Address and Contact Information
Address: 34 Mill St, New Buffalo, PA 17069
Phone: (717) 834-6565
Website: https://milliespizza.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Millie’s Pizza – 34 Mill St, New Buffalo, PA 17069 | 717-834-6565 est …
We are open for dining, delivery and take out during our normal business hours and our full menu is available.
Millie’s Pizza | New Buffalo PA – Facebook
. Not yet rated (0 Reviews). . Closing Soon. . 34 Mill street , New Buffalo, PA, United States, 17069. Links. . milliespizza.com. Contact info. . (717) 834 …
Order Millies Pizza Menu Delivery in New Buffalo – Uber Eats
34 Mill St, New Buffalo, PA 17069 · Neapolitan Style Pizza. Millie’s Pan Pizza. Cheese Pizza · Pizza By The Slice. Cheese Pizza Slice · Appetizers. French Fry.
Reviews
Christian S
I’ve had Millies pizza 3 times now, the first time I was immediately surprised to find someone did their homework on how to make a proper pizza.
The ratio of dough to sauce to cheese is perfect, the crust is thin, well done on the bottom and soft in the crust. It’s everything I think of when I imagine what a pizza ought to be, coming from someone who has made their own dough for two years.
They must use good ingredients, as they don’t use the typical small pepperoni, and more than likely take their time in preparation to let the dough do its thing.
The hours are odd, and they aren’t open on Mondays and Tuesdays, however, open on Sundays.
Give it a try, i’d put it up against any pizzeria in the county, easy.
… moreThe ratio of dough to sauce to cheese is perfect, the crust is thin, well done on the bottom and soft in the crust. It’s everything I think of when I imagine what a pizza ought to be, coming from someone who has made their own dough for two years.
They must use good ingredients, as they don’t use the typical small pepperoni, and more than likely take their time in preparation to let the dough do its thing.
The hours are odd, and they aren’t open on Mondays and Tuesdays, however, open on Sundays.
Give it a try, i’d put it up against any pizzeria in the county, easy.
Melanie Ryan
Millie’s is a wonderful pizza shop that deserves all of your business. They have the best pizza crust, sauce, and toppings. This family owned shop does whatever it takes to make sure you have a wonderful meal and atmosphere.
… moreLuis Rovira
We stumbled into this place while riding our motorcycles back to VA through some awesome trails in the PA area. Family owned and operated. Everyone was very friendly and the pizza was fantastic. Spoke to the owner for a bit about motorcycles, MTB, and Drones…. Instantly felt welcome. Small-town hospitality done right.
… moreBRENDA SMITHERMAN
We ordered a large meat lovers pizza and 1 Italian sub and 1 cheeseburger sub. The delivery was faster than expected and I did not have the pizza but my son in law said it was awesome. I had the cheeseburger sub. 1st the hamburger patties were amazing tender and juicy,2nd the roll hand made and soft and delicious. This roll did NOT come out of a bag. The sub was well put together and perfectly portioned additional toppings. I have rarely enjoyed one more. The delivery driver was prompt and polite, my sub was still warm . I highly recommend this restaurant. Great job all around quality food.
… moreTalena Truitt
We have never actually eaten inside Millie’s but it’s a cute little old house right off the highway. Their dough is fantastic, we haven’t had a single thing we haven’t liked from here. But let me just say the absolute joy it brings me that they DELIVER. We live near the ferry boat campground which is 10 minutes away and it always arrives within the time (or sooner) provided. The ONLY thing I’d like to say is they don’t provide bread with salad which is just probably something I’m trained to think from other pizza shopped but no reason to take away a star. Thanks Millie’s!
… moreDaniel Dunkleberger
The pizza is amazing, the staff is friendly, the place is clean and decorated nice. My new favorite pizza shop.
… moreCLINT Sanchez
The delivery young man is very pleasant helpful and kind. REALLY GOOD TO HAVE GREAT PEOPLE SERVICE
… moreMarieA
The reason for only 2 stars is because my sub didn’t looks like a sub lettuce, tomato, onion everything, I open it and had this white stuff looked disgusting, took off , the second this is my pizza wasn’t done , greasy as all hell I asked for oregano didn’t get that the prices are already high so my food should be the way I want it ,should look great and taste delicious not this time very sad
… moreLloyd Jones
We got a seasonal site at riverfront campground, and Millie’s was highly recommended by some long term residents. The great thing is they deliver directly to the campsite, and you don’t have to worry about them finding you. They also take cards upon delivery. We’ve been ordering all season, and the owner surprised us with a little gift, can’t beat the service, and the pizza is always hot and fresh. If you’re staying on the juniata river side, Millie’s is definitely a must try! Definitely makes it easy when you don’t feel like cooking!
… more2fst4u wAgone
I’ve been getting food from Millie’s for about 10 years now. The food is always excellent. Once in a while there’s a small mistake but considering they help the young community by employing some kids as their first time job, I can see past it. All in all this place is a must if you’re in the area or even passing through.
… more