Nick
Wow. Heard great things about this place and it held up to the hype. The pizza was cooked perfectly. Crusty and crunchy on the bottom and chewy at the same time. Got a slice of the square to try and it was excellent as well. Definitely in my top 10. The Italian hoagie wasn’t anything to write home about but it wasn’t bad.
… moreTodd Walters
Tonight I ordered a Sicilian pizza togo. Once I received the pizza it was a THIN crust not thick as advertised. I spoke to the male who was the manager and was told that he’s having trouble with the dough rising due to the heat and humidity. The toppings and sauce were good but the crust was hard on the outside and and struggled to cut it with a knife. The lady at the register was nice and friendly. This did not meet the expectations of a Sicilian pizza.
… moreAbraham Sultan
UPDATED 01/28/24 +Full Videos
Check out the cinematic I did for an 8-cut Sicilian pie. If you’re reheating this, does best in a Corningware for 8 min at 375F. A darn tasty pizza.
Pizza is a very personal thing. If you like an Ironborn style pizza (that place in the Strip), with a thick chewy crust that has light, stringy cheese that looks like the ones in TV commercials and light sauce, then this is for you.
This location’s been around forever. 50 years by my count, probably longer. I stopped by to get a slice of plain, and then got another. If you can, ask for a corner slice.
The plain’s done Sicilian style so it’s cut into squares.
I sat down and felt like I walked back three decades. Classic pizza shop seating, comfy space, and the smells and aromas of an ever-busy kitchen that gets good business everyday. Shades of nostalgia all day long.
The only thing that was missing was a Pac-Man arcade cabinet.
If you want cheese you can chew on, try Mineo’s in Squirrel Hill.
I went a little overboard on taking photos, but I think this place is worth a quick bite.
X-Lg Neopolitan with Pepper Rings 9/10
Their classic with banana peppers.
Very good.
Fries 4/10
Onion Rings 4/10
Garlic Bread 4/10
I got these three for the Royal Rumble along with the 18-cut Neopolitan with Pepper Rings and a 16-cut Sicilian with garlic and tomato (10/10). $83. I would definitely get the pizzas again and again. The sides?
Meh. But their pizza is definitely worth getting. Posted extra photos and videos as a separate update.
… moreJoshuah Wieland
Very nice people and a cozy atmosphere at night. Food is alright, but the crust of the pizza was a little too crunchy for my taste.
… morePhillip Irvin
Wow, what a nice surprise. We were looking for a pizza place right off 76 as we passed through PA. The food was much, much better than the 4.3 ave rating here. Everything had excellent flavor and very large portions. We will definitely stop again on future trips. Worth a visit!
… moreFloyd Barnard
In town visiting from Ohio and need a place that delivers. Do we choose Napoli pizza. The crust is a little too thin but the sauce is great and the toppings for the price could have been more. All and all not bad pizza.
… morePaul Konschak
Best square pizza I have ever eaten. Italian wedding soup and the caprese salad were also delicious. We Will definitely come back when we are in the area
… moreMs Miller (Amanda)
Stopped here today while shopping and in the area. They have a wide variety of items and a nice looking menu. Grabbed 2 slices of Sicilian pizza one with pepperoni and one with bacon. This pizza was so so so good. The girl who waited on us was very nice and the place was clean! Cute little pizza joint. They had tables for you to sit and eat. Reasonably priced. Will definitely eat again!
… moreGeoff Sachs
I ordered a Sicilian pizza the taste of it was not the same as i expected… ordered a large with 2 toppings for 28 Dollars it was dry hardly any sauce on it .. it was like they didn’t want to open a new sauce bucket , very disappointed don’t know if I will return.
… moreAngela Chambers
I drove 19 miles to the place I entered the store it definitely needs a remodel. Customer service at the counter was not good at all. I looked at my Sicilian pizza and was immediately disappointed the presentation was horrible, the crust was hard and the taste of the pizza was not good at all. I will never return to this pizza place.
… more