Nellie's - Arcade, NY 14009 - Menu, Reviews, Hours & Contact

This is a family restaurant with a home cooking style that doesn’t disappoint. They have a simple salad bar with very fresh ingredients. Generous portions for breakfast. Brewed ice tea, not the fake fountain ones you get at most restaurants these days. The servers are very provfessional. Worth a visit if you’re in the area.

… more

R J

A word of caution: DON’T ORDER THE FISH FRY OR FISH PLATTER!! We were in Arcade for the day recently and decided to have dinner at a local restaurant before heading home. After reading the reviews for several restaurants, we decided to eat at Nellie’s. *THE GOOD: A large menu selection and the service was excellent. Our server was pleasant and very attentive throughout our meal. And the extra thick chocolate milkshake ($5.75) was simply amazing!! It was so thick that the straw was useless and I had to eat it with a spoon. Possibly the best chocolate milkshake I’ve ever had. *THE NOT SO GOOD: We ordered a large fish fry ($17.00) and a Nellie (fish) platter ($20.75). Both meals looked delicious, but we quickly discovered that both fish dinners were absolutely tasteless. If you were blindfolded, you couldn’t tell what you were eating. I suspect that they served a cheaper (and tasteless) fish like Cod and not Haddock fish. Some other customers made the same comment about their fish dinners, so that’s a very real problem. We did tell the waitress about our tasteless fish dinners, but no compensation was offered. For what we were charged for the two fish dinners, don’t waste your money. The next time we visit Arcade, we’ll probably pick a different restaurant. If we do decide to visit Nellie’s again, we definitely won’t order fish dinners. Thanks for reading!

… more

Simply Ginger

This is a POPULAR restaurant and for good reason! Food is always top tier, service is never less than amazing and the restaurant is decorated in such a unique but captivating way!

… more

Doug McCallum

This was our first stop at Nellie’s and it I’ll definitely NOT be the last. From great food and atmosphere to great service, Nellie’s will be our new favorite spot to grab a bite to eat coming to and returning from scout camp.

… more

Mark Lavrey

What a neat little place, like stepping back in time. The food is top notch and the staff was on top of everything! Go hungry because you’ll get more than you expect.

… more

Wendy Sherwood

Very large portions. The ham steak is a MUST! We were there for breakfast, but because the pies looked ridiculously good, we got a slice of coconut cream and blackberry, to go We chose wisely! The service there was also wonderful. Highly recommend this place

… more

Sean Grohman

Great little diner in the heart of Arcade. The menu has a nice variety of food no matter breakfast, lunch, or dinner. Service was fantastic and the food was hot. Next time we’ll have to get a slice of the delicious pies!

… more

Stribing “Wildflower” Kimberly

This adorable family run old time diner nestled in a lovely red barn is filled with locals and travelers alike enjoying the camaraderie and fabulous home cooked meals. Lovely place, we will stop again and again!

… more

Jenni Malcomb

We came in about 2 minutes before they were supposed to close. And we’re treated awesome! Food was delish, fresh and reasonable. Customer service was FANTASTIC! We will definitely be back!

… more

Judy Namaina

Good food, fish fry is good… Clean restaurant and bathroom… Nice and cool inside.. If you like the big glass ask for it we always do… You get to know the waitresses by there first names…

… more

… View more

Nellie’s

Address and Contact Information

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Related Web Results

Nellie’s Restaurant | Arcade NY – Facebook

Nellie’s Restaurant – Classic American Dining in Arcade, NY

Nellie’s Restaurant, 572 Main St, Arcade, NY 14009, US – MapQuest

Reviews

Leave a Comment Cancel reply

🍽️ List or Update Your Restaurant

Recent Posts