Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Midtown Pizza of Middletown – Middletown, PA – 442 E Main St …
Order Hours About. 10:30 AM-8:00 PM; Shop address is 442 E Main St, Middletown, PA 17057442 E Main St, Middletown, PA 17057; (717) 702-6175.
Midtown Pizza Middletown – Facebook
Midtown Pizza Middletown, Middletown. 450 likes · 176 were here. 440 E Main StMidtown Pizza 440 E. Main St. Middletown, PA 17057(717) 944-2195Check out…
Reviews
David Mullin
Showed up a little early, allowed me to wait inside where it’s warm(20° outside). Had a slice of fresh cheese pizza, it was delicious. Had the 1/4lb bacon burger, it was the best burger I’ve had in months!
… moreB Walters
The inside of this restaurant was bigger than it looks from the outside. The food we ordered was pretty good as well as the price. We were able to order via the lunch special…quite a bit of food for the price especially nowadays. My half Italian sub n fries w/drink was pretty good. He ordered a breaded chicken sandwich also w/ fries n drink….although his fries were cold but they replaced them with no problem . The staff were very accommodating. The only thing missing was some background music it was fairly quiet. We’ll definitely be back .
… moreAmanda Keller
Stopped in for the first time and we-ordered a toasted ham and cheese sub and Italian sub. The food wow. The toaster sub was perfectly toasted and didn’t cut up my mouth as i bite into. Flavors are amazing. Music I don’t know what there say but it sounds good too.. $17 for 2 subs not bad at all
… moreCharisse Morrell
I really tried to give the benefit of the doubt to this place, but I should have paid attention to the reviews. I notice now that most of the 5 star reviews are 2 or 3 sentences long – a good tip off that they’re not real.
I ordered the fettuccine Alfredo off the Build Your Own Pasta section. The sauce tasted like olive oil and milk (and that’s pretty much what it looked like as well). The chicken was thin, dry, and chewy.
The service wasn’t awful but wasn’t anything special. The best part of the meal was the bread that came with any entree.
I ate a couple bites and didn’t take it home with me. It just really really wasn’t good. Generally I’d give a place another chance and order something different, but based off the reviews, it sounds like everything is just as bad as the pasta. And $16?! That’s with no beverages or dessert or anything. Sheesh.
I won’t be back.
… moreI ordered the fettuccine Alfredo off the Build Your Own Pasta section. The sauce tasted like olive oil and milk (and that’s pretty much what it looked like as well). The chicken was thin, dry, and chewy.
The service wasn’t awful but wasn’t anything special. The best part of the meal was the bread that came with any entree.
I ate a couple bites and didn’t take it home with me. It just really really wasn’t good. Generally I’d give a place another chance and order something different, but based off the reviews, it sounds like everything is just as bad as the pasta. And $16?! That’s with no beverages or dessert or anything. Sheesh.
I won’t be back.
Hasan Ahmad
Really wanted to like this place but half their menu advertised outside and on menu table was not available permanently. Also a relatively straight forward mushroom
And cheese burger was taking over 20-25 minutes because of an issue with the cook . Not acceptable
… moreAnd cheese burger was taking over 20-25 minutes because of an issue with the cook . Not acceptable
Monica Rivera
Quality of the food is great. The service is great. They will go above and beyond to meet your expectations with the meals and service. Family friendly atmosphere. Will come here again and definitely recommend.
… moreSimply A Peach
Traveling and stopped in to order a pizza for take out and the staff was super nice and very courteous. I loved their onion rings and the crust on the pizza was delicious
… moremaximilian torres
Me and my girlfriend went to the Hozier concert in Hershey and stopped in for a little lunch before the event. Midtown pizza exceeded my expectations in a small Italian restaurant. We ordered garlic knots, chicken parmesean sub, meatball sub and fries. The garlic knots were small but came with 9 and were buttery and garlicky, the meatball sub was good and as was the chicken parmesan sub. The bread on the sandwiches really made it special. Though we didn’t go to the bar, but we dined in, the food came out in good time and the service was good. I recommend for those looking for a quick bite and the prices aren’t outrageous.
… moreDarren Royer
Why even order toppings if they’re going to be this cheap with them. Pizza is either under baked or there’s half the amount of toppings that any other pizza shop would put on. Plus no delivery until after 5 and nobody to tap a pint of beer ad dinner time on a Saturday…. Place is in the weeds!
… moreRyan Allen
Chicken Cordon Bleu disgusting made with old shredded chicken and bad mayo wouldn’t give a refund or make it correctly
… more