Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Take out
… View more
Craving authentic New York-style pizza in Wendell, Idaho? We’re your local spot for fresh, handmade pizza, calzones, and delicious wings. Call in to order, stop in or, order online. Experience the difference of daily-made dough, homemade sauce, and premium ingredients. We’re passionate about pizza and wings– it’s all we do! We are never complacent as We believe complacency breeds mediocrity.
Hours
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–8 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 21 S Idaho St, Wendell, ID 83355
Phone: (208) 536-3110
Website: https://536pizza.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
New York Pizza and Wings
Looking for pizza near me? New York Pizza & Wings in Wendell serves fresh pizza, wings & calzones! Minutes from Glenns Ferry, Mountain Home, …
New York Pizza and Wings CALL- 208-536-3110 – Order Online
New York Pizza and Wings CALL- 208-536-3110. 21 S. Idaho Street, Next to … Idaho Street, Next to the old Theater, Wendell, ID 83355. Open now • Closes …
New York Pizza & Wings | Wendell ID – Facebook
New York Pizza & Wings, Wendell. 665 likes · 13 talking about this · 6 were here. 208-536-3110 Wendell, Idaho. Authentic Buffalo Wings and Fresh, hand…
Last Updates
Reviews
abeni baca
This place has hands down some of the best pizza in the area.As someone who used to work at a pizza place, this establishment is amazing. The staff were super friendly and welcoming, and the service was quick even though the place was busy. An affordable delicious easy dinner after work. If you’re anywhere near here, do yourself a favor and stop in!
… moreKatherine Purnell
Delicious!! Everything in Gooding was closed passed 9pm and we needed a late dinner. I called up, put in my order and they had it ready in a reasonable amount of time. We ordered the Hawaiian, BBQ Chicken, Supreme, and Meats. The texture was just right, taste was “perfect” as my daughter stated, presentation was beautiful, portion sizes hit the spot!! We would recommend this to family, friends and travelers passing through! Do yourself a favor and go try out this hidden gem!!!
… moreEthan Palmieri
It was some of the best pizza I’ve had—definitely the best in Idaho so far, and I visit Boise and Twin Falls regularly. I’m originally from Texas, so I know good food; I’ve tried pizza from all over, from Houston to San Antonio to Austin. This ranks close to the best I’ve tried! I loved the garlic they put in the upside-down pizza; it made such a difference to the flavor. The crust was perfect—not too sweet, not too dry, but perfect, with a great texture. Everything seemed fresh and well-put-together. The only thing is that it did take a while to be made, but besides that, I don’t have any other notes. I think everyone passing through Wendell should try it.
Visited again to get some pizza and wow y’all killed it again
… moreVisited again to get some pizza and wow y’all killed it again
Alyssa munning
We ordered a Hawaiian pizza and the sweet and spicy peach wings and both were delicious. The owners are amazing people too. They were very welcoming and helpful for it being our first time ordering. Our family loves new York pizza and wings!
… moreMelanie Rediker
Disappointed. I really wanted it to be good. I had yellow plastic in my crust. $47 for a medium Upside Down Pizza and 20 wings. The pizza is supposed to be deep dish, and was pretty thin. Looks nothing like the photo on their website. The wings were pretty bland. Hot honey is not at all hot fyi. And was told if I split my order of wings into 2 flavors I can’t get the deal. You have to get 20 wings of all the same flavor. I initially asked if my total was with the discount and was told she had “already hit the button so it is too late to look.”
… moreLee
Their wings are simply superb Superior to Wingstop and Buffalo Wild Wings more meat on them and more flavorful can’t wait to try their Pizza
… moreJerry Pierce
I lived on the east coast for 15 years and the main thing I miss is the pizza and wings in New York. I found them in Southern Idaho. The crust passes the test all the way. You can tell the best ingredients are used in all aspects. Then you get to the wings. I can’t say enough. Deep fried in beef tallow!!!!!!! The flavor of the crispy skin and the meat …. There’s nothing else like it anywhere around. The buffalo sauce is as close to genuine as I’ve had since leaving the east coast. The bleu cheese and celery included are an awesome touch. I’ll be back again and again. Awesome! Thank you guys. Keep doing what you’re doing.
… morebob jenkins
We got a medium Meat Lovers Pizza late Saturday night at like 9:30. I’m so glad New York Pizza was open because it was fantastic! Amazing service, super nice and welcoming the whole time. She said it would be 15 minutes for our Pizza and it was less than 10 minutes. And it was some of the best pizza I’ve ever had. Tons of bacon on the top and lots of cheese just how I like it. Will definitely be stopping by next time I’m in Wendell!
… moreTruck Restoration
Really good pizza every time. The crust is solid, toppings are generous, and it always hits when I’m craving pizza. This is my go to spot.
… moreSHIRLEY ANDERSON
Ordered 2 pizzas, a large Hawaiian and a need supreme. The Hawaiian was burnt, we could only eat the toppings. This was our first time trying them. Guess we won’t be ordering again. The Supreme was very good.
… more