David Kempt
The pizza was pleasantly delicious. The only thing I would have asked what would be for a little more pepperonis but other than that it was spot on. And it was awesome bumping into a long time friend that was working there Jimmy the snake. I’d recommend trying it if you haven’t. Update 12-8-25 My brother won a large 3 item pizza from Facebook and I picked it up and bumped into Jimmy the Snake and got a picture. What a absolute legend he is. When it comes to pizza dedication he’s dedicated most his life to the pizza game. The other guy that was working was there last time and seems very cool. Easy to talk with. Good people good pizza 2nd new score 7.6
… moreMasten Thrust
This place is an absolute must try, got a fold over and a pizza and both we very remarkable and delicious. The crust of the pizza alone is worth coming back here because it’s had plenty plenty of toppings that didn’t effect the crispness of the crust at all.
… moreJerry Harrison
I’d like to consider myself a pizza connoisseur so I decided to try Neighbors pizza. Both times now that I have ordered, the person that took the order over the phone was friendly and efficient and double checked my order and address. (much appreciated). The delivery was faster than time given on the phone, and the driver was super polite and cheerful.
Now for the pizza…
An absolutely fantastic, traditional, small town pie. Great crust, great sauce, great ingredients and cooked perfect! Will definitely order again!
… moreStephen Gaffney
Local, family-owned pizza joint found in a strip shopping complex. It is carryout or delivery only. They use traditional stack pizza ovens. Crust is from an old family bread recipe. There is a party cut thin crust and a deep dish style available. The family who runs it are all super friendly. Pizza, salads, subs, stromboli, and sides are all very good.
… morekeith grant
Great pizza! The deep dish is worth the wait! Thick, full slices unchallenged through northern Ohio!
… moreRyan Smith
It had been a while since I visited Neighbors Pizza. The last time I came here the pizza was really good but this time it wasn’t that great. Honestly, it reminded me of eating Pizza Brothers. It looked and tasted just like Pizza Brothers, which I’m NOT a fan of. The last Pizza I bought from Neighbors had sorta a beer-battered crust taste. Not this one. All in all, I was disappointed with this visit. I am not sure if they changed their crust style but it definitely tasted that way.
… moreJeannette Smith
Wonderful experience! I was looking for a new pizza place and decided to try Neighbors Pizza. They were nice and friendly on the phone. The pizza prices are very affordable. The menu includes an array of other options. I was told a half an hour for a delivery and it was delivered in 20. Fresh hot and delicious!! I’m hooked already. Thanks!!!
… moreAshley Huffman
Always friendly and helpful. Delivered a correct stromboli after a mishap, free of charge.
As a life long pizza enthusiast, I appreciate the top notch food and family feel.
… moreMegan Gould
Some of the best pizza in town and the dude who owns it is always so nice!
… moreHeather Banks
Reminds me of a pizza you would get from a bowling ally. Kinda bland. Not much flavor.
… more