Gottfried Kibelka
I know, 5 stars might be a bit much, but I was impressed by the family atmosphere, the daily specials that include an all you can eat pasta day, the value ($4.75 for a bottle of Peroni in 2026 is not bad), and the Pizza.
It’s just not my kinda dough. I like chewy, hearty crusts of the Baguette variety better than the white bread crust they are serving here. I am also a bit of a stickler when it comes to classic pies. A Margherita should represent the Italian flag, with crushed and/or fresh tomatoes, fresh mozzarella (di bufala), and whole basil leaves. The Margherita here consisted of chopped basil, a tomato sauce, and a mixture of cheeses that covered the pie. No doubt, I liked the tasty pizza, but a classic Margherita it wasn’t.
I would have liked to see some local beer on draft and if it is only to support local businesses. Still,
5 stars because it is a busy neighborhood Italian that feeds the community with a variety of Italian staples and flavorfull affordable pizza.
… morePink Queen
Has consistently gone down hill… very disappointing… uuuuhhhhhhh where’s the sauce man? Over $20 for a small and theres literally no sauce! Every time at least one thing is wrong with the pizzas. Used to be the best, now… not so much
… morevictor barmak
I have been here like 7 years ago, it’s like a family business, pizza it’s good, good one for takeout as we were in a rush, but service it’s good over there, didn’t know but they do have plates, not just pizza.
Thin and crispy crust, just on my taste was a bit too oily and missing some cheese on the Margherita side, but it’s an good option and not expensive. Atmosphere it’s good too.
… moreSean Holland
Amazing pizza, the best garlic knots I have ever had. Classic family pizzeria, the world needs more places like this.
… moreDaniel Patterson
Monty’s Pizza has been around for many years and is located in a convenient strip mall not far from my house. It’s a great spot to visit with family and friends when you’re in the mood for a quick and delicious bite. This local pizza joint offers a wide variety of tasty options, including some fun and creative specials. Their garlic bread is absolutely amazing, and the bruschetta is to die for!
… moreFriar Mike Loblein
Love Monty’s. Eat here often. The Full Monty is the best!! Garlic knots are drenched. Just a fun place to enjoy.
… moreAnnie Kalis
I’ve been in this area for approx three years and have tried numerous places for a good pizza.
Monty’s makes the Best!
Great quality and taste, give it a try you won’t be disappointed! Their spaghetti is good too! Pizza crust is northern style, not chewy and the sauce is not sweet nor salty.
Keep up the great work Monty’s crew
… moreKathy Mitchell
Our group had several dishes, ckn Parm, lasagna, spaghetti…all delicious. Loved the soft breadsticks! Great service
… moreTheresa Martin
The best spaghetti and meatballs I’ve had in a while. Reminds me of my grandmother’s. Eleonora was attentive and friendly. I came by on a recommendation and will return soon as the customers are also extremely nice.
… moreHillary Morales
We had high hopes given the great reviews and how difficult it is to find good pizza in Florida. The customer service was great, very nice on the phone and friendly when I went in the restaurant. We ordered a large Sicilian pizza. The dough and sauce were good but there was barely any cheese on the whole pizza, just a sprinkle. Literally single shreds of cheese on it. It was also more like a medium size and the pieces were cut real small. Nothing like a Northeast Sicilian. It was really disappointing especially since it cost $24. Basically sauce and dough. Still ate it because we were hungry but it was a let down.
… more