my first time trying this place and it was so good! I picked up a small meat lovers pizza. I asked for light on the sauce and it was perfect. The pizza bite was really good too wasn’t sure what it was but it was amazing actually. The pasta fagioli soup was good too.

… more

Khraig Schupp

I entered with no expectations and left with a want to return.

I was somewhat shocked when I went to place my order, and I was told the pizza cook was out on a delivery. Being a Sous Chef myself, I’m fully aware of the industry’s struggle right now. 5 stars for the struggle.

The restaurant is clean, and the staff was super friendly. I don’t have a single complaint , which says a lot from my other reviews.

I will return in the future to try other pies besides the vegetarian pizza. Most likely the meat lovers. Stay tuned for more pictures and videos.

… more

Rob

Business traveler looking for a quick lunch. Upon entering I honestly did not have high hopes. I was wrong. Don’t let this place fool you. Had two plain slices and a can of Diet Coke for $6.50. Not only a great value, the pizza was excellent. Just goes to show you don’t judge a book by its cover. Real cheese, plenty of sauce, and a crunchy thin crust.

… more

Nitzely Baez

This place is very welcoming, the girl in the front desk was very sweet and nice which is always a plus when a place has great customer service. The pizza crust was amazing but the only down side is how greasy the pizza was. It fell apart and it wasnt very tasty.

… more

shoshana pursley

As anyone from the area knows, there are A LOT of pizza places. We tried Old Colony for the first time and it’s definitely my new favorite. Have only tried the pizza, so far, but we can’t wait to try everything else they offer!

… more

Kimberly Magnani

Pizza is very good. They are always fast and friendly!

… more

… View more

Hours

Address and Contact Information

Menu Photos

Order and Reservations

Photo Gallery

Related Web Results

OLD COLONY PIZZA – Wallingford, CT | Online Ordering – Clover

Old Colony Pizza | Wallingford CT – Facebook

Old Colony Pizza Delivery Menu | Order Online – Grubhub

Reviews

Leave a Comment Cancel reply

🍽️ List or Update Your Restaurant

Recent Posts