New York Pizza & Family Restaurant

Get your fill of authentic Italian dishes at a local restaurant in Tannersville, PA. New York Pizza & Family Restaurant offers an array of Italian dishes.

New York Pizza & Family Restaurant Delivery Menu – Grubhub

Order delivery or pickup from New York Pizza & Family Restaurant in Tannersville! View New York Pizza & Family Restaurant’s March 2026 deals and menus.

New York Pizza & Family Restaurant | Tannersville PA – Facebook

New York Pizza & Family Restaurant, Tannersville. 641 likes · 668 were here. Serving Authentic New York Pizza And Italian Cuisine.

Reviews

Cynthia Diehl

Amazing food. So caring and friendly. Great place to eat if you like a little restaurant and great food. Highly recommend shrimp scampi. Delicious. Great prices for the outstanding food and service.

… more

Kayla Wagner

We ate here last year when we came to Great Wolf Lodge and remembered they had good pizza!
So this year, we decided to go back again.
This is the best bacon cheeseburger! Their fries, pizza, Stromboli and funnel cake fries were just as good!
The service was excellent too!

… more

John Jimenez

First time here, and got to say everything was gd, the pizza, pasta and the sandwich. The service was on point as well, she was always coming around asking if were gd or needed anything else. She knows the menu and great recommendations as well. Definitely when I’m in town I will come back, I enjoyed everything.

… more

terri byles

The pizza is the best in the area. The sauce is delicious! Our server, Alissa is sweet, checked on us often and when something needed fixed she did it immediately. HIGHLY recommend.

… more

Tanay Chandak

Amazing food amazing service they charge tip but it’s worth it!

… more

Ernesto Alicea Alicea

Phenomenal staff, great food however the place is in need of major cleaning. Much dust floating around and just makes it somewhat unpleasant to eat. This is the only downside I could see because everything else is great.

… more

Drew B

Pizza and wings were great! Very affordable & our waitress was very pleasent! Highly recommend if you want good food, but don’t want to spend a fortune!

… more

Isidro De los santos

Even though they were about to close due to weather conditions the staff went above and beyond for us. Pizza was AMAZING! Everything tasting incredible. The staff smiled at all times even when we got there at last minute. Truly, one of the best slices I’ve ever had.
Keep the good work guys!

… more

Riz Zambrano

Great pizza and delicious food. The portions are generous and the service is outstanding. Favorite pizza spot for me

… more

Sveta dikiv

We visited for the first time while passing by. At first, I hesitated because the place looked a bit old and could use more cleaning and attention, even some minor repairs. But the pizza I ordered was simply amazing — truly exceeded my expectations! Despite the interior, the taste left a very pleasant impression. It would be great to pay a bit more attention to cleanliness and the condition of the place — it would greatly enhance guests’ experience.

… more

… View more

Address and Contact Information

Menu Photos

Order and Reservations

Photo Gallery

Related Web Results

Italian Dishes | Local Restaurant Tannersville