NY Pie

  4.7 – 1,065 reviews   • Pizza restaurant

Social Profile:

NY Pie…New York Pizza with Nashville Soul – Welcome home! NY Pie is proud to serve authentic New York style pizza made with the freshest & highest quality ingredients. Our dough & pizza sauce are prepared fresh daily; each pizza is hand-tossed & baked in a brick oven, resulting in a thin, crispy crust. We’ve planted our Northeastern roots in the South & are excited for you to experience the pizza we grew up eating. With every visit, we strive to give our customers a fun and welcoming experience. From flour to pie, we invite you to fall in love with our pizza.

From-scratch dough & brick oven baking are the hallmarks of this casual, NY-style pizzeria.

✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery NY Pie 37209

Menu Photos

Order and Reservations

Order: Order online

nypienashville.com

Photo Gallery

Related Web Results

NY Pie | Where Authentic New York Pizza Meets Nashville Soul

Experience authentic New York pizza in Tennessee – thin, hand-tossed dough (made daily) stretched & backed in a traditional brick oven.

NY Pie | Nashville TN – Facebook

NY Pie, Nashville. 3138 likes · 61 talking about this · 5961 were here. NY Pie is a Nashville-based pizzeria serving NY style pizza, slices,…

NY Pie – Coming Soon – Nashville – Capitol View

Boulevard & 11th Avenue North Nashville, TN 37203. Hours. Coming Soon. NY Pie – Coming Soon. At NY Pie, our vision is simple – to bring our customers the …

Reviews

Dave
Having had thin crust New York pizza in actual New York plenty of times, I can say NY Pie nails it. The pizza was great! We ordered a ricotta white cheese slice, meat lovers, and a Greek, plus six garlic knots and a tea. I was expecting the bill to come out around $18-$19, but it ended up just under $30. Turns out you get New York pizza AND New York prices. The pizza was excellent, but the garlic knots were pretty bland. For what we paid, the value wasn’t quite there.
That said, the staff are fantastic. Friendly, fast, and they kept the tables clean. We went on Super Bowl Sunday and they were running like a well oiled machine. If you’re craving authentic NY-style pizza, this is the spot, just know you’re paying for the full New York experience.
… more
Sabrina GomezHidalgo
The most refreshing pizza we’ve ever had ! Even our picky eaters enjoyed the fresh and house made pizza. From the dough , toppings , the sauce and their ranch !!! Is heaven sent definitely a must !! The workers were soo friendly and helpful especially John .
… more
Chiara Nicole
It’s like walking in to a real NY Pizzeria!! The pizza is delicious and at the first bite my mom & i looked at each other like WOW THIS IS GOOD! 10/10 recommend!
… more
Liv C
Pizza is incredibly good. It’s floppy pizza but it’s NY style and real doughy at the same time. They have a lot of options to choose from before 4pm for single slices too.
… more
Sarah Elizabeth
The pizza was delicious! It’s a very small restaurant on the inside, not really enough room to move around if there’s a line waiting to order. However, the pizza is worth the hassle. My friends and I sat outside, just so that we didn’t feel so crammed. And they brought the pizza to us, which was unexpected! I would’ve thought I would’ve had to go back up to get it… But The service was appreciated!

My only complaint was that when we were sitting outside, putting up the umbrellas was incredibly difficult. I tried multiple times to do it on my own, and it just wasn’t working. It was hot enough of a day that it would’ve been nice to have some shade. Also, there were no napkins outside so to get napkins, we had to go inside and take them off of another table… But that was hard since most of the tables had people sitting at them. So I just waited until people moved, and then I took a handful of napkins from their table, but left the dispenser inside.

But I love that there’s plenty of parking because of where it was located! Super easy to get in and out! And the people working, they were really nice! But again, the pizza was delicious. I’ll definitely be going back.
… more
Avishek Datta
One of the best pizza in Nashville. Must try. Will definitely order again. Order half of Margherita and other half of Garlic chicken. Both taste great.
… more
Olivia Vasile
Really authentic New York style pizza! Closest you’ll get to New York pizza, the crust is absolutely delicious. Fresh ingredients, and friendly staff. The lazy grandma is one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had
… more
Mary Layman
Everyone was so nice, and the food was super fresh and tasty!!! Legit, y’all! Highly recommend.

I am lactose intolerant, so certain cheese and milk products will upset my stomach. Tho they don’t have dairy-free cheese, the folks working were more than happy to accommodate with replacing the mozzarella/ricotta on the calzone with Swiss (which I can eat because it’s an aged cheese). It was perfect. Though fair warning, I got the small and it’s a whopper! You get your money’s worth, that’s for sure.

My husband got a couple slices of pepperoni and they were also big and I’m told delicious!

Both of our meals came out HOT… like melt-the-fork-while-cutting-the-calzone hot. Which is amazing, not going to lie.

Oh, and get the garlic knots, you won’t regret it.
… more
Dr. Adam Meade
This is pizza made for people who understand that dough, balance, and restraint matter. The crust has structure and flavor, the sauce tastes like tomatoes instead of sugar, and the toppings exist to complement—not smother—the pie.
This isn’t pizza that begs for dipping sauces or hides behind excessive cheese. It assumes you can taste. If your benchmark for “good pizza” involves coupons, stuffed crust novelties, or the belief that more grease equals more flavor, this place will feel oddly quiet—because nothing here is yelling to cover up a lack of quality.
Fair warning: eating here may permanently ruin your ability to enthusiastically agree when someone suggests “just grabbing a large from a chain.” Ignorance is bliss. This pizza removes the ignorance.
In a region where pizza expectations have been set embarrassingly low, this place quietly proves that the problem was never pizza—it was exposure. Set this place as a destination when you are driving through and be sure to tell ’em Large Marge sent ya.
… more
Alysekelly
Love love love this pizza spot! The owner, Tommy has the best cannoli recipe known to man! Our family is from NYC and this is the most authentic tasting NY pizza in town! Please visit them, you will not regret it. Robert, the manager is truly the kindest and most professional and attentive staff member and we can’t wait to return!
… more
… View more

Leave a Comment