Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 295 Nassau Blvd, Garden City South, NY 11530
Phone: (516) 408-9998
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Nassau Blvd | Hours + Location | American Restaurant in New York
My Three Sons Bagel Cafe Home. Toggle Navigation. Hours & Locations · Menus … Hours & Location. 295 Nassau Blvd, Garden City South, NY 11530 · (516) 408 …
My Three Sons Bagel Cafe | American Restaurant in New York
We pride ourselves in using only the highest quality ingredients in all of our locations to deliver the best and freshest products.
My Three Sons Bagel Café (@mythreesonsbagelcafe) – Instagram
Best Tasting Hand Rolled Bagels Anywhere! 88 Covert Ave, Stewart Manor NY 974 Franklin Ave, Garden City NY 295 Nassau Blvd, Garden City South NY …
Reviews
Trisha T
Delivery Review
I’ve been on the hunt for good bagels in Long Island bagels and this place is pretty solid. I’d heard it is good and when I saw it on Uber eats as my husband was craving bagels I decided we should give it a try!
I was excited to see they have a lox scallion cream cheese option because sliced lox with scallion cream cheese separately is expensiveeee. This was a great alternative and I added a tomato. I got that on an egg everything bagel toasted and was happy with what I got!
The bagel itself was a softer dough compared to some other places but it still had a good body to it (i.e. t didn’t deflate completely when you bite into it). There was a good bagel to cream cheese ratio and the cream cheese wasn’t bland which is something I look out for.
I would give this bagel a solid 8/10
… moreI’ve been on the hunt for good bagels in Long Island bagels and this place is pretty solid. I’d heard it is good and when I saw it on Uber eats as my husband was craving bagels I decided we should give it a try!
I was excited to see they have a lox scallion cream cheese option because sliced lox with scallion cream cheese separately is expensiveeee. This was a great alternative and I added a tomato. I got that on an egg everything bagel toasted and was happy with what I got!
The bagel itself was a softer dough compared to some other places but it still had a good body to it (i.e. t didn’t deflate completely when you bite into it). There was a good bagel to cream cheese ratio and the cream cheese wasn’t bland which is something I look out for.
I would give this bagel a solid 8/10
Anthony Savares
I typically don’t like to write negative reviews but here ya go. Ordered bagel, lox and cream cheese. Received bagel, 90-% cream cheese and a 10% lox. Give me a break. On top of that, the lox were not fresh – see the pictures that show the discoloration around the edges of the lox. In addition, the raspberry crumb bun looked great and was moist but left a bad taste of artificial sweetener in our mouths. I’d say this is the worst of the 3 bagel stores in the immediate area (A&S and the one a few blocks away). Complete ripoff, sorry never again.
AS A REPLY TO THE OWNER – the picture was 1/2 of the bagel that was purchased (for descriptive purposes) and it was a full not a mini. It was loaded with cream cheese and the lox were limited. I stand by the 90/10 %. The lox is discolored around the ends, & while the pic may lack some clarity I have no reason to say it if not true.
THE FACT THAT YOU CHOSE TO REPLY IN A MANNER THAT YOU DID (TRYING TO DISCREDIT MY EXPERIENCE) TELLS ME ALOT ABOUT YOUR BUSINESS ACUMEN & INDICATES TO ME THAT MY DECISION TO NOT SHOP HERE AGAIN IS THE CORRECT DECISION.
There are simply better local options.
… moreAS A REPLY TO THE OWNER – the picture was 1/2 of the bagel that was purchased (for descriptive purposes) and it was a full not a mini. It was loaded with cream cheese and the lox were limited. I stand by the 90/10 %. The lox is discolored around the ends, & while the pic may lack some clarity I have no reason to say it if not true.
THE FACT THAT YOU CHOSE TO REPLY IN A MANNER THAT YOU DID (TRYING TO DISCREDIT MY EXPERIENCE) TELLS ME ALOT ABOUT YOUR BUSINESS ACUMEN & INDICATES TO ME THAT MY DECISION TO NOT SHOP HERE AGAIN IS THE CORRECT DECISION.
There are simply better local options.
Seamus C
Always come for their collaborations with smoked spice bbq. Even when crazy busy with a line out the door the staff is fast, efficient, and courteous. The food is always delicious. Always a big order from my job. Keep up the great work guys!
… moreJohn Fuentes
My Three Sons Bagel Café
Sure, it’s a deli—but don’t let that fool you. My Three Sons Bagel Café runs like a well-oiled machine. Even when the place is hopping, they keep things moving with zero chaos and total confidence. You’ll be in and out with a fresh, delicious bagel before you can even check your texts.
And let’s talk about those bagels: every single one hits the mark. Fresh, flavorful, and made just how you like it. Bonus points for the fact that the person who takes your order is the same one who makes it—meaning fewer mistakes, faster service, and no sad surprises when you unwrap your sandwich.
The staff is on it. Friendly, focused, and clearly invested in getting your order right the first time. Plenty of parking, zero hassle, and none of that all-too-common “wait… this isn’t what I ordered” disappointment.
Bottom line? My Three Sons isn’t just a deli—it’s the real deal. Give them a shot, especially if you’re tired of playing deli roulette.
… moreSure, it’s a deli—but don’t let that fool you. My Three Sons Bagel Café runs like a well-oiled machine. Even when the place is hopping, they keep things moving with zero chaos and total confidence. You’ll be in and out with a fresh, delicious bagel before you can even check your texts.
And let’s talk about those bagels: every single one hits the mark. Fresh, flavorful, and made just how you like it. Bonus points for the fact that the person who takes your order is the same one who makes it—meaning fewer mistakes, faster service, and no sad surprises when you unwrap your sandwich.
The staff is on it. Friendly, focused, and clearly invested in getting your order right the first time. Plenty of parking, zero hassle, and none of that all-too-common “wait… this isn’t what I ordered” disappointment.
Bottom line? My Three Sons isn’t just a deli—it’s the real deal. Give them a shot, especially if you’re tired of playing deli roulette.
J Love
So, my review for this Nassau Blvd location is mixed. I will start with the positives. Now the taste of my food was amazing. The Brioche french toast with caramel and bananas. Like IHOP used to have this dish and it was my favorite…the Banana Foster, so I just recreated it, and Oh was I satisfied.
Now the issue here was…..I may not have been satisfied if I didn’t watch and check the people. The young lady opened my banana maybe 5-7 minutes before the French toast was ready….and flies were landing and coming back. So when the lady was about to put that old banana, I had to say No.. New banana or No banana. They cut a fresh one and solved.
The potato salad given to me as a side to my sandwich dish was a fail, but they easily replaced with a chips when it did not taste well. The sandwich was also good.
The Raspberry lemonade was delicious. So in total… I would say, I am satisfied, but maybe I will order in store always to keep an eye…and only this location do I approve. Because I tried the Covert location after and their French Toast was so dry.
Will I be back? Yes…they mastered that Banana Foster dish. Even with the hiccup, I was pleased.
… moreNow the issue here was…..I may not have been satisfied if I didn’t watch and check the people. The young lady opened my banana maybe 5-7 minutes before the French toast was ready….and flies were landing and coming back. So when the lady was about to put that old banana, I had to say No.. New banana or No banana. They cut a fresh one and solved.
The potato salad given to me as a side to my sandwich dish was a fail, but they easily replaced with a chips when it did not taste well. The sandwich was also good.
The Raspberry lemonade was delicious. So in total… I would say, I am satisfied, but maybe I will order in store always to keep an eye…and only this location do I approve. Because I tried the Covert location after and their French Toast was so dry.
Will I be back? Yes…they mastered that Banana Foster dish. Even with the hiccup, I was pleased.
Veronica Cardoza
I usually go to the Franklin Ave location for my daily breakfast since it’s close to home, but this time I needed to order breakfast for my entire medical team, so I decided to go with their catering and delivery service. From start to finish, the experience was flawless.
Patricia, the manager, was phenomenal in helping me place the order. She was upfront and honest about portions, and the pricing was exactly as listed on the catering menu online. The delivery was handled by Wilmer, who went above and beyond. He not only delivered the food but also helped set up our break room and was incredibly friendly throughout the process.
The food itself was a huge hit! Everything was fresh, perfectly portioned, and absolutely delicious. My team couldn’t stop raving about it. Honestly, if I could give this place more than five stars, I would. The quality and consistency of My Three Sons truly stand out, and no other deli compares.
I’ve already recommended them to colleagues and drug reps, and I’ll definitely be ordering from them again in the future. Thank you for always exceeding expectations!
… morePatricia, the manager, was phenomenal in helping me place the order. She was upfront and honest about portions, and the pricing was exactly as listed on the catering menu online. The delivery was handled by Wilmer, who went above and beyond. He not only delivered the food but also helped set up our break room and was incredibly friendly throughout the process.
The food itself was a huge hit! Everything was fresh, perfectly portioned, and absolutely delicious. My team couldn’t stop raving about it. Honestly, if I could give this place more than five stars, I would. The quality and consistency of My Three Sons truly stand out, and no other deli compares.
I’ve already recommended them to colleagues and drug reps, and I’ll definitely be ordering from them again in the future. Thank you for always exceeding expectations!
Perseus Barnes
i go here for breakfast every day and have never had a bad experience. the staff are friendly and polite, food is made quickly, and the pricing is not bad for the food quality. i’ve brought friends and family here and the food has held up to their standards too. the place is cleaned throughout the work day and i rarely see a messy table. i’m glad to be a regular here and will be as long as i am in the area 🙂
… moreEmily Smith
I am not somebody to write reviews because i hate negative stuff but I’ve had it:
I’ve given this place more than enough try’s to like it and get a better taste in my mouth for the individuals whom work behind the counter but i’ve truly only had one great interaction with an employee there. The woman with the black hair and tattoos is by far the most sweetest outgoing employee there. You can see she is NOT LAZY. All other employees make things up as they go and make their own rules is pathetic. Where is the owner of this business ?? It seems to be self ran by the employees themselves because this is not the same place that i knew a couple years back. It is a mess and the food is a mess. The bagels are incredible but the cooking is awful by the employees.
It’s extremely unfortunate that the employees at the nassau blvd location are lazy and cut corners resulting in terrible reviews and terrible tasting food. The audacity to ruin a businesses reputation in a wealthy & high consumer area is very sad.
My fiancé ordered a BEC and the bacon was RAW on some pieces. This is absolutely unacceptable and completely unsanitary serving people raw food. This place needs a serious revaluation and the owner needs to take charge and read how negative these reviews are before hiring employees that are lazy and get too comfortable serving half raw food and not even being able
to butter a bagel !!!! The amount of times I have ordered a bagel with butter and all i’ve tasted was bread is enough to be unable to count on both of my hands. –
This is a very fast paced business and extremely busy but that doesn’t give any employee the green light to slack in the food industry and serve uncooked raw food or not meeting the services standards that businesses 10x more busy meet on a regular basis. If you are unable to serve food meeting protocol (unless someone asks for RARE bacon) then do not take it upon yourself to serve such a things without considering potential health consequences. Ultimately if you’re unable to serve decent food when rush occurs you probably don’t belong in the food industry considering the amount of stress that comes with rushes and a fast pace environment.
To the owner – you need to reevaluate this location because it’s disgusting considering i am paying as a consumer for a great place i once loved to now throwing my breakfast in the trash because its raw and tastes terrible.
… moreI’ve given this place more than enough try’s to like it and get a better taste in my mouth for the individuals whom work behind the counter but i’ve truly only had one great interaction with an employee there. The woman with the black hair and tattoos is by far the most sweetest outgoing employee there. You can see she is NOT LAZY. All other employees make things up as they go and make their own rules is pathetic. Where is the owner of this business ?? It seems to be self ran by the employees themselves because this is not the same place that i knew a couple years back. It is a mess and the food is a mess. The bagels are incredible but the cooking is awful by the employees.
It’s extremely unfortunate that the employees at the nassau blvd location are lazy and cut corners resulting in terrible reviews and terrible tasting food. The audacity to ruin a businesses reputation in a wealthy & high consumer area is very sad.
My fiancé ordered a BEC and the bacon was RAW on some pieces. This is absolutely unacceptable and completely unsanitary serving people raw food. This place needs a serious revaluation and the owner needs to take charge and read how negative these reviews are before hiring employees that are lazy and get too comfortable serving half raw food and not even being able
to butter a bagel !!!! The amount of times I have ordered a bagel with butter and all i’ve tasted was bread is enough to be unable to count on both of my hands. –
This is a very fast paced business and extremely busy but that doesn’t give any employee the green light to slack in the food industry and serve uncooked raw food or not meeting the services standards that businesses 10x more busy meet on a regular basis. If you are unable to serve food meeting protocol (unless someone asks for RARE bacon) then do not take it upon yourself to serve such a things without considering potential health consequences. Ultimately if you’re unable to serve decent food when rush occurs you probably don’t belong in the food industry considering the amount of stress that comes with rushes and a fast pace environment.
To the owner – you need to reevaluate this location because it’s disgusting considering i am paying as a consumer for a great place i once loved to now throwing my breakfast in the trash because its raw and tastes terrible.
Faryal Chaudhry
Small shop, does not have a lot of variety of cream cheese. Ordered omelette on a roll. Spinach was not fresh at all. Didn’t chop the spinach, put the entire leaf on the omelette. Food is expensive. Service is very slow. Paid 5.97 only for the roll with omelette.
… moreMike Behman
Very slow. Very unorganized. Bagels taste good if your just getting bagels to go and have a lot of time to waste. Do not get anything prepared. They mess up orders more often then they get them correct. Here’s a pic of my bagel with not too much cream cheese. Funny…they have a sign on the counter that says due to rising cost their menu prices are going up. Maybe train your staff to take orders correctly and not waste product.
… more