Skyler Donner
Stopped by this sandwich shop and overall had a solid experience. The sandwich itself was really good — fresh ingredients and nice flavor, though it did feel a bit small for the price point. I also tried the mac and cheese, which was pretty bland and tasted more like the boxed kind rather than homemade.
Service was friendly and the place was clean, so there’s definitely potential, especially if the portion sizes and sides get a little upgrade. I’ll definitely be back to try more options. I totally forgot to save the picture of my sandwich but I’ll add one next time I go.
… moreKayla Hurst
We didn’t know this place was even here since Schlotzsys left! It is ABSOLUTELY DELICIOUS! 10000% will be back. Soooo good. The “regular” size sandwich is the perfect size. We got the muffaletta and turkey avocado. The bread is great!
… moreAmy Slavick
We were traveling through on our way to Chicago, and I looked up a local place for lunch. Nice had great reviews, so I decided to try it. It did not disappoint. I had a turkey and gouda sandwich. It was very good. The sweet potato chips were also really good. Bonus was the Coca-Cola Freestyle machine. However, today I only wanted water due to drinking a big diet coke on the drive and they still charge $3 for a cup, or I could purchase a bottle of water, and I had those in the car too. They have signs on the door for no outside food and drink. But the food was good and if I lived in the area, I would be a repeat customer.
… moreMarcello Mendez
It was peaceful and calm inside. It wasn’t overly crowded, which made it easy to get in and out. I’m not certain if that’s typical for them, but on this specific day, I enjoyed the veggie sandwich and appreciated the jalapenos they added. They provided a nice kick! I rated it three stars because I think I might not have picked the best sandwich. I will certainly return to try something different to give them a fair shot and keep you all updated.
… moreAlicia Sullivan
I would not recommend. The turkey sandwich was incredibly dry. It was like biting into dust. I asked if they had an oil/ vinegar to add to it but apparently they don’t carry anything like that. Two chips, two sandwiches and two drinks $45.
… moreDaily Driver
Delicious sandwiches, fair prices, friendly atmosphere, and great bread! So glad I found this place! It’s a hidden gem!
… moreTammy “Lil’ Marzipan” B
We tried the turkey avocado and chicken+bacon sandwiches. Both were really good and we’d definitely get them again.
The customer service was good too.
Tables were a bit dirty, but we only saw one employee handling the register and food. One person can only do so much, so we understood and opted for takeout.
… moreSteven Tworek
The bread is always fresh and the sandwiches are consistently flavorful. My wife and I make it a point to stop here whenever we are in the area. It’s an unassuming storefront, but it offers a surprisingly decent amount of interior space. We genuinely crave these sandwiches; we have never been disappointed.
… moreHeather Rae
A smash every time!! I can’t tell you how many times I’ve had their veggie sandwich but it’s my go to almost every time. I take off ranch and add the chipotle Mayo and omg.. with their warm, freshly made jalapeño bread! It’s SO GOOD! Photos do not do this thing justice. Highly recommend giving this place a try!!
… moreRichard Canganelli
The Braunschweiger sandwich was excellent—really tasty and well-made. It’s a solid choice if you’re visiting Milwaukee or just want a classic local sandwich. The liver sausage was flavorful, and it came together perfectly on good bread.
Definitely worth trying if you like this kind of thing. Good spot!
… more