Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Simple, family-run Italian joint serving New York-style pizzas, pastas & subs from a counter.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 145 Palm Bay Rd NE Suite 116, West Melbourne, FL 32904
Phone: (321) 953-8488
Website: http://www.michellispizza.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Michelli’s Pizzeria: Michelli’s Pizzeria | Lunch, Dinner | West …
Fresh ingredients paired with a passion for pizza and pasta make Michelli’s Pizzeria … 145 Palm Bay Road NE • West Melbourne, FL 32904. | 321-953-8488 |. Home …
Michelli’s Pizzeria | West Melbourne FL – Facebook
. 94% recommend (326 Reviews) ; . Open now ; . 145 Palm Bay Rd NE, West Melbourne, FL, United States, 32904-8601 …
michellis_web | Michelli’s Pizzeria
145 Palm Bay Road NE. West Melbourne, FL 32904. We Deliver! DIRECTIONS 321-953-8488 · Menu · Specials · Order Now; MoreHide. Reviews · Location & Hours.
Reviews
Brian & Nicole Love
Update – Walking into this pizzeria, the aroma alone is incredible-and the food absolutely lives up to it.
I called in to place an order and Amber was so pleasant, patient, and knowledgeable about the entire menu. Even though she was clearly busy, I never felt rushed or brushed off, which was very refreshing. I had a discount, and her manager, Ellien, came over to help. She was incredibly kind and patient, walking Amber through everything step by step- it was genuinely nice to see such a positive, teachable moment between staff.
Great team, great atmosphere, and the food never disappoints.
☆☆☆
Delicious and Worth the Return!
Stopped in to grab food to go for dinner after not visiting in quite a while—and wow, it did not disappoint!
We ordered the baked ziti, spaghetti and meatballs, and everything was packed with flavor. The meatballs were huge and delicious, and the sauce had great depth—definitely not watered down sauces like most places. The garlic rolls were super fresh and garlicky (in the best way), and the salads were fresh and crisp. The caprese salad was especially impressive—large portion and super fresh ingredients.
There are several tables for indoor seating, plus a wall-side table for extra space. The music wasnt terribly loud – making it easy to hear anotjer person. The menu has a great variety, and everything we tried was fresh and absolutely delicious.
Can’t wait to go back!
… moreI called in to place an order and Amber was so pleasant, patient, and knowledgeable about the entire menu. Even though she was clearly busy, I never felt rushed or brushed off, which was very refreshing. I had a discount, and her manager, Ellien, came over to help. She was incredibly kind and patient, walking Amber through everything step by step- it was genuinely nice to see such a positive, teachable moment between staff.
Great team, great atmosphere, and the food never disappoints.
☆☆☆
Delicious and Worth the Return!
Stopped in to grab food to go for dinner after not visiting in quite a while—and wow, it did not disappoint!
We ordered the baked ziti, spaghetti and meatballs, and everything was packed with flavor. The meatballs were huge and delicious, and the sauce had great depth—definitely not watered down sauces like most places. The garlic rolls were super fresh and garlicky (in the best way), and the salads were fresh and crisp. The caprese salad was especially impressive—large portion and super fresh ingredients.
There are several tables for indoor seating, plus a wall-side table for extra space. The music wasnt terribly loud – making it easy to hear anotjer person. The menu has a great variety, and everything we tried was fresh and absolutely delicious.
Can’t wait to go back!
Kristina Brower
Wonderful experience!! The service was fantastic (as always)- Eileen and Amber were so sweet to my little one. They were friendly, fast and welcoming. I picked up takeout and even after a 25 minute drive home the food was still hot and fresh, which really says a lot about the quality and care they put into their food. They even had a delivery driver help me walk out to my car. All the dishes tasted amazing and was perfectly cooked. Stuffed shells, baked ziti and fettuccine Alfredo and garlic knots. Michellis truly goes above and beyond. Highly recommend anyone looking for great food and excellent service.
… moreangelica vazquez
The food was delicious! Service was excellent super friendly and fast. Came in for lunch, lunch specials had a good variety, fair pricing and big portions. Seating is a little cramped. All in all I would recommend trying this place.
… moreKimberly Kenton
1st time ordering their pizza. Online order delivery time was not accurate. When you open the app to check progress, time changed from 7:41pm to 9pm. Called to check, they said “online is an hour 40 out! And the app changes the time. “
Delivery just shy of 8pm when ordered at 6pm.
16” Pizza was hot but mushy.
Crust was disappointing.
At $38 with tax, delivery and 15% tip-
Do not recommend.
… moreDelivery just shy of 8pm when ordered at 6pm.
16” Pizza was hot but mushy.
Crust was disappointing.
At $38 with tax, delivery and 15% tip-
Do not recommend.
JB
I am all in favor of supporting my local pizzerias and I understand the cost of everything is up but the prices here have become a bit unreasonable if not abusive I ordered a med.cheese with ham and pineapple along with 5 wings it came up to $30.89…. l went to John’s…. Got a large 5 topping for $18 with tax included.
It’s your business and you are entitled to do as you please but my advise to the owner is this sometimes you have to pause and go back to basics and remind myself how I got here# the customer!
Get back to reasonable and fair prices or lose a loyal customer I can only speak for myself.
… moreIt’s your business and you are entitled to do as you please but my advise to the owner is this sometimes you have to pause and go back to basics and remind myself how I got here# the customer!
Get back to reasonable and fair prices or lose a loyal customer I can only speak for myself.
Scott Troi
The three of us dined in. It was a Sunday evening, they weren’t super busy. We grabbed a table and and sat down. Eileen was our server. She did a great job and had a good sense of humor. The atmosphere was really great and we were laughing a lot having a good time.
It’s a pretty place and the food was really good. I liked the cheesy garlic bread a lot and that was eaten right away (by me of course!) I didn’t want to share it was really good. . For my main meal I had the alfredo sauce pizza and I made a Hawaiian out of it by adding ham bacon and pineapple. The sauce for that pizza was really good.
As we were sitting I saw people doing takeout so they do that too. So that’s also an option.
Anyway there was really delicious food, a great atmosphere and I enjoyed my time here.
… moreIt’s a pretty place and the food was really good. I liked the cheesy garlic bread a lot and that was eaten right away (by me of course!) I didn’t want to share it was really good. . For my main meal I had the alfredo sauce pizza and I made a Hawaiian out of it by adding ham bacon and pineapple. The sauce for that pizza was really good.
As we were sitting I saw people doing takeout so they do that too. So that’s also an option.
Anyway there was really delicious food, a great atmosphere and I enjoyed my time here.
Shiva
Tonight, I visited Michelli’s Pizzeria, and to be honest, the interior design wasn’t anything fancy. It has more of a casual, laid-back vibe. Based on the staff’s recommendation, we ordered the supreme pizza, but it took over 30 minutes to arrive. When it finally came out, it was huge—more than enough for three people—but unfortunately, the taste didn’t stand out. It wasn’t bad by any means, just kind of average. It was, well, just pizza.
One thing I did appreciate, though, was how welcoming and friendly the staff were. They had a lot of customers, which was nice to see, but overall, I don’t think I’d go back again.
… moreOne thing I did appreciate, though, was how welcoming and friendly the staff were. They had a lot of customers, which was nice to see, but overall, I don’t think I’d go back again.
James Lee
Update: When I had called Michellis that same night, I was left on hold forever. However, I just received a phone call from the restaurant apologizing for my experience. She acknowledged my issues and said she’d make it right. Not necessary, but certainly appreciated. Every restaurant goes through a tough night occasionally. To reach out to a customer is the sign of a great restaurant. We’ll be back.
Sorry guys. You used to be my favorite. Today I ordered, and the girl taking my order couldn’t have been any more clueless. Placed me on hold 5 times. I asked about getting 1/4 sausage on my pizza and she asked me if that was more than a half. I explained it to her, but it didn’t stick. Asked for no onions on my salad, got onions. Ordered no olives on my salad, got olives. Asked for my pizza to be well done, it was basically raw. Asked for delivery time. I was told an hour, I called back after an hour and 45 minutes. Finally showed up 2 hours from when I ordered. Don’t take this the wrong way. I think you’re great, but this time it was a huge fail. Put someone answering the phone that can actually follow instructions and knows fractions.
… moreSorry guys. You used to be my favorite. Today I ordered, and the girl taking my order couldn’t have been any more clueless. Placed me on hold 5 times. I asked about getting 1/4 sausage on my pizza and she asked me if that was more than a half. I explained it to her, but it didn’t stick. Asked for no onions on my salad, got onions. Ordered no olives on my salad, got olives. Asked for my pizza to be well done, it was basically raw. Asked for delivery time. I was told an hour, I called back after an hour and 45 minutes. Finally showed up 2 hours from when I ordered. Don’t take this the wrong way. I think you’re great, but this time it was a huge fail. Put someone answering the phone that can actually follow instructions and knows fractions.
Tone Ortiz
1ST I see dirty tables and bugs in the floor then I paid close to $12 for 2 slices and a soda. I gave it a shot anyways and no way in hell those 2 slices are worth $10. Didn’t even taste good it was mediocre at best. Not even Johns Cafè in Elizabeth NJ is this expensive and they’ve been open since 1968. They so good that the NY Mets and Knicks orders from them. And you can get 2 slices of REAL pizza and a soda for $7 in JERSEY!!!! This place should sell $1 slices at best. And CLEAN UP THE FILTH IF YOUR GONNA CHARGE THAT MUCH… I THOUGHT I WAS AT YANKEE STADIUM WITH THISE PRICES
… moreDustin
Eric the owner is awesome. Eileen the server was awesome. Great pizza. Great food from the opinion of a NYer. Pizza on point!! Don’t abuse this knowledge but you can bring a beer in there and enjoy since they don’t have beer and wine license. Don’t take advantage of that please. I only had 2. Lol. 8.2 on the Dave portnoy scale. We’ll done Eric and Eileen. I will be back!!
… more