Emma Fete
Very quaint with delicious food and charming service. The menu is a bit small compared to something like big chains, but the small neighborhood vibe is more clearly meant to demonstrate a curated and intentionally designed menu, with seasonal offerings. The drink/wine menu was very good. The cannoli were amazing. As a huge fan of local restaurants and someone with a wide palate, I’d heartily recommend Nonna T’s!
… moreKatie Hamilton
Amazing service and food. We came for Valentine’s Day and it was very relaxing. Multiple people came to check on us to make sure everything was to our liking. Very friendly atmosphere with authentic Italian food. They sent us home with a rose for Valentine’s Day, very sweet. Will definitely be back.
… moreAlycia O’Connor
This is the best Italian food I’ve had in the area in YEARS. Nonna T’s was absolutely delicious. I ordered the berry margarita, cheese tortellini, and the seafood pasta. All were fresh and flavorful! We also had the calamari for an appetizer which was SO good there wasn’t a chance for a picture. We will be back!!
… moreCheyenne Cansler
My boyfriend and I came here for our three year anniversary and we couldn’t be happier with our choice. We were served by Nonna T herself and she was the friendliest and most welcoming lady I had ever met. The food was impeccable and some of the greatest food I had ever eaten. if you have not been here yet I would definitely look into visiting soon. We ordered almost everything on the menu and all of it was absolutely amazing- our total only came out to $100 with tip. The prices are very reasonable for the quality of food. I would eat here every day of the week if it was possible .
… moreSabrina Powers
If I could give Nonna T’s Italian Restaurant 100 stars, I would.
From the moment we walked in, it didn’t feel like we were entering a restaurant it felt like we were walking into our own grandmother’s kitchen. And not just any grandmother… the kind who feeds you like you’ve been lost at sea for three weeks and refuses to let you leave without seconds. Nonna T herself is the heart and soul of the entire place. She didn’t just serve us, she took care of us. She checked on our family like we mattered. She made us laugh. She made us feel seen. She treated us like we were her own. By the end of the night, we weren’t customers, we were her family.
The food? Unreal. Every bite tasted like it was made with love, tradition, and about 100 years of Italian wisdom. You can tell nothing is rushed, nothing is fake, and nothing comes from a freezer. It’s the kind of food that makes you close your eyes for a second and just sit in gratitude.But what truly made the night unforgettable was the experience. Nonna T created an atmosphere that you just don’t find anymore. Warm. Genuine. Personal. The kind of place where memories are made.
It was hands down the most amazing experience we have ever had at a restaurant not just because the food was incredible, but because of how she made us feel.
We will absolutely be back!
10/10. No notes. Just love. ❤️
… moresalma saikaly
Perfect chicken Parmesan and Verde pizza with extra sausage and onions. Super delicious. The services was professional and friendly.
… moreJohn Orlando
We don’t live near Mentor but were going to the hockey rink and found this gem to eat at before the game. On a busy Friday without a reservation Nonna herself made sure we got a seat and were taken care of. With a seat at the bar we could watch Nonna work some magic in question clearly running the show and cooking the mains. Impressive for Nonna! Food was excellent, eggplant Parmesan and tortellini especially delicious! Service was top notch and welcoming. Will definitely stop again!
… moreLeila Shaneek
I just wanna say u guys r truly amazing. Me and my son came for Valentine’s Day! “The house restaurant” is wat my son calls it, it changed our lives! The food was amazing!!!!!! Very fair prices! The experience was amazing! I live family owned and it’s so pretty inside! Those cannolis are amazing! The tortellini changed our lives! And then they gave us a rose with our check. Perfect Valentine’s Day date thank you guys so much. I’m so happy to have found u guys I’m bringing my mom for her birthday. It was always a dream of hers to open her own restaurant in her house. Also I love the parking. There was plenty room and it was full house.
… moreDarija Sokolowski
I recently had the pleasure of hosting my daughter’s baptism at Nonna T’s Italian Restaurant and I cannot express enough how exceptional the experience was. From start to finish, the team went above and beyond to ensure that our special day was nothing short of perfect.
Nonna and her son Sunny came out several times during the occasion to greet the guests.
Firstly, the staff was outstanding. They greeted us with warm smiles and made us feel right at home. Their attention to detail and genuine care for our needs was evident throughout the entire event. They were incredibly accommodating, ensuring that every guest was taken care of, from the youngest to the oldest.
Now, let’s talk about the food – it was phenomenal! Each dish was beautifully presented and absolutely delicious. It was clear that the chefs take immense pride in their craft, and it truly showed in every bite. Many of our guests raved about the meal and even requested the restaurant’s information for their future gatherings.
They exceeded all expectations and made my daughter’s baptism a day to remember. Thank you to the entire team for your outstanding service and exquisite food – we will certainly be back!
… moreZaidee P. Laughlin
Well worth the stop, even if traveling through. Excellent food, especially their house salad and any of their pastas. Nonna T herself serves and rounds in the dining room to see how people are enjoying the food. Very cozy atmosphere, was a little loud (hence the 4) due to a boisterous group. Very fast, extremely friendly service. They seated us promptly on a Friday night even though we didn’t have a reservation. Portions were mammoth, so arrive with an appetite. And very good value!
… more