Social Profile: 
… View more
The newest Napper Tandy’s opened in the old Nutty Irishman building at 60 East Main Street, which once upon a time served as a firehouse in the middle of the downtown. Work started in January 2017 and the old Nutty received a top-to-bottom renovation. The main bar has been moved toward to the front of the building, allowing us to create several areas for eating and drinking on the first floor. The overall style of decor is modern meets old-fashioned. The pub menu is similar those at the other Napper Tandy’s locations, featuring classic American comfort food along with some special creations from the Bay Shore chef. Among those, the Brussels sprouts app, Jameson steak, and pan seared scallops entree have proven popular.
Buzzy Irish-inspired pub offering classic & creative eats, a full bar & frequent live entertainment.
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Reservations: nappertandysbayshore.com
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Napper Tandys Bay Shore, Bars in Bay Shore, Restaurants in Bay …
Napper Tandy’s Irish Pub and Catering is conveniently located on Main Street in Bay Shore, Long Island! Please join us for lunch/dinner or to watch your …
Napper Tandy’s Bay Shore (@nappertandysbayshore) – Instagram
4.5K+ followers · 843 posts · Irish Pub • Catering • Private Events • Daily Specials • Happy Hour • 20+ Draft Beers • Lunch • Dinner • DJ & Live Bands …
Napper Tandy’s Irish Pub
SMITHTOWN, NY. 15 EAST Main St, Smithtown, NY 11787. BRECKENRIDGE, CO. 110 Lincoln Ave, Breckenridge, CO 80424. BAY SHORE, NY. 60 E. Main Street Bay Shore, NY …
Last Updates
Reviews
Kirk Stroehlen
I loved it more when it was the nutty Irishman it had that room warm Irish pub feel and the upstairs now they’ve closed it off it’s not the same. I remember when that place was way bigger. I remember when it was the firehouse before the nutty Irishman.. Still trying to find an authentic Irish pub atmosphere to those of the Irish pubs of violent, and not one of them hit the mark. Couldn’t even pour a proper Guinness. Food was OK. The corn beef is that OK but to get an appetizer took a while then to get My entrée. Yes it took quite some time.. I wish one of one Main Street was still around. That was the true Irish bar in Port Jeff just before the tracks it was owned by an Irish family. The lighting was correct. The way an Irish pub should be in the atmosphere was the way an Irish pub should be.
… moreDawn D
We went in on a Saturday evening & were seated right away. Our server was amazing. He was friendly & always checking up on us getting refills. The food was delicious.
… moreMary Neftleberg
We recently hosted our company holiday party at Napper Tandy’s, and it was an absolutely fantastic experience! From start to finish, the service was impeccable—attentive, friendly, and professional. The food was a highlight of the evening, with every dish beautifully prepared, flavorful, and served promptly.
Not only was the quality of both the food and service top-notch, but the restaurant was also surprisingly affordable, making it an excellent choice for events. The ambiance added the perfect festive touch, and the staff went above and beyond to ensure everything went smoothly.
If you’re looking for a spot to host a gathering or just enjoy an outstanding meal, I highly recommend Napper Tandy’s. We’ll definitely be back!
… moreNot only was the quality of both the food and service top-notch, but the restaurant was also surprisingly affordable, making it an excellent choice for events. The ambiance added the perfect festive touch, and the staff went above and beyond to ensure everything went smoothly.
If you’re looking for a spot to host a gathering or just enjoy an outstanding meal, I highly recommend Napper Tandy’s. We’ll definitely be back!
Jessie Cookson
We had a great experience tonight. It was our first time here and it was Valentine’s Day so they had a different menu. We can’t wait to go back when we can try their regular meal. My only negative was that we did a lot of waiting but it was to be expected on a busy night.
… moreDino Sitaras
Excellent Sheppard’s pie. Grew up in Sunnyside NY so I know a good Sheppard’s pie. Ambiance is bar like it is supposed to be. Place has very good food which is why we booked 3rd party event in last few years.
… moreTara Quealy
Recently hosted an event at Napper Tandys in their back room and everything was excellent! We booked our event last minute but everyone was great and made it a night to remember. The room is pretty the food, is delicious and the staff is attentive. Kelly went above and beyond. She is the best! Our family was so happy!
… moremaria diorio
I celebrated a baby shower there and was very pleased! The food was great, the venue was perfect , and the service was fantastic! The staff was friendly and very accommodating I highly recommend this venue . Whether you plan a shower, birthday or any event… you will be vey pleased!!!
… moreVictoria Halloran
I can’t thank Brenden, Patrick and the team at Napper Tandy’s enough ! My daughters bridal shower was nothing short of amazing. The food , service and room were perfect for her special day. We received so many calls and compliments. We appreciate you all and can’t wait to book another event !
… moreEmily Devine
I cannot say enough positive things about Nappertandy’s. I looked at, what felt like, every restaurant/venue in Suffolk County to find a location for my sister’s bridal shower. Nappertandy’s by far offered the best package, and the best price. The upstairs room was so perfect. Courtney made the planning process so so so easy, I did not have to stress out about anything. They provided linens, a rattan chair for the bride, a gift table, game table, dessert table, everything. I was very worried about finding a venue that was accessible for older people/those in wheelchairs and Nappertandy’s has an elevator. The food and staff were great! Our package included a cake, we were asked what color/writing we wanted and to our (very pleasant surprise) they went out of their way to give us a beautiful (and delicious) cake that perfectly matched the bridal shower theme. I highly highly recommend hosting an event here!
… moreFranjez
The Mahi Mahi Sandwich is DELICIOUS! Napper Tandys Bay Shore is a huge property, 2 floors, front & rear outdoor areas & plenty of indoor space. The food is fresh & deliciously prepared, the staff is attentive, it’s ground floor & very spacious.
… more