Address and Contact Information
Address: 1010 St Lucie W Blvd, Port St. Lucie, FL 34986
Phone: (772) 323-0170
Website: https://www.nysandwichco.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
NY Sandwich Co. | Port St. Lucie Sub Shop | 772-323-0170
N.Y. Sandwich Co. – Authentic Flavor, Modern Vibe Welcome to N.Y. Sandwich Co., where classic deli tradition meets a fresh, modern twist. Located in Port …
Menu | NY Sandwich Co. Subs
Taste the difference at N.Y. Sandwich Co. From crispy chicken cutlets to loaded subs and fresh salads, our menu brings the flavor of NYC to Port St. Lucie.
New York-style deli in Port St. Lucie, Brooklyn’s Best – Facebook
Both were excellent and the bread comes from the owner’s brother-in-law’s bakery in Brooklyn! My new go to sandwich shop! Good luck to the …
Reviews
JiXo
I ordered the Turkey and chesse. I choose provolone cheese. The toppings I chose were grilled onions, jalapeños, lettuce, and tomatoes. The food was delicious. The bread was toasted to perfection. It was crispy and was delightful with every bite. The turkey was sliced thick. The tomatoes were ripe. You could literally taste every ingredient. I had two chicken empanadas. Not pictured. The staff was super friendly. I enjoyed the food and the environment. I will be going back a few more times. – Jay
… moreEnrique69
This is the second time I went there . The first time I arrived at 5:01 and they said they were already closed- the sign says 5:00 pm a real New Yorker would have taken me . But regardless I gave them another chance . I ordered a New York chopped steak and cheese . It tasted good but it was mostly pickles , tomatoes and soggy lettuce not worth another the money or another trip. Do not recommend . Two sandwiches, a tortellini salad and chips cost $36.00. I don’t mind paying if the value and quality are there . My last trip there was!!!
… moreMichele Cupid
I have been to this hidden gem several times now. They absolutely do not disappoint! The bagel sandwiches are custamizable & consistently delicious. The customer service is so pleasant and friendly. I have recommended several people to try the food here, and they all say its great!
… moredavid sinnes
Portions are great to the point you can stuff yourself or share. The pics show only half of the sandwich ordered. The staff is extremely nice.
… moreFrank Lenau
It’s a great deli, welcome addition to PSL! I had a sandwich, ribeye cheese steak with fries and right off the bat, first bite, Bada bing bang, the bread!! It’s the right bread! The sandwich had great flavor and if you can eat more than half you’re going to be FULL! I’m no light weight fella and half was perfect. I shared with my work colleague and we were both stuffed between the half sandwich and sharing the fries. The have Doc Browns soda’s!! Iykyk. Turned my amigo on to cel-ray at my insistence and he loved it! Can’t wait to get hungry again to get back and try that chicken cutlet!! The folks working were super nice and with the nice weather we sat outside and was nice lunch for a weekday work day especially!!! Thank you for the great food today! Oh, and fries were on point! Hot and crispy but you could smush with your tongue to roof of mouth and they were soft and creamy! Perfectly salted too I didn’t even use my ketchup/mayo mix I use almost always on fries. They were really good and generous amount. I woulda if I tried to eat the whole shebang myself.
… moreEric Ortiz
From the moment I stepped into NY Sandwich Co., I was greeted with warm smiles and genuine hospitality that made me feel right at home. The staff’s attentiveness and enthusiasm for their craft are truly commendable, creating an inviting atmosphere that enhances the dining experience.
Now, let’s talk about the heroes absolute masterpieces! Each sandwich is a harmonious blend of fresh, high quality ingredients layered between perfectly baked bread. The flavors are authentic and robust, reminiscent of classic New York delis. Whether you’re craving a traditional Italian combo or a creative twist on a classic, NY Sandwich Co. delivers with excellence. 
The dedication to quality and customer satisfaction is evident in every bite. It’s rare to find a place where both the food and service exceed expectations, but NY Sandwich Co. achieves this effortlessly. A must visit for anyone seeking the quintessential hero sandwich experience!
… moreNow, let’s talk about the heroes absolute masterpieces! Each sandwich is a harmonious blend of fresh, high quality ingredients layered between perfectly baked bread. The flavors are authentic and robust, reminiscent of classic New York delis. Whether you’re craving a traditional Italian combo or a creative twist on a classic, NY Sandwich Co. delivers with excellence. 
The dedication to quality and customer satisfaction is evident in every bite. It’s rare to find a place where both the food and service exceed expectations, but NY Sandwich Co. achieves this effortlessly. A must visit for anyone seeking the quintessential hero sandwich experience!
Jordan Shrader
NY Sandwich Co is a full five-star spot for me. The sandwiches are already great, but the bread is what makes it next-level. It’s brought in from New York and you can honestly taste the difference right away — super fresh, perfect texture, and it just makes the whole sandwich hit harder.
Everything else holds up too: ingredients are fresh, portions are solid, and the staff is quick and friendly. The place stays clean, and the food comes out exactly how you expect it.
If you want a sandwich that actually tastes special, this is the place. The bread alone is worth the visit.
… moreEverything else holds up too: ingredients are fresh, portions are solid, and the staff is quick and friendly. The place stays clean, and the food comes out exactly how you expect it.
If you want a sandwich that actually tastes special, this is the place. The bread alone is worth the visit.
Taylor Harper
So glad we decided to stop in! Everything we ordered was fresh and delicious. You can tell they use quality ingredients and take pride in what they serve. The portions were great, the prices were reasonable, and the service was kind and welcoming. It’s always nice to find a spot that makes you feel appreciated as a customer. We’ll absolutely be returning and recommending this place to friends and family!
… moreDavid Teitelbaum
Ok so we came here because the wife was hungry and her friend was like you need to try this place.
So we drove up and you can see an American flag waving out front which I like and the red umbrella.
The outside looked nice, like normal Florida cement block places. But when you walked in, the place up front was small and kinda barren but the kitchen was huge.
Met PJ up front who I’m guessing is the owner as he named a sandwich after himself. No one said hi when we walked in so I’m guessing it was a real new York place lol.
Anyway, we ordered the PJ sub, which is chicken, red pepper, prosciutto, mozzarella and vodka sauce. My wife got the Philly cheese steak. The Philly steak was daring considering we just had the best ever in Philly at Angello’s not too long ago.
The subs came with a little bag of chips. And my wife bought a Dr brown soda. We got our meals which were in styrofoam boxes. Wish they used other things for the planet but it is what it is.
I unwrapped my sub and it looked good. I bit into it and tasted good. The only complaint I have is the sauce made the bread super soggy and the sandwich started to go through it immediately. But it was very tasty.
My wife Philly cheese steak was excellent. That was creamy, flavorful as she likes to say, not chewy, bread was toasted good. It was excellent.
Overall I’d give it a 4.75 for my bread but it was delicious both items.
… moreSo we drove up and you can see an American flag waving out front which I like and the red umbrella.
The outside looked nice, like normal Florida cement block places. But when you walked in, the place up front was small and kinda barren but the kitchen was huge.
Met PJ up front who I’m guessing is the owner as he named a sandwich after himself. No one said hi when we walked in so I’m guessing it was a real new York place lol.
Anyway, we ordered the PJ sub, which is chicken, red pepper, prosciutto, mozzarella and vodka sauce. My wife got the Philly cheese steak. The Philly steak was daring considering we just had the best ever in Philly at Angello’s not too long ago.
The subs came with a little bag of chips. And my wife bought a Dr brown soda. We got our meals which were in styrofoam boxes. Wish they used other things for the planet but it is what it is.
I unwrapped my sub and it looked good. I bit into it and tasted good. The only complaint I have is the sauce made the bread super soggy and the sandwich started to go through it immediately. But it was very tasty.
My wife Philly cheese steak was excellent. That was creamy, flavorful as she likes to say, not chewy, bread was toasted good. It was excellent.
Overall I’d give it a 4.75 for my bread but it was delicious both items.
Melissa Kussrath
Wanted to try some place new. The chicken cutlet was amazing the bread was super soft. Also ordered the philly was amazing as well! The fries
… more