At the heart of our kitchen is slow-fermented, homemade sourdough crafted with care and patience. From the crispy golden crust of our pizzas to the fresh Italian rolls in our sandwiches, every bite reflects time and quality. We pair our breads with hearty seasonal soups, roasted vegetables, cured meats, fresh mozzarella, and house-made spreads, all layered with intention. For a sweet finish, try our homemade cookies and cannoli, baked fresh daily for a simple, nostalgic indulgence. Rooted in old-world flavor and made for real life, come taste the difference that time and tradition make.
Norway Pizza XChange – Facebook
Details. . 82% recommend (46 Reviews). . $$. . Closed now. . 457 Main St, Norway, ME, United States, 04268 ; Links. . norwaypizzaxchange.com ; Contact info.
Joseph Avola
Made the trip all the way to Maine and Norway Pizza Xchange did not disappoint! The staff was incredibly warm and inviting and took the time to walk us through some of their specialty pizzas.
We tried the Almost Famous, The Margherita and Pats Pizza based the staff’s recommendations. The pizza itself was Excellent with a capital E!!!
Nice flop, not too doughy, not too crispy. Everyone at the table was split on what their favorite was (although my personal favorite was the Almost Famous.) Also need to shout out how fresh the Margherita was!
They also have a really good beer selection and nice wine list although we didn’t get a chance to indulge. Hands down best place for pizza in the area!
… moreAlex Vinh
This place is under new ownership and it’s so good. We’re from Boston and the pizza has North End vibes. Pizza crust was crispy, I thought it was brick-oven. The salad was very fresh and sweet potato fries were on point. The owner chatted with us and was so warm and friendly. If you looking for a lowkey place with great service, try this place. I’ve been here twice already!
… moreMichael Moulton
Cant say enough good things about this place. The owners are amazing! Pizza was easily the best ive had in the area. The steak bomb was also one of the best ive had in recent memory. Whatever they use to marinate the steak in really brings it up a notch. They made our kids feel right at home. My son, who is notoriously pickey, has now said that this is his new favorite place to eat and that I needed to leave a one million star review.
You can tell these folks really take pride in the food they make, and the community they serve. I spent a good portion of my life in food service and its nice to see a younger generation doing everything they can to bring good food to the masses for a reasonable price.
… moreBonnie McAndrews
Ordered Not Your Mama’s meatballs, waited 10 mins and they alwere served with 3 1/2 slices of cheese that wasn’t even melted. was told it will melt over the HOT meatballs . However, the meatballs were ice cold. They took it and I waited some more, this time the cheese was melted but the meatballs were still not hot, just warm. Was told it’s their lunch rush so I should order ahead next time. Won’t be a next time. Do better pizza exchange 🙁
… moreRod Christmas
The meatball pizza was excellent. We also had a steak bomb sandwich, turkey panini and spicy roni pizza all excellent. The crust is perfect and I love the sauce. Staff were super friendly. Dine in was pretty slow. We will be regulars for sure but would recommend take out or order ahead of you are time sensitive.
… moreNaomi Curry
The taste of the food is good, however I have to wonder why I found a little rubber band under my cheese in my pizza and it was very oily. The chicken wings were huge and not very crispy and fatty. The staff was friendly but the rubber band is concerning, I obviously didn’t finish my food after that find.
… moreKendall Croteau
It was our first time in and I can’t wait to come back! Everything about the experience was impressive. The pizza was DELICIOUS, the service was above and beyond, and the view is so charming. It is clear that the staff truly care about your experience and go the extra mile to ensure you enjoyed it.
I’m so glad to see such a lovely space be filled with such a kindhearted company, happy customers, and full bellies. It’s restaurants like this that add so much charm to a town.
… moreRachel Sinclaire
Who knew brussel sprouts on a pizza would be amazing! Light and flavorful without the sprouts overpowering the sauce. Bruschetta pizza was fresh & drizzled with balsamic dressing, but not drenched. Lots of great flavors. Prices are low compared to area and wait time was negligible. Swing by and enjoy!
… moreTyler Holmquist
I’ve never really done one of these reviews but this pizza was truly some of the best that I’ve had in years after living in Portland and traveling all over New England. The couple running the place we’re extremely accommodating and friendly. We will definitely be back to try the other toppings!
… moreNicole Welch
Our waiter was an absolute sweetheart! Our pizza was taking a bit longer than expected and this kind employee brought us fries on the house. Wish I’d gotten his name so I could properly credit him here, but my friend and I truly did appreciate his generosity. It’s rare to find such incredible customer service (in my experience), and it really made my day. Thank you! Would definitely eat here again 🙂
… more