Alex Lederman
Delicious sandwich spot, all meats and cheese are heated up on the grill before serving. Delicious.
… moreRye Kuder
Used to be a great place to eat… but the prices are wayyyy too high now. Nearly double the price of what they used to be, and with less of the indulgent ingredients. Mostly fillers and almost no delectable items to satisfy the price that you’re paying. I truly miss this place and hope they hear my words, finding solace in our community.
… moreKeith Gould
Pulled off the 84 for something to eat. Really wanted a sandwich and this place delivered. Fast friendly service. Bread was bomb. Got the Manhattan and the Bronx. Killed both in record time. Cookies are A+. You can’t go wrong trying this place out.
… moreMegan Bean
We stopped in for lunch while traveling from PDX to Idaho and were pleasantly surprised! The staff was incredibly friendly and our food came out quickly. The subs were delicious—fresh and flavorful. We also enjoyed the outdoor seating area, which was clean and comfortable. Definitely a great spot for a quick and tasty bite on the road. We’ll absolutely be back!
… moreAshlee Petersen
I got the cheesesteak and my husband got the hot pastrami. Both were good but I liked the pastrami better. The steak on mine tasted a little bland despite smelling amazing. Service was quick and employees were kind! I would definitely stop by again.
… moreCarolina Margaria
Excellent sandwiches, friendly & quick service, and quality ingredients. Couldn’t really ask for more, and it certainly delivers in a way most fast food does not.
The bread was excellent!
There are some tables and chairs for dining outside, and you can also order food for pick up.
… moreTami Bishop
It was my first time having a sammie at New York City Sub Shop. Oh my, the bread is deelish, the meat, the cheese and all the yum toppings! The peanut butter cookie was the perfect dessert. The murals are awesome, with a specific shout out to the skiing shrimp! 10/10 YUM!
… moreBrian Tai
I’ve been coming here on and off for a few years now when I visit town. I’m not sure what happened but it seems like quality has fallen off. I ordered the cheese steak sub and it’s not like any other cheese steak I’ve had. It’s 90% lettuce with a very small portion of meat inside. It’s also mostly dry with no melted cheese. See my photo. It’s also $20 for this.
… moreKim Bowlby
The 4 of us got 2 Full Size Bronx (Hot Pastrami) sandwiches, and the girls wrapped as four separate sandwiches-which we greatly appreciated! They were DELICIOUS!!! We got 4 homemade cookies and 4 sodas. $61 total. So $15.25/person
… moreHudson Whittaker
If you’re reading this, you’ve found it. No need to keep looking. Just go. You’ll love it. It’s everything you’re hoping for.
… more