Social Profile: 
![]()
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Hey there! If you’re on the hunt for a taste of authentic New York bagels right here in South Tulsa and Brookside, look no further than New York Bagel Cafe. We’re not newbies to the bagel game – we’ve been serving up those classic, chewy-on-the-inside, crispy-on-the-outside bagels for almost 15 years now! You might’ve known us as Old School Bagel, but hey, we’re going back to our roots with the name change. We’re bringing back that classic New York Bagel Cafe vibe, one bite at a time.
Counter-serve spot for bagels stacked with toppings & spreads, plus salads & sandwiches.
Hours
| Monday | 6 AM–3 PM |
| Tuesday | 6 AM–3 PM |
| Wednesday | 6 AM–3 PM |
| Thursday | 6 AM–3 PM |
| Friday | 6 AM–3 PM |
| Saturday | 6 AM–3 PM |
| Sunday | 7 AM–3 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 3723 S Peoria Ave, Tulsa, OK 74105
Phone: (918) 743-7400
Website: https://newyorkbageltulsa.com/nybcbrookside?utm_source=google
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
New York Bagel Cafe | Best Bagels in Tulsa, OK | Bagels near me
New York Bagel Cafe: the best Bagels in Tulsa, OK and other locations. Order directly online today for takeout or delivery. Save money, support local …
New York Bagel Cafe – South Tulsa – Facebook
New York Bagel Cafe – South Tulsa, Tulsa. 2829 likes · 25 talking about this · 3777 were here. We specialize in traditional New York style water boiled…
New York Bagel Cafe – Tulsa, OK | joe coffee
New York Bagel Cafe in Tulsa, Oklahoma. 4.5 stars (995 reviews). Cafe. Hours, menu, photos & directions.
Reviews
Joshua
Tried this bagel spot this morning and was not disappointed. They have a nice little area off to the side for outdoor seating. The atmosphere is A+. Cozy, strung lights, comfy chairs and tons of styles , and a fireplace. Very nice. I ordered the pepperjack breakfast bagel with sausage and it was delicious. The bagel was toasted perfectly and the cheese melted all over. Slice of tomato was an excellent add. I absolutely recommend, and if you have time, enjoy dining in.
… moreBar
I’ve been going to this place for years! It has also been my go to for a quick breakfast or brunch on the road.
This morning unfortunately my chicken Caesar bagel order was made with very brown romaine lettuce and was literally drenched in dressing and the chicken tasted like it had been sitting out.
I also ordered a cookie that tasted mostly like flour and was hard as a rock.
My chai was basically milk with a dash of chai.
So disappointing. It will be awhile before I go back.
Very lackluster.
… moreThis morning unfortunately my chicken Caesar bagel order was made with very brown romaine lettuce and was literally drenched in dressing and the chicken tasted like it had been sitting out.
I also ordered a cookie that tasted mostly like flour and was hard as a rock.
My chai was basically milk with a dash of chai.
So disappointing. It will be awhile before I go back.
Very lackluster.
Star
I tried cookies from here awhile ago and they were great! My second time stopping in and I was disappointed. The cashier was unpleasant. The gluten free bagel sandwich was like cardboard and the cinnamon bun was dry. On the plus side,the coffee tasted good and kept me awake on my long drive.
… moreOlivia Burrus
I prefer the one on 71st and Yale. I ordered in the app to have the order made at a slightly later time so it would be done when I got to Tulsa (about 30 minutes later). They made it immediately so it was cold when I got there and it was not the right order. The bagel they did give me was okay.
… moreCasey Peetz
Cute bagel cafe in Tulsa. I picked up a bagel to-go for my family member. It has a lot of menu options. There’s lots of cafe seating and a nice outdoor patio for better weather. The patio has a water bowl for dogs so I’d guess dogs are welcome on the patio. A good amount of parking. And it’s right next to a nice green space park.
… moreAllison Young
My bagel had fuzz on it, it was stale, and it had half the normal amount of cream cheese. My chai was all milk, and my boyfriend got a plain coffee instead of what he ordered. And the lady in the drive through was not friendly. Normally we have no problems but if this is the new standard, we will not be coming back.
… moreJon Clark
The folks that work there are great but the bagels are extremely subpar. On top of that they give you a thimble of cream cheese on the bagel, I know that ingredients are getting more expensive but for $5 I expect better than this. It seems like every time I give this place another chance it disappoints me more. You might as well just go get a straight roll and eat it, the cream cheese is basically imperceptible.
… moreGabriella G.
It’s been about a year since I’ve eaten here. It was always just okay. I ordered the same, a jalapeno cheddar bagel toasted with butter. The bagel had a lot less cheddar on the top and less jalapenos than what was used in the past. The worst part, though, and reason for this review, was the butter substitute they were using which made me physically sick. There was not even a hint of butter flavor in this greasy schmear. It had no taste and was more like corn oil. Dry bread saturated with corn oil. Did they run out of butter? What was the deal? I ate 1/2 of the bagel against my better judgement and threw the other 1/2 away. I won’t return. Per a prior posted review about authenticity, the bagels here do not/never have had the wonderful texture of a boiled bagel, in my opinion. I don’t know how these are made. However, bagel places in Tulsa are few.
… morestephanie olunloyo
The Bagels are ehh, but this review is not about that. My partner ordered a blueberry bagel with blueberry cream cheese and bacon. He checked the order, and there was no bacon on it. So he told the drive-through individual who appeared to be male and the individual took the order from my partner and gave it back to the kitchen to fix…that would have been okay if the food never left the kitchen but once its out its extremely unsanitary and the way to handle that would be to ask hey can we give you the bacon on the side. My partner tried to provide feedback, and the individual reacted and lied, saying there was bacon on there (even though he took it back and had bacon put on there) So, understanding the type of establishment this is I will not be returning. The bagel is not worth the disrespect
… moreHeartwood docs
Food is always excellent here. My favorite is the Asian salad. I used the drive-through and so I don’t have anything to say about the service or atmosphere. It’s my “go-to” drive-through for good salads.
… more