Social Profile: 
… View more
We make Ice Cream the old-fashioned way, with a modern twist. Mystic Ice Cream is produced by spinning a scraper inside a chilled cylinder, which is filled with pure cream, sugar, and all the ingredients we remember as kids: cookies, candy, fruits, pies, chocolates, and pure vanillas. That’s the old-fashioned part. The modern “twist” is the addition of our favorite drinks and liqueurs.
Address and Contact Information
Address: Route #466A, 1217 W Miller St, Fruitland Park, FL 34731
Phone: (352) 812-1366
Website: https://mysticicecream.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Mystic Ice Cream – Adult & Premium Ice Cream in the Villages, FL
Indulge in our rich, all-natural adult ice cream flavors, including alcohol-infused options. Visit our shop or find our truck at various locations in the …
Mystic Ice Cream | Fruitland Park FL – Facebook
Mystic Ice Cream, Fruitland Park. 6481 likes · 21 talking about this · 6068 were here. * THIS IS OUR OLD PAGE – NEW PAGE IS PINNED *
Mystic Ice Cream (@mysticicecreamfl) · Fruitland Park, FL – Instagram
The Original Adult Frozen Dessert & Homemade Ice Cream. 5 Locations in Central Florida. Style’s Best of the Best, #1 on FL Ice Cream Trail.
Reviews
Rob W
What a cool place!! And they have awesome Ice Cream too! I went here today to celebrate with some customers. They have a BUNCH of neat flavors. The employees were so nice and friendly. The owner came over to visit, and was very nice as well. The icecream was AMAZING! THe atmosphere is really neat and nostalgic. We really enjoyed our time at Mystic Ice Cream today
… moreJamy
Oh my gosh! This was the most fun I’ve had in a while!! I got the cherry amaretto and Bailey’s Irish cream ice cream, my sister got a white Russian ice cream and my stepmom got the kahlua ice cream. We enjoyed our treats while listening to karaoke. What I especially loved was how supportive the audience is. It didn’t matter if you sing like an angel or were completely tone deaf, they cheered and applauded. No catcalls. ❤️ One woman had dementia and the DJ walked her up on stage and sang with her. She was so happy and it was a really sweet moment.
The decor is really something else too. It kind of defies describing so I’ve included some photos, but it’s a weird, fun mix of music and cultural nostalgia. I made sure to get a couple of their wild, tie dye tee shirts before I left.
… moreThe decor is really something else too. It kind of defies describing so I’ve included some photos, but it’s a weird, fun mix of music and cultural nostalgia. I made sure to get a couple of their wild, tie dye tee shirts before I left.
Elysium Joy
ADDITIONAL NEW MT DORA SHOP
348 N Alexander Street, Mt. Dora
Rosalie gave us the low down on this fabulous handmade icecream.
She feels like the Ambassador for this growing privately-owned chain of local creameries.
As you can see from the photos, this “sweet” little shop beckons us back to a simpler time when life was more relaxed and eating icecream was a super treat.
One absolutely wonderful feature of this delicious eatery is the ADULT Flavored icecreams.
We have traveled extensively and cannot recall anywhere we could get icecream that was liquor infused.
Rosalie will assist you in picking out a fantastic flavor combination as she did us with what tasted like a chocolate covered cherry with a kick.
Absolutely love the Mt. Dora shoppe!
… more348 N Alexander Street, Mt. Dora
Rosalie gave us the low down on this fabulous handmade icecream.
She feels like the Ambassador for this growing privately-owned chain of local creameries.
As you can see from the photos, this “sweet” little shop beckons us back to a simpler time when life was more relaxed and eating icecream was a super treat.
One absolutely wonderful feature of this delicious eatery is the ADULT Flavored icecreams.
We have traveled extensively and cannot recall anywhere we could get icecream that was liquor infused.
Rosalie will assist you in picking out a fantastic flavor combination as she did us with what tasted like a chocolate covered cherry with a kick.
Absolutely love the Mt. Dora shoppe!
Jon Hall
This eclectic ice cream store is going to be the highlight of your day. It’s great for families and fun, as they have nightly trivia games with karaoke. Check the menu and website for flavors of the month, and for events happening in the evening. The staff is knowledgeable, and offers free samples. There are flavors that are boozy, and offer a very unique option if you want something with a little kick. You won’t get drunk off of them, but they do offer an extra flavor profile.
… moreTanya Hernandez
This was our first time going to this location in Fruitland Park and they have homemade ice cream and homemade waffle cones which their ice cream was very delicious and everyday at 5:30 – 8:30 they have different events for the whole family. It has a family vibe and a older crowd and some grandparents brought their grandkids with them to sing some Karaoke and it was fun. Everyone that was there, in including the staff was very friendly the only thing I wish is that the ice cream could be a little cheaper but it was so delicious
… moreIn WNC
Mystic Ice Cream is a hidden gem! The ice cream is absolutely delicious with a variety of unique and classic flavors to choose from. The staff is incredibly friendly and welcoming, making the experience even better. Plus, the fun karaoke nights add a special touch that keeps us coming back. A perfect spot for a sweet and entertaining outing!
… moreDebbie Lemasters
This place is totally amazing. With iconic items, lots of 50’s, 60’s and 70s old memorabilia all over the walls. All the tables are decorated in the 70s era and has different games that you can sit at to play this place offers each night something for everyone to do see pictures. The ice cream is homemade with several amazing flavors and you can even have your ice cream made with alcohol.
… moreJulie Irving Fontes
This little place was so cool. They have record albums from every era and a really unique atmosphere, that really appeals to the baby boomer age. I guess they have a trivia night and a karaoke night. The ice cream is homemade and very delicious. The even offer free samples. Definitely check it out.
… moreDolore Porte
Darrell is an amazing host as are all the people serving ice cream. The Ice cream is amazing. We plan to visit all five locations. Atmosphere is also amazing.
… moreKathleen Higgins
So unique. Delicious ice cream. Regular and alcohol versions. You have to see all the memorabilia inside. I took lots of pictures. Close to Lake Griffin state park.
… more