Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Indulge in our mouthwatering selection of delicious slices, savory wings, and whole pizzas — all handcrafted from scratch in a relaxed, Italian-style counter-serve setting. Established in 2003 in the heart of Downtown Syracuse, Nick’s Tomato Pie has been a local favorite for over two decades. From our house-made dough to our signature sauce, every pizza is made fresh daily using the finest ingredients — including premium Grande® cheese. Enjoy a variety of hand-tossed New York-style pizzas, plus our famous “Nick’s Tomato Pie” that keeps customers coming back. Dine in or take out — we’re here to satisfy your cravings, one cheesy slice at a time.
Extra-large pizzas, plus slices & wings, served in a mellow Italian counter-serve eatery.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 109 Walton St, Syracuse, NY 13202
Phone: (315) 472-7703
Website: https://nickstomatopie.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Nick’s Tomato Pie
See our latest menu, find our hours, and order online directly from us. Locations in Syracuse, NY.
Nick’s Tomato Pie | Syracuse NY – Facebook
Nick’s Tomato Pie, Syracuse. 1537 likes · 1 talking about this · 493 were here. delicious slices & whole pizzas savory wings & more ✓ Handcrafted…
Menu – Nick’s Tomato Pie
109 Walton Street, Syracuse, NY. Appetizers. Desserts. Wings. Whole Pizzas … 109 Walton Street, Syracuse, NY 13202. Open now • Closes at 8PM. All hours.
Reviews
Yunong Shi
Great pizza, great vibe! Tons of slice options—cheese, meat lovers, Sicilian, buffalo chicken—all super flavorful and perfectly charred. Classic NY fold, crispy crust, and gooey cheese. The place has a cool, late-night college energy with friendly staff and fast service. Interior is no-frills with checkered floors and stacked pizza boxes—gritty in a good way. Open late, right in the heart of downtown. A must-stop after a night out!
… moreOlivia Gambino
I am obsessed with nick tomato pie. The pizza is delicious and Eric and Watson have the best customer service! Great end to my night 10/10 recommend WILL BE BACK!!!! We ordered one slice and they gave us a whole assorted pie! COME TO NICKS TOMATO PIE
… moreCharles Walker
I enjoyed my slice of Chicken Bacon Ranch pizza from Nick’s Tomato Pie. My son had the Spicy Honey and enjoyed it as well. The slices are substantial, so one might be sufficient for a quick dinner. The server was friendly and let us know what is what when it came to slices. The restaurant is a little tired looking inside but, no doubt, was nicer in the past. The adjacent room with the tables feels like a bit of an afterthought. All in all though, not a bad slice of pizza!
… moreDaryl Cheney
We were looking for a late evening meal after a concert and near our hotel. Nick’s was one of the Google suggestions so we decided to give it a try. We loved the large variety of slices. The chicken wings and garlic knots were excellent.
… morecalvin corriders
Nicks tomatoes pie is great. The pizza is delicious with fresh ingredients. The customer service is also great. Jodie and Aldo made me feel like family. I would recommend their pizza to all
… moreAttilio Lospinoso
This was at the top of my list of pizza places in Syracuse that I still needed to visit, and ot was really good. There was only one guy working, which was pretty impressive, and he was just slinging out pies. He was also very friendly and apologized for the amount of time it took to get my pizza out, but it really didn’t feel like that long, especially considering he was the only one working. I had a large pizza with mushrooms and peppers, and it tasted really good. It did feel like the crust at the end needed a little something to add to its flavor, but other than that, I have no complaints. Also the price of the pizza is very reasonable! I was surprised! I would come back, and I have seen that sometimes they have a Spaghetti pizza, and I would really like to try that!
… moreEmma Espinoza
Best pizza in Syracuse, NY! Jody and Nick was nice and courteous, something I didn’t expect in NY. They out did themselves is service alone, but the pizza is what took the care or rather the pie! Highly recommend if you want an authentic NY pizza experience!
… moreMr. Branham
The pizza was great if you want your crust more crispy just tell him to cook it a little longer staff is excellent very friendly great jokes
… moreRob Oatman
If you’re looking to absorb a bit of local color in Syracuse’s Armory Square, Nick’s Tomato Pie is the place for you. It’s not super clean and the menu boards were not functioning. We could hear a bit of moaning/bellowing from the other side of the dining room. No worry, though. Turns out it was just Clarence, a foul-mouthed vagrant who, we were told, considers the joint a “safe place.” Clarence was under the influence, but seemed to love everyone, including me, my family, the financial advisor seated next to us and Raquel, the person in the command chair of this establishment. (I can’t say enough about Racquel; she handles Clarence in a heartwarming manner, telling him to behave and returning his proclamations of affection all while just getting her job done. If there had been an impending asteroid strike, I believe she could have led us to safety. She was that good.)
As for the pizza, the crust is the standout player. The pepperoni pie was somewhere between OK and a-little-better-than-OK. The poutine pizza was far superior, loaded with yummy cheese and crisp fries. I would have liked to have seen more gravy on that one, though.
… moreAs for the pizza, the crust is the standout player. The pepperoni pie was somewhere between OK and a-little-better-than-OK. The poutine pizza was far superior, loaded with yummy cheese and crisp fries. I would have liked to have seen more gravy on that one, though.
Rob St. Croix
Just check-ed into hotel and wanted a bite. This was close and looked promising. Wow was I happy I tried it. I would eat here frequently if I was a local.
… more