Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Hours
| Tuesday | 10:30 AM–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 10:30 AM–8 PM |
| Thursday | 10:30 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 10:30 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 10:30 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–6 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 5037 Old US Hwy 322, Milroy, PA 17063
Phone: (717) 667-3711
Website: http://www.originalitalianpizzamilroy.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Milroy Original Italian Pizza – Milroy, PA – 5037 Old US Hwy 322 …
View the menu, hours, address, and photos for Milroy Original Italian Pizza in Milroy, PA. Order online for delivery or pickup on Slicelife.com.
Milroy OIP – Original Italian Pizza | Reedsville PA – Facebook
Super Bowl Specials 2/8/26! Large 1 topping pizza for only $12.99! OR Large 1 topping pizza & 12 wings for $29.99! Pre-orders are appreciated and recommended!
Milroy Original Italian Pizza – View Menu & Order Online – Slice
Our own homemade bread butterflied and topped with garlic oil and mozzarella cheese . Served with our own red sauce. $8.63. Breaded Cauliflower. Batter dipped …
Reviews
Brenna Bubb
The Milroy OIP catered both my rehearsal dinner and recently a luncheon for Indian Valley teachers. Both were delivered and ready on time, all hassle free! Our food was set up and ready to eat. We were able to customize our own menu, even outside of the regular restaurant menu options! Staci was super flexible and worked with us to make exactly what we wanted. Both meals were amazing! Tyde and his crew are always a delight to work with! Highly recommend!
… moreMichael K
Popular Italian and pizza restaurant. Really good subs and pizza selection. Fridays are especially busy for carryout and delivery. Nice stop in Milroy on the way up to State College
… moreJohn Killeen
Staci was awesome with helping me get together a rehearsal dinner for my sons wedding. The pizza was delicious and the wings were fantastic! No one left hungry and everyone raved about how good everything was. There was even a gluten free option for pizza. Staci was there every step of the way and made sure we didn’t want for anything. I highly recommend using OIP in Milroy for your catering needs.
… moreHeidi Brady
Our first – but not last! – experience with Milroy OIP began with communication with Staci about catering a wedding in McVeytown Saturday, October 18, 2025. She accepted the opportunity with open arms and made the catering component of the wedding planning an absolute breeze! She went above and beyond from a number of aspects, and served the most delicious and beautiful buffet we could have asked for!! We thank her and the Milroy OIP mgmt for a fabulous experience, and we look forward to making the Milroy OIP our go-to when we’re at our cottage in PA. On top of that, we know we’ve made several new friends with Staci and her wonderful family! Thanks, again❣️
… moreAnthony Davis
Very good service here! I got a Stromboli special and added black olives, anchovies, tomatoes, onions and extra cheese! Yummy! I recommend visiting this place.
… moreMolly
If you are looking for a place to stop – go here! It is right off the highway and has delicious pizza. The ingredients taste so fresh – one of the best pizzas we’ve ever tried! Such friendly people as well! I would drive out of my way to come back.
… moreSteve Gomez
They were nice enough to sell me what they had left over after closing one night. Hoagies were soggy. So I gave it another try sometime later and the chicken was flavorful but dry like the pizza.
… moreVince Giordano
We look forward to getting food from the Milroy OIP every Friday night. From the pizzas (BBQ and buffalo chicken are great as well as the Big Mac) to the sandwiches and fries, you can’t go wrong with what you order. Best of all is the service. The staff greet you by name and are very welcoming. Thank you for your hard work and great food!
… moreCatherine Kauffman
Delicious food! Staci was very efficient! She went beyond expectations to make the wedding special for the Bride and Groom!
… moreDeku Marnoma
If you’re like I was debating between driving to the Burnham OIP or going here, just go to the Burnham one because the food is better. I wasn’t going to write a review as the woman at the counter was so kind, but once I got the food I was so disappointed, not to mention the 20 minute wait AFTER I had received the notification that it was ready, and I watched at least 3 other people come in and pick up orders quickly. A wait is to be expected during peak hours and I don’t fault them for that, but I ordered a HOT sub and waited 20 minutes for it to be completely COLD when I got it. It seemed like the bacon and chicken (overcooked) had been refrigerated and then just put right in the sub. The bread was good but that was about it. I asked for a side of ranch in the notes but did not get any; fries were not fresh cut, could get the same sort of taste for cheaper at a fast food restaurant to be honest. Again, staff was nice but the wait coupled with the food quality is just something I wouldn’t choose again.
… more