Nilou Yaar
The food was phenomenal. I wasn’t a big fan of the radicchio salad, as it was a little too bitter for me. We tried a sampler of their small plates, and every one of them was delicious. We enjoyed it so much. I had the sea bass, and oh my God, it was so good I couldn’t believe it.
And honestly, the best part of this restaurant is the people who work there. They are so friendly and kind that I enjoyed every minute.
… moreMatthew Van Lunen
There are very few restaurants that I go to that every single dish I order just blows me away. That is how it was at Mystico. We went for dinner and it was so good. We needed to return for lunch the following day. Staff was all super nice and helpful. Ambience was wonderful and for lunch they let us bring our dog and sit outside. I live four hours away from this restaurant and it was so good. I might have to just drive to have dinner. The focaccia is a must have and the smoked caponata they give you with it is phenomenal.
… moreJeffrey Burke
This was our 3rd time. Fantastic experience every time. The service was outstanding. Friendly and inviting. The drinks are creative and delicious. Halibut was cooked to perfection. Bolognese ravioli was the best thing I’ve eaten in a very long time. The chef’s love and passion shine.
… moreMatthew Butler
Was in town for our annual trip to Manchester and discovered this restaurant. Completely blew me away! Sat at the bar, and to our pleasant surprise the owner Luis was there and guided us through the menu , the drinks and we had a pleasant afternoon learning all about the restaurant , the food, and how expertly executed his cuisine And operation is done.
Talk about uncommon hospitality, this surpasses it.
Do not miss the antipasto board and his own creative Elixirs to mention a few highlights. We are going back for dinner tonight!
… moreAileen Creagh
10/10, for every single reason. The server was pleasant, attentive, knowledgeable, and seemed to have pride and passion for the food they serve. The place has a lovely atmosphere, decor & vibe. The bartender saw me getting uncomfortable as the sun hit my back & he came to lower the blinds behind me before I could even look for the cord. We had the limoncello spritz, tuna bowl, and porchetta panino. So beautiful, fresh and delicious. The little salad that came with that sandwich seemed to have been magically misted with lemon, olive oil & salt. Can’t wait to come back in. Thank you!
… morebrian bowden
Made a reservation for 3 people for my wife’s birthday. We ordered several appetizers and pasta entrees which were all excellent! To begin, we had the carpaccio, crudo tasting, oysters on the half shell, lobster & burrata and the cacio e pepe. For entrees we had the Amatriciana, Spaghetti with crab and the Carbonara. Everything was perfect. If I had one criticism, I would ask for the Carbonara to be a little more creamy/ saucier but that’s just a personal preference. The focaccia was out of this world. Warm, soft and flavorful with a trio of accompaniments. Our server Mara, was the perfect combination…warm, friendly and professional. Attentive but not overbearing. We live an hour away in Glens Falls, NY, but we will definitely return.
… moreEric S
Mystic is fabulous. A little gem in the heart of Southern Vermont. Fabulous food, cozy upscale atmosphere, best cocktails and wine list, and gracious service.
This place is at a whole entirely other level. So much attention to fine detail. Every single aspect of the experience was delightful
• Location: Mystic, Vermont
• Cuisine: The restaurant is known for its cozy atmosphere, offering a variety of dishes including local Vermont cuisine, seafood, and a wide selection of wines.
• Ambiance: The cafe features a charming and relaxed setting, ideal for both casual dining and special occasions.
• Specialties: They often have a menu that highlights local ingredients and seasonal dishes, with a focus on fresh and high-quality food.
… moreMary Rose
Food, ambiance, and vibe were spectacular, visiting from Boston and wish there was a place like this in beantown. Staff is passionate about the food and it makes the experience that much more exquisite. Highly recommended- some of the best bread and pasta ever. Great Italian red wine selection- a must visit in Manchester.
… morePeter Schenk
Absolutely phenomenal dining experience!
Very few restaurants can compare to the quality and atmosphere at Mystico Cucina Italiana. The food was extraordinary — perfectly prepared, beautifully presented, and bursting with authentic flavor. The service was attentive and genuinely warm, making the entire evening feel special. The atmosphere is cozy yet elegant, creating the perfect setting for a memorable meal.
I’ll definitely be back soon — truly one of the best Italian dining experiences I’ve had in a long time!
… moreXilia Faye
One of our favorite places to eat in Vermont! It’s a 3 1/2 hour drive from home but we still try to make it at least 4 times a year. We have tried nearly everything on the menu in each season and it’s all so skillfully prepared with an artistic understanding of flavor pairing and composition. You can’t go wrong with anything you order. Impeccable food, amazing drinks, and very friendly staff keeps us coming back again and again.
… more