Nicko’s NY Pizza brings authentic New York–style pizza to the heart of Euharlee, GA. Our dough is made in-house, hand-stretched, and baked to perfection for that classic foldable slice you can’t find just anywhere. Alongside our signature pizzas, we also serve fresh salads, hand-scooped ice cream, and feature an arcade for the whole family to enjoy. Whether you’re dining in, grabbing carry-out, or calling ahead for a quick pick-up, Nicko’s is all about great food, good times, and community. Located at 110 Covered Bridge Rd, Euharlee, GA ⏰ Open Wednesday–Thursday 3 PM–8 PM, Friday–Saturday 11 AM–9 PM Call us at 470-315-4625
Hours
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | 3–8 PM |
| Tuesday | 3–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 3–8 PM |
| Thursday | 3–8 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 110 Covered Bridge Rd, Euharlee, GA 30120
Phone: (470) 315-4625
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
Nickos Pizza
Nicko’s NY Pizza | Euharlee, GA Authentic New York-style pizza made fresh daily in the heart of Euharlee. Hand-tossed dough, classic pies, …
Nicko’s NY Pizza | Euharlee GA – Facebook
Details. . 100% recommend (25 Reviews). . Closed now. . 110 Covered Bridge Rd, Euharlee, GA, United States, 30120 ; Links. . nickosnypizza.com ; Contact info.
Nickos NY Pizza
Nickos NY Pizza. Pickup Shipping. Select location. Find the nearest store. Nicko’s Pizza and Wings. 110 Covered Bridge Rd SW. Euharlee, GA 30120. +100 miles.
Last Updates
Reviews
Lee Stevenson
Run don’t walk to Nicko’s NY Pizza. Not often does a pizza place allow 1/2 and 1/2 on specialty pizzas. Nicko’s does.
The oven baked wings and pizza are worth the drive if you live a distance away.
We had lemon pepper wings and an 18inch pizza. Both were top notch.
We enjoyed these two delights across the street at a picnic table in the park.
… moreThe oven baked wings and pizza are worth the drive if you live a distance away.
We had lemon pepper wings and an 18inch pizza. Both were top notch.
We enjoyed these two delights across the street at a picnic table in the park.
Adri Hargrove
Had to check this out after learning about it on Instagram! The pizza was good and fresh! Love love love the margarita pizza that basil was amazing!! Also got an ice cream in a cup for the road! The two cashiers were very kind and gave me a sample on the banana pudding ice cream which I highly recommend it was delicious!! The arcade was fun as well although I wish I won something!!
… moreDanny Pettus
My first visit, I didn’t know what to expect, so i ordered a slice of pepperoni pizza and a drink. It arrived quickly and was hot and tasty. The slice was hanging off the edges of the paper plate it was delivered on, so a $5.00 slice is a good value. Drinks are self service. The building is an old historical building and the wood floors are somewhat uneven in places. All-in-all, a wonderful experience. Although I did not try it out, there is a small game room in a room at the back of the store.
… moreC
This was our first time coming in. The great white pizza is delicious we also had a order of the wings and they were excellent also. 10/10 would recommend. Friendly customer service from the employees
… moreGwendolyn
Literally had to stop eating to write this review. The food is fantastic and the vibes are immaculate. The workers are super friendly too! I don’t have a photo of the full pizza, we ate it too fast.
… moreGlenn Garrett
As a kid growing up in Kennesaw GA, my family would go to a lil pizza joint called Little Red Heads, the pizza there was freakin delicious and as I ate it I always had a happy feeling. After I moved away I wasn’t able to find that happy feeling again until a couple years ago in Nashville, TN at a place called Five Points Pizza, so from the age of 25 till 58 I wasn’t “happy” with the pizza I ate. my husband asked if I would like to try this place and today on 11/29/2025 at the age of 60 I found that “happy” again and it’s close to home.
Nicko’s NY Pizza is my new “happy” the crust is perfect…❤️
… moreNicko’s NY Pizza is my new “happy” the crust is perfect…❤️
Nikki Hill
Really, really great. I’ve ordered a couple of times for pickup. The pizza is so good. The crust is so crispy and bubbly and they use the small pepperonis that turn into cup when you cook them. No complaints there. The only reason I’ve docked a star is because I’ve ordered the garlic knots and each time they are raw in the middle. It isn’t pleasant. I can tell they are being cooked at a temp that is too high for too short a time. The garlic in the middle is raw which traps too much moisture. The flavor is so good but it’s deeply unpleasant biting into a raw doughy middle. Especially since it’s $11 wasted. They could easily fix this by making the knots a little smaller, dehydrating the garlic, and/or cooking at a lower temp for a longer time. If that gets fixed, I’m happy to update my review! Not trying to hurt a small business, but people should know what to expect!
… moreMichelle Mckenzie
This place is so crazy good. The crust is perfection – the closest thing to Joe’s Pizza in NYC that I’ve had anywhere (except Joe’s). We got a Bruschetta pizza and a BBQ. I can’t decide which one was more delicious. They were both amazing. They were out of peaches for the BBQ pizza the night we were there, so I’m thinking that the BBQ would have won if all of its intended toppings had made it onto the pizza. If you’re on the fence, go try this place. You won’t regret it.
… morePatrick Cunningham
Ok, usually when I see a small, locally owned restaurant that has a small number of near-perfect reviews, I tend to think they’re being given the friends and family boost from people trying to be supportive. Not the case here, Nicko’s has obviously earned it because holy cow! This is the best pizza I’ve had since I left NY. The crust is perfect, that nice little crunch when you bite into a slice is everything. Excellent work y’all, we will be back!
… moreLeah Fowler
Had a group of 8 ranging from almost 70 down to almost 4, everyone had a good time and felt welcome. All our pizzas were fresh and excellent. The cheese bread bites were a big hit too
… more