Mayflower Seafood Restaurant Greenville

  4.2 – 2,083 reviews  $$ • Seafood restaurant

Social Profile:

Mayflower Seafood in Winterville is the top destination for all your seafood needs. We have the best food and an amazing staff that are ready to handle all your needs. We have been in the seafood business for over 30 years and have perfected the process of bringing the best products to you and your family in a timely and efficient manner. We look forward to seeing you soon here at our Winterville location

Health and Safety:  Staff get temperature checks · Staff required to disinfect surfaces between visits · 


Hours might differ

Address and Contact Information

Address: 136 Davenport Farm Rd, Winterville, NC 28590

Phone: (252) 321-6188



Photo Gallery

Related Web Results

Mayflower Seafood Winterville

Mayflower Seafood in Winterville is the top destination for all your seafood needs. We have the best food and an amazing staff that are ready to handle all …

MENU | mysite – Mayflower Seafood Winterville

Use tab to navigate through the menu items. APPLY HERE. apps.jpg. DailySpec.jpg. errydaySpeci.jpg. ©2023 by


Mayflower Seafood Restaurant, Winterville: See 49 unbiased reviews of Mayflower Seafood Restaurant … Air U Trampoline Park & Party Center of Greenville NC.

Reviews & Complaints

Brian Ingle
We are new to Greenville North Carolina. we just moved here last November. this was our first visit to the Mayflower seafood restaurant. I grew up on good seafood in South Carolina. This is a definite oldie but goodie restaurant. The seafood is fresh, with a calabash style. The service was awesome. for this quality of food I was surprised at such the reasonable prices. even with the restaurant having a full bar liquor license. The bar didn’t seem to be in operation. There was a Very nice family feel. The restaurant even had 60s and 70s music playing, and not very loud so you could still be able to hear each other talk at your table. i’m hoping to Mayflower seafood restaurant Will be in business for many years to come. We will certainly be frequent customers.
… more
Hunter Taylor (smokylemon14)
The food was decent here, ive never really had anything too bad although at my last trip i tried something new, i got the fried captain Smiths combo with greenbeans and french fries, the combo comes with a nice amount of popcorn shrimp, dome oysters, some scallops, a deviled crab, and a pice of flounder. I dont have many complaints other then the deviled crab was salty and the greenbeans had no flavor, they wernt seasoned and by the taste they wernt salted or peppered, i had to do thst myself which isnt too bad, it alowed me to pick how much i wanted but still a little something would help them. I do have one more complaint though, the fried flounder was very thin and very very crunchy, there was alot of just fried batter on the ends which some people like but personally i dont.
… more
Trebor Yentup
The farther I go the better Mayflower gets I’ll start with customer service from beginning to end it was good better then most places nowadays they had everything I ordered and the food wasn’t burnt like some of the other Mayflowers dirty grease or just keeping in the fryer too long if your in the area this one is well worth the stop less your familiar and you already know
… more
First and foremost I’m not saying this is my number one but it really makes a difference the atmosphere plays a big part in a restaurant for me it had old feel …. it needs to be remodeled anyway their food wasn’t hot enough for me to start with the fish wasn’t fried hard enough for me the scallops that are ordered was (frozen)…. dried and rubbery awful very awful I ordered catfish, the catfish was mighty thin and I’m used to seeing catfish being a little meatier than that . The waitress was very nice and polite would I go back there and eat again…… NO thanks!
… more
Lori Bennett
This place is usually FANTASTIC! This time we ate around 3 pm . Only a couple people in dining room .Food arrived quickly. All ppl in party (4 ) ordered seafood. I ordered combo of 2 oysters and clam strips. Clam strips were good. Oysters were mostly breading with strange taste. Another person in party also got oysters and could not eat because of the weird taste. Fish was very thin. Staff was good. Very friendly. But food has gone down hill. Would not suggest. Hopefully they can pull it back together.
… more
Judy Johnson
Generous portions of Popcorn Shrimp & Scollops were delicious. Our server, Joel was amazing.
… more
Shel C
The coleslaw was awful, grated very fine. No taste. The oysters and fan tail shrimp was tasty. The trout was not meaty. Get the flounder instead. The hostess was great, but the waitress we had to constantly remind to bring condiments. We tipped her nicely, we just won’t be going back.
… more
toni glenn
Food was amazing, our server Taylor was awesome. She was very attentive, made sure we had everything we needed. Went above and beyond to make sure our dining experience was excellent. Will definitely be back
… more
Lance Osborn
Got sat down at a sticky table. Waiter was polite but did not enjoy his job. All of the seafood we ordered was bland and rubbery. Worst food of all our vacation stops. Most of the ceiling tiles where stained or had water damage. was not a great look. Other wait staff was friendly tho. 10/10 don’t recommend.
… more
Pam Jones
Omg. I got the bacon cheese burger and fries. It was so good. The waitress was very nice and she got everyone’s order perfect. We had 8 people at our table. I really enjoyed it. This was my 1st time going. Very satisfied.
… more
… Load more reviews

Leave a Comment

Please rate