Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
* Welcome to Michelangelo Southold Pizzeria and Restaurant …
Welcome to Michelangelo Southold Pizzeria and Restaurant * 53345 Main Road Southold NY 11971 * 631-765-0300. MICHELANGELO TAKE OUT MENU …
Michelangelo’s of Southold – Facebook
53345 Main Road, Southold, NY, United States, 11971. Services. . Specialties. Outdoor seating · Dine-in · In-store pickup · Takeout · Reservations. Contact …
Michelangelo’s of Southold (@southold_michelangelos) – Instagram
586 Followers, 106 Following, 35 Posts – Michelangelo’s of Southold (@southold_michelangelos) on Instagram: “631-765-0300”
Reviews
Michael Tillman
Our group of ten, all enjoyed the service, delicious food and ambiance of this resturant. Our server was excellent providing us with great recommendations. There is a seperate area for pizza, which was busy while we ate in the main, more formal dining area.
… moreSam Root
This Long Island Italian restaurant was a spontaneous stop after a fishing trip. The service was solid, and the food arrived fast.
I ordered classic spaghetti and meatballs with a side of sausage. The pasta was perfectly cooked, and the meatballs were huge. The sausage was tasty, but I was too stuffed to finish it. The calamari appetizer was also well-prepared.
Prices were reasonable for Long Island, New York. If you’re craving Italian, it’s a solid choice.
… moreI ordered classic spaghetti and meatballs with a side of sausage. The pasta was perfectly cooked, and the meatballs were huge. The sausage was tasty, but I was too stuffed to finish it. The calamari appetizer was also well-prepared.
Prices were reasonable for Long Island, New York. If you’re craving Italian, it’s a solid choice.
Karitas Mitrogogos
On a sunny day last week (June), a friend and I dropped by for slices of delish pepperoni pizzas …. however, I also couldn’t resist trying one of their garlic knots that I enjoyed even more! The place’s outdoor seating area is also pleasant with its many colorful pot plants & flowers.
… morecharles F.
This review only applies to the dining room. Food was kinda bland. It was all prepared very nicely and cooked perfectly, just kinda light in the seasoning. Prices were on the higher side but worth the portions and service given. Dining room was clean and employees were polite. Restrooms are clean too. Definitely will be back to try again! More flavor
… moreJohn T
We’ve made several visits here while visiting the area. The food, service and atmosphere are constantly good. This visit we enjoyed eggplant parmesan, eggplant rotini, and spaghetti with meatballs. The red sauce is excellent on all of these plates. The bread basket and included salad were very good as well. We recomnended.
… moreSteven Georgiadis
The interior of the building was nice. The waitress took a little long to get our orders. The calamari was really tender and the marinara sauces were perfectly made. The chicken parmesan was really good to. They also made extremely delicious bread rolls. The portion sizes are also exactly what I wanted.
… moreJoyce Culver
Michaelangelos is an excellent restaurant with great food, service, and waitresses. Try the eggplant parm or chicken franchaise. I am a cook and aware of food and taste.
So I enjoy this restaurant. A local restaurant that is not into “designer” food. The pizza is delicious. Stay away on big weekends, as it gets busy.
… moreSo I enjoy this restaurant. A local restaurant that is not into “designer” food. The pizza is delicious. Stay away on big weekends, as it gets busy.
Jeremiah
I like this place a lot. The people there are friendly and actually very creative with their slices. Upside down Sicilian is really good. I didn’t take a picture of that but should have!
I’ve never eaten in the restaurant side. It does look very nice as well though so rest assured you would be comfortable.
… moreI’ve never eaten in the restaurant side. It does look very nice as well though so rest assured you would be comfortable.
Paul Mallia
Great Italian food restaurant worth visiting if you’re heading out to eastern Long Island. Food and atmosphere are great, and never have any complaints about the dishes. Sometimes gets very busy so service can be a bit delayed, but if you’re looking to relax and have a nice meal, this is the place. Specials are always great as well and there is plenty of parking. Clams oreganta and calamari arrabiata appetizers are excellent, worth trying. Will keep returning!
… moreStephen Wong
Good clean pizza. Crust is nicely made never burned. Pasta was nicely sauced and flavorful. Friendly local fixture for consistent food. Prices are reasonable enough for locals to be regulars.
… more