Julie Conway
Mike’s Pizza never disappoints! It’s the perfect meal to pick up after a day on a boat. We had it several times during our 3 week stay last year and couldn’t wait to go back. Got a large pepperoni and Italian sausage pizza and a salad. Perfect!
… moreDavid Chambers
Wonderful food, welcoming family atmosphere, this vibrant busy little restaurant became a staple on our trip. If you’re looking for fresh salad while on Exuma Mike’s has got you covered. Over our trip we mixed and matched a lot of the menu always with a great salad. Always nice to find the little gems where people pour their love into the food they share. Many thanks for the fantastic eats.
… moreMike Metcalf
Had a garden salad and we got a pepperoni pizza and a sausage with onion pizza. Will venture to say it’s the best on the island. Was tasty. Family run joint. Mike is a great guy and his family is nice. Will return and recommend you give him your business too. Eat in carry out or he says he delivers.
… moreMariama Wood
I always visit the restaurant and the food is great. Last night Chef Mike catered a 3 course dinner at our Airbnb and the food was amazing. We had a yummy pecan crusted salad, curry lobster, vegetables, the best roasted potatoes ever. We also had a Bahamian inspired dish of roasted chicken and mushrooms, peas and rice, and Mac and cheese. Brownies and ice cream for desert. Service was wonderful!! Will definitely use Chef Mike again.
… moreMarc Eberhart
Very good pizza, great wings. Mike is a wonderful man and his staff are too. I love everything about this place. Looking forward to exploring more of the menu.
… moreWandering Knapps aboard MV Illuminate
Best pizza in the Bahamas. We ate the cheese, meat, and veggy. So delicious. Perfectly crunchy bottom and soft crust. The veggy the sauce is the best I’ve ever had, I’m from the states. Mike is a great host, loves to make sure you are enjoying yourself and he knows everything about the island. Must stop here.
… moreTerry Christofferson
Best pizza on the island and price is very reasonable. We ate there twice while in Exuma. If it was up to me I would have ate there more often. Staff is great!
… moreTyler
Very friendly service and delicious pizza. We just arrived from TX and needed a quick meal. They even stayed late to finish cooking our order. (Thanks again!)
We enjoyed every type we tried and will likely be back!
… moreDez G
Nice spot, pizza is good- average, but nothing special. Staff wasn’t bad but not particularly friendly. Inside is clean. Seems like most people order already but we only waiting about 15 minutes. $40 for 1 small 2 topping and 1 medium 3 topping pizzas.
… moreRonda Stede
We went there expecting a quick, easy meal, and once we placed the order, we were told it would be 30 minutes to cook. So we placed an order for fries to munch on while we waited. We were the only ones in the restaurant and only noticed a couple of call-in orders while we waited. The pizza smelled amazing as it was cooking, but when it arrived, it was so greasy and had a much different taste than we anticipated. The cheese was super oily, and there was minimal pizza sauce. We were overall very disappointed in the flavor profile, and after it cooled off was even worse, leaving a film of grease on top of the pizza. If you’re going there, order in advance and be prepared for it to taste drastically different than in the US.
… more