Higgy
Stumbled upon this place while on vacation. Pizza was decent, wings were good, owner recommended the chocolate pound cake which was surprisingly amazing!
The wait staff could use a little bit of coaching but overall it was a good experience.
Lastly they were kind enough to remind me that Sierra Mist is the same as Sprite.
… moreGary Bailey
The pizza no longer looks like this. The new owners serve very low quality pizza. Looked more like a teen hang out when I went back. I will never be going back.
… moreCharlotte Moss
A very disappointing experience. I did not know there were new owners. Had raved to my sister about how good the pizza was. The pizza order took quite a while, the waiter, slid the pizza off the tray, into the table. Smashing it, when serving. The owner did not offer to replace it. As we were starving, my sister ate some, that was still on the tray,, I ate very little. The pi,za was very bad, not near the quality of the previous owner. Bad experience. Normally I would have strongly requested another pizza , but as I said, a long wait, and extremely hungry. No offer to decrease the price either.
… moreHali Bradshaw
My wife and I stopped by here tonight after a long day of driving. We were staying at a nearby hotel and the restaurant was temporarily unable to deliver, so the owner upsized our pizza at no charge. As the restaurant was only 3 miles from the hotel, we figured why not. We were not disappointed! The pizza was true New York style, hot, fresh, and perfectly sauced, while my wife’s cheese ravioli was doused in an amazing authentic meat sauce. The owner was kind, and an excellent host. Were we locals, this would be our usual spot! If we are ever in the area again, we will definitely be back.
… moreRobin Johnson
This was one of the best pizza’s I have had in a long time. The toppings were abundant have never had a pizza with so many. Will definitely go back. The owners were so nice, enjoyed talking with them.
… moreDavid Kern
Our first visit is going to be one of many! New owners, Thomas and Amy are sure to succeed as they are extremely friendly and totally committed to serving everything on the menu using only the freshest ingredients and prepared from scratch. We ordered pizza, salad and a grilled sub which exceeded our expectations. We highly recommend this family owned restaurant! You will not be disappointed.
… moreJessie Hardy
Bad experience all around. The pizza and cinnamon sticks i got from here were not good. Cinnamon sticks were so greasy/soggy and couldnt hardly chew the crust. The crust on the pizza was the same way. We ended up throwing a large order of both away after only eating a few bites, very disappointed we not only wasted our money but was also left with nothing to eat for supper.
… moreJerZeeGirl66
Finally caught them open, friendly atmosphere, Amy said they just bought the place so I’ll give her the benefit of the doubt. A lot of things looked old, wasn’t decorated, tables were awful, had sticky plastic covering them. Portions were large but lacked flavoring.the sauce was plain, they deliver so that’s a plus, the pizza is passable but if your looking for authentic Italian food then you will have to look elsewhere, using New York in their name is misleading…taste nothing like up North.
… moreSonny Campbell
I have been going here for quite awhile and ever since the new owners came in it feels like they’re not even trying. The Service, Food and Atmosphere feels dull and generic. I got a small Mushroom/Bacon pizza, it tasted like dry cardboard topped with mushrooms. It’s sad
… moreJohannas Gutenberg
No longer Mama Marry’s.
Now called “New York Pizza”
Same number and location but
COMPLETE MAKEOVER
Under new ownership of Pete, a well renowned and extremely talented Chef, New York Pizza has absolutely amazing food and it’s ALL hand made from scratch. The prices are absolutely amazing and unbeatable. They deliver, are incredibly warm and accommodating, and have daily specials that are always agreeable.
… more