Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Classic pizzas, pastas & hot Italian subs whipped up in modest quarters with booths & tables.
Hours
| Wednesday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 3919 New Bern Ave, Raleigh, NC 27610
Phone: (919) 250-0700
Website: http://www.mikespizzanc.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Menu – Mike’s NY Pizza
Mike’s NY Pizza Menu – Authentic New York style pizza, Italian cuisine, sandwiches, and more!
Mike’s NY Pizza – Italian Restaurant, Sandwich, Dinner
Mike’s NY Pizza, Italian Restaurant, Sandwich, Dinner.
Mike’s NY Pizza | Raleigh NC – Facebook
Mike’s NY Pizza is Near You and Ready to Serve 3919 New Bern Ave, Raleigh, NC 27610 (919) 250-0700 Come and try it · Mike’s NY Pizza is Near …
Reviews
Robert Dixey
Overall Rating: 8.8/10
A welcoming spot known for serving up some of Raleigh’s best traditional cheese pizza.
Service / Atmosphere: 8.1
The staff are friendly, and the place is kept clean. A notable touch is how they refrigerate grated Parmesan cheese to ensure it’s fresh when served with the pizza.
Food:
Traditional Cheese Pizza: 9.1
Currently holding the top spot in Raleigh for cheese pizza. It’s cooked to perfection with a crispy crust and a delicious sauce. Definitely a must-try.
Steak and Cheese Sub: 8.8/10
This sub stands out as the best steak and cheese offering in Raleigh, featuring a perfectly toasted roll packed with the right amount of steak. The combination of yellow and white cheese adds a unique flavor profile. A bit more seasoning and a splash of house sauce could push this sub into even higher ratings.
Value: 8.8
At $32 for a large pizza, a sub, two drinks, and the experience of dining in a pleasant area, the price represents great value for the quality received. Money well spent.
… moreA welcoming spot known for serving up some of Raleigh’s best traditional cheese pizza.
Service / Atmosphere: 8.1
The staff are friendly, and the place is kept clean. A notable touch is how they refrigerate grated Parmesan cheese to ensure it’s fresh when served with the pizza.
Food:
Traditional Cheese Pizza: 9.1
Currently holding the top spot in Raleigh for cheese pizza. It’s cooked to perfection with a crispy crust and a delicious sauce. Definitely a must-try.
Steak and Cheese Sub: 8.8/10
This sub stands out as the best steak and cheese offering in Raleigh, featuring a perfectly toasted roll packed with the right amount of steak. The combination of yellow and white cheese adds a unique flavor profile. A bit more seasoning and a splash of house sauce could push this sub into even higher ratings.
Value: 8.8
At $32 for a large pizza, a sub, two drinks, and the experience of dining in a pleasant area, the price represents great value for the quality received. Money well spent.
A Ali
Food was good but I got the 7.99 combo and one small buffalo pizza and the total came out to $38? You’re telling me one small buffalo pizza is almost $29? Feels like they made up a price or tried to scam bc when I was going to order the exact same thing but with one more pizza it was $51. Wont come back just bc of that
… moreAnna Slawter
Mike’s is a great pizza place. The only issue I had with the pizza was it was a little wet but I believe that is because the ingredients are so fresh. We had a supreme pizza with lots of veggies on it. The food tastes excellent! The restaurant itself is in an older building, and so it has the older pizza place vibe. I did notice a sign saying they would be closed between May 8-26, 2025.
… moreGina Marie
Not the quality I expected for $40!! The vegetable toppings were still raw and just strewn about on top; picking up a slice, and they all fall off, not to mention it was warm at best.. the pepperoni pizza upon picking it up (carryout) though, was still steaming out the box. Dishing it was a different story, like pepperoni soup pizza.
Had high hopes and completely fell flat.
… moreHad high hopes and completely fell flat.
Tyler Glover
I Love pizza and am a critic for it to be perfect… crust is nice and crispy and the flavor of the sauce is great. No flop when you pick up and the slices are big. Love getting the lunch special!
… moreCorban Robinson
The pizza itself was good but not mind-blowing, I thought the crust had a great chew to it.
But I don’t do business with cheaters so I won’t be going back not can I recommend.
I ordered the large (18″) and was given a medium. I measured it in front of them. The response was “well that’s what you ordered.” The pizza barely fits in the box and I saw no larger boxes so maybe if you dine in you will get 18″ but anything to-go they will not give you what you order. And that size is a significant difference, I’ll even be generous and say my pizza was 16″ which is 201 square inches vs 18″ pizza which is 254 which is a significant difference.
… moreBut I don’t do business with cheaters so I won’t be going back not can I recommend.
I ordered the large (18″) and was given a medium. I measured it in front of them. The response was “well that’s what you ordered.” The pizza barely fits in the box and I saw no larger boxes so maybe if you dine in you will get 18″ but anything to-go they will not give you what you order. And that size is a significant difference, I’ll even be generous and say my pizza was 16″ which is 201 square inches vs 18″ pizza which is 254 which is a significant difference.
Or Goldhorn
Amazing pizza! The crust was crispy, the ingredients super fresh, and the flavors rich and delicious. We enjoyed every bite! The staff was also very friendly and welcoming. Highly recommend!
… moreJeffrey Terrill
The pizza is great, one of the better options in Raleigh for NY style pizza. Surely a top ten option in the area. Eat it fresh. If you carry it all the way home it won’t be as crisp as it is straight from the oven. The owners are friendly and provide great service, too.
… moreMichael Boughman
Used to order from here all the time with DoorDash, seems every I try to order since they dropped DoorDash, they seem aggregated by a call in order. Such a shame. Loved this place, yes past tense. I’m moving on as they’ve lost all convenience and seem to be annoyed with a call in order for pickup. I guess they have enough business to not need new customers. Such a shame.
… moreAndrea Breazeale
I drive past this spot all the time and decided to stop in. Im glad I did, the baked spaghetti was delicious!! I will be going back!
… more