Hours
| Sunday | 12–9 PM |
| Monday (Labor Day) | 12–9 PM Hours might differ |
| Tuesday | 4–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 4–9 PM |
| Thursday | 4–9 PM |
| Friday | 12–9 PM |
| Saturday | 12–9 PM |
Menu
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Meatballs Pizzeria |
A family meatball recipe carried Karen Martar from New York to the mountain town of Sylva, where she opened the aptly named Meatballs in 1983.
Our Story | Meatballs Pizzeria
Our story hails from a wild Italian woman who changed a town forever. A family meatball recipe carried Karen Martar from New York to the mountain town of Sylva, …
Slice of the dream: New Sylva pizzeria comes full circle
Meatballs Pizzeria is located at 414B West Main St. in Sylva. Hours of operation are noon to 9 p.m. Friday through Monday and 4-9 p.m. Tuesday …
Reviews
Aaron Cranford
I have a very high standard for pizza. We stopped in for some slices. They were flavorful and a generous size. I’m not a fan of the amount of cheese as well as how much they melt the ingredients into the cheese. Also, the crust was just a little burnt in some spots. The peanut butter pie was very good.
… moreWestley Strellis
Delicious pizza! I had the meatball pizza. The sauce was popping with fresh flavor, the cheese was great, the crust was tender with sour dough aromas, and the meatballs were awesome too. I will definitely be back.
… moreAreej Abdulwahab
The lady was super nice and friendly. I had two pizza and I like the truffle pizza ( fungi) but my mom loved Norma pizza .
… moreSteven Grady
Unfortunately very mediocre. The flavor was bland, the pepperonis are the big ones and cooked under the cheese, and the sauce seemed to be watered down. I actually added salt to my pizza to try to bring the flavor out.
… moreRich Carstensen
I was passing through Friday evening and was looking for a place to eat before continuing home. I found this wood fired pizza place and thought I’d give it a shot.
… moreza flores
my review pics are NOT for meatball’s pizza. it was for the place that existed here before. meatball’s must have carried over the google reviews from the last place. the old place had better flavor and MUCH better prices. meatball’s is okay enough but pricey.
… moreGinger Brew
Been here 3 times since it opened and have loved everything. Got the daily special calzone last night and it was awesome. Will keep coming back!
… moreGina T.
Friendly staff, great wood fired pizza and hand crafted cocktails. Plenty of seating inside and out. Cold beer on tap as well as craft non-boozy sodas.
… moreAmy Williams
This was quite literally the best pizza I’ve eaten in a very long time!! The crust is perfect, not too thin and not too thick with just the right amount of crispy woodfire! I got the apple pizza and my husband got the spicy Italian, both were fantastic!! They did take about 20 to 25 minutes to get to the table but the service was great! The staff is along the super laid back crowd but by no means we’re they rude or inattentive. We just went next door to the microbrewery and had a beer out on the deck overlooking the creek while we waited. I got the apricot peach pale and it was very tasty!! The brewery offers tasting generously. I’m gonna be dreaming about this pizza when we go home! The music was good and not too loud. The bathrooms could surely use a deep cleaning inside the brewery but they do have hand sanitizer all around. The parking is limited. I highly recommend these two places for a relaxing lunch and some good chatting with friends!
… moreVampy Alyssa
So the menu online has different prices than the actual menu at the restaurant. Online it says a pepperoni pizza is $15 but I was charged $28 at the restaurant. Overall the cheese sticks was pretty good but the pizza was really disappointing for the price and the size isn’t that big at all. The crust was a bit burnt and there wasn’t much flavor to the sauce. I could have spent $10 less at Mad Batter and gotten a bigger and more flavorful pizza with some garlic fries too.
… more