Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 807 Millersport Hwy, Amherst, NY 14226
Phone: (716) 446-9715
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Natalie’s Mediterranean Eatery
See our latest menu, find our hours, and order online directly from us. Locations in Buffalo, NY.
Natalie’s Mediterranean Eatery | Amherst NY – Facebook
Natalie’s Mediterranean Eatery, Amherst. 1186 likes · 15 talking about this · 609 were here. Where every things homemade.
Natalie’s Mediterranean Eatery | Toast
… Restaurant info. Come in and enjoy! Location. 807 Millersport Hwy, Buffalo, NY 14226. Directions. Similar restaurants in your area. scroll left scroll right.
Reviews
Jessica Lowell Mason
I have been been going to Natalie’s since I first was brought there in 2004. At that time, the thing to order was mujadara (I inadvertently named our firstborn daughter Darah after it;), but we have since expanded our horizons beyond the lentil wrap. I loved the fellow at the front; he was so sweet and was my associative staple over the years. It had a family run, authentic feel. Clean, simple, healthy, straightforward, and dependable yummy Mediterranean fare in a casual sit in, canteen environment. Delicious, especially the baklava. I was so sad that the fellow, Tony I believe, and his family seem to be missing from the establishment now, but it was still the same good fare when we went last week. Definitely recommend asking for tahini or another additional sauce if you order the falafel wrap, which is good stuff! Soups are great, and it’s not easy to find good, tasty soup available every day of the week. Tony, we miss you. Good luck to the new owners. Grateful Natalie’s still exists!
… moreAmanda St
I have been a repeat customer for a very long time. I live about 40 min away now and when I am out and about in the area on I try to grab food here. New Year’s Day I decided to get my usual chicken gyro with my husband and they were soooo nice, giving us some soup to try since we were the first customer of the new year. It was so incredibly kind of them to do that, especially since it was my first time trying their soups. The chicken lemon and rice was so tasty but my goodness that Italian meatball and spinach was out of this world! Will def be back for the soup now too.
… moreTaghreed
Do not fool yourself by the menu photos on DoorDash. The presentation and portions did not match the advertised item. VERY misleading. The hummus advertised shows a full plated dish with olive oil and garnishes, but what was delivered was a small plastic container of plain hummus for $10. The quality and presentation did not match the menu at all. The taste was another unfortunate surprise!
… moreEvan Kus
Good Mediterranean food. Flavorful and quickly prepared. Worth a visit if you are in the area. I had the Greek Salad Special with chicken and it came with rice and pita and tzatziki.
… moreLily Bloom
I’m from out of state and I’m so happy I found this hidden gem.
Owner is very friendly and the establishment is clean. Self serve water, with bottled beverage options.
Primarily mediterranean food options, but there is menu items for food such as chicken fingers, cheeseburgers, soups.
I had the chicken souvlaki pocket. I ate it with the dill dressing. Absolutely delicious! It was refreshing and savory at the same time. Very well balanced and lifted my energy for the rest of the afternoon. I also got the fresh made baklava… best baklava I have ever eaten. Not too sweet, the pastry texture was crunch and chewy. I haven’t had a baklava as good as this. I will be coming back here again before I leave. The atmosphere inside is very cozy, and the noise levels are quiet. Average level of busy, but not any problems finding a seat. It’s a place where you order at the counter, find your own place to sit, and they’ll bring your food to you. Place trays in designated spot, same as trash.
Very lovely foody find.
… moreOwner is very friendly and the establishment is clean. Self serve water, with bottled beverage options.
Primarily mediterranean food options, but there is menu items for food such as chicken fingers, cheeseburgers, soups.
I had the chicken souvlaki pocket. I ate it with the dill dressing. Absolutely delicious! It was refreshing and savory at the same time. Very well balanced and lifted my energy for the rest of the afternoon. I also got the fresh made baklava… best baklava I have ever eaten. Not too sweet, the pastry texture was crunch and chewy. I haven’t had a baklava as good as this. I will be coming back here again before I leave. The atmosphere inside is very cozy, and the noise levels are quiet. Average level of busy, but not any problems finding a seat. It’s a place where you order at the counter, find your own place to sit, and they’ll bring your food to you. Place trays in designated spot, same as trash.
Very lovely foody find.
Brian Hehr
Delicious. The tastiest chicken gyro I’ve had. Tzatziki was perfect and I love that it was mixed in. Pita is thin and warm, crafted nicely, not a typical messy gyro. Fresh and light, absolutely nailed my lunch craving. I can only wish I had tried Natalie’s sooner!
… moreBen C.
We order from here so often, lemon chicken rice soup is always a go to. Decided to order the STEAK & RICE BOWL (pictured). It’s 3/4 salad. No indication that’s what I’m going to get. Barely any steak or rice in my meal, won’t ever order this again. I didn’t order a salad… $16 way too much. Soup was good
… moreTheresa Dristle
I got a gluten free wrap. It was super tasty and delicious. Food came out fast and it tasted fresh. Would come back again.
… moreedward harris
We had the chicken Souvlaki salad and pita. Very tasty! 10 our of 10 for us. Definitely will be a regular. Can’t wait to try some of the other things on the menu. Give it a try, you will not be disappointed
… moreMich Bar
Ful mahdamas was the best i have had anywhere. I’ve they’d this at many places and they had the best. Very friendly and nice atmosphere. Food that makes you feel good and healthy energy after eating.
… more