Social Profile: 
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout
… View more
Hours
| Tuesday | 11:30 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11:30 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11:30 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11:30 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11:30 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 11:30 AM–8 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 4515 NY-30, Amsterdam, NY 12010
Phone: (518) 842-4907
Website: http://www.nicolinos518.com/
Order and Reservations
Reservations: spoton.com
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Nicolino’s Restaurant: Home
Nicolino’s legacy began in 1983 when Nicolino and Lina Cassella along with their children; Cristina, Antonella, and Joseph brought Amsterdam the finest of …
Nicolino’s Restaurant | Amsterdam NY – Facebook
Nicolino’s Restaurant, Amsterdam, New York. 5177 likes · 9 talking about this · 6328 were here. Italian Restaurant.
Menu – Nicolino’s Restaurant
Take a look at our delicious menu here at Nicolino’s Restaurant and try the amazing flavors … +1 (518) 842-4907; 4513 State Highway 30 Amsterdam, NY 12010.
Reviews
Rebecca Gwozdz
Upon arriving, the restaurant had lost our reservation- But they were able to seat us after a not long wait. Our server was new (her first night, I think she said) – but what she lacked in experience, she made up for in personality. One of our orders was wrong originally and had to be sent back- which meant we didn’t get to eat together – but the food was delish! We were seated near a larger party who were very loud. It was difficult to hear one another – once that party left (near the end of our meal) – things were better.
… moreDenise Trombley
I ordered 1 items for the dinner for 4, one was ready on time, the other I had to wait as they seemed not able to find it, finally about 6 minutes later our it comes. The second dinner the pasta was in no way cooked, I like pasta – bit under cooked but this was maybe cooked for 2 minutes or less. I had asked when I placed my order for an extra portion of Alfredo sauce as I am well aware that the pasta absorbs a lot of the sauce. There was minimal broccoli and minimal chicken. The staff was pleasant and efficient. I have been going to Nicolino’s for years in Amsterdam NY. I will not return, they have the greatest bread ever, so sad. I did call and speak with the manager who was not very concerned. I had asked why the second dinner took so long and questioned if it was even made that maybe I was waiting for them to now make it which might explain why the pasta was so under cooked, she mentioned oh it was back there.
… morePeter M
Very good food, nicely prepared. People at our table thought that the food could be seasoned with a bit more finesse. I had a delicious glass of wine and there were many good choices. We were here for a special occasion, enjoying food and conversation. The place could use a bit of sprucing up but i would definitely come back for the food and service.
… moreAngela Donnelly
Our server was Maris, and she was absolutely wonderful! The bread and dipping oil was yummy and warm. We ordered the chicken parm and chicken francese. The marinara was very can like and the francese didn’t actually have any lemon in it. It’s definitely changed since there is no family in the kitchen anymore. Still a beautiful restaurant with fabulous service.
… moreBailey
It was only 4:30-5:00 and we were dining in a quiet corner and only the second party to be seated. But when the next small group arrived the noise level was quite disturbing .,it wasn’t that people we’re talking loud but the room amplified everyone including the waitress (who was wonderful) asking / taking the order just rang through the room ( so much for an intimate, dining experience) ….. the room needs some sound baffling to help in this area . This is a classy restaurant not McDonald’s. …. But I will dine there again .
… moreMarie Schnitzer
Amazing food. Excellent service. We had a group of 6 of us. We ordered the fried green tomato caprese special – delicious! Our entrees were plentiful and so yummy – we all have leftovers for tomw – all different meals and we all loved them.
… moreJoseph Stanzione
Went last weekend and was very impressed. Ever since moving up here from Westchester, I have struggled to find great food. The food here is delicious and the portions are huge. The menu is different compared to other Italian restaurants in the area. They have many options to choose from. To say the least this is my new gem and I will try to come here atleast twice a month from now on.
… moreMichelle Halliday
We didn’t have reservations but they did have seating available . The vodka rigatoni is so delish . A very creamy sauce! Just the right amount of spice. My boyfriend had the tutti de mare a d they plated spectacularly. Also very delish! Offer bread and dipping oil while wait and that in itself is a wonderful taste of Italy as well.
… moreRaúl Cerdas
The absolute worst fettuccine alfredo in the world. Beyond atrocious. It turned me atheist as a higher being would not allow something as horrid as the food at this establishment to grace the earth. Waitress was nice however.
… moreBarbara Metcalfe
We made reservations. Had to wait at bar before being seated in a not too crowded restaurant. Had to pay bar tap, couldn’t add it to our dinner tab Why?? Ordered 2 appetizers- crab dip and beans and greens. There was no crab in the crab dip only garlic and the chips served with it looked like they came from the bottom of the bag-crumbs! I ordered the Oso Bocca beef shank with mash potatoes and veggies. It was one of the specials- waitress came back out to tell me they were out of mashed potatoes…… got pasta soaked in oil and a ton more garlic. My husband ordered Fra Diavolo. again the waitress came back NO RED Sauce…substituted Vodka sauce was to be served on cappellini They substituted angel hair without even telling him. He hates angle hair pasta. We ordered the soup, it came out ice cold, we didn’t even try to send it back. all and all it was lousy food! The waitress was nice but really not very professional. It was $200.00 (4 people) – money not very well spent- never again…… we didn’t even get a manager to come to our table to see how things were, so I guess it will just be our little secret!
… more