4.1 – 265 reviews • Pizza restaurant
Humble, longtime strip-mall hub for pizza, pasta, salads & chicken entrees in basic surroundings.
✔️Breakfast ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
order.toasttab.com
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Mario’s Famous Pizzeria – Order Online
FOOD · White Pizza w/ Ricotta Pie · White Pizza w/ Spin Pie · White Pizza / Broc Pie · White Pizza / Eggplant Pie · Bacon Pie · Marios Pizza Pie · Vegetable Supreme …
Reviews
Rich Caranante
Amazing Pizza and food! I order from here regularly and had parties catered from here several times. My guest always compliment the food at our parties. I highly recommend and think they are one of the best pizzas in the area. And Im coming from NYC so I know about pizza and Mario’s is top notch, one of the best.
… moreMichael D’Armi
Marios has been my daughters choice for pizza delivery for several birthdays in a row, and she requests Marios any time we have pizza nights. The whole crew is so nice, make sure to accommodate any needs in restaurant or delivery. Prices are great and pizza is amazing. Subs are even better.
Been eating here for years, finally time for a review, get a slice or two if you haven’t yet.
… moreChristina Hira
The workers behind the counter were polite and efficient. My pizza was warmed up, but I was not a fan of the cheese which had a rubbery texture, nor of the poor quality tomato sauce used. The crust was excellent though, crunchy, chewy, and a hint of salt. Even my cat enjoyed the crust. However, I would visit again based on the fact that it was a clean setting and the workers were smiling and nice. Visited at lunchtime on a weekday. $6.40 for two plain slices to go. Free parking lot in the back which is excellent!!
… moreJohn P
They shouldn’t have menu items if they don’t know what it is. Ordered a grandma’s pie which is all sauce and little cheese, they made a pie with no sauce and all cheese. Ordered a Caesar salad and they gave a garden salad (roasted red peppers olives red onion cucumber tomatoes etc ) with Caesar dressing. The list of absurdities goes on I’m not going to list it all. Nobody said you had to put these items that you don’t know on the menu. If you are charging extra for a speciality pie & listing it I expect to receive it when I ordering it especially not the opposite. Ordered grandma pie that had a sprinkle of cheese for a reason, the all cheese literally no sauce pie is basically inedible & the complete opposite of the order.
… moreMichael
I always get good food and service, so I eat here twice a week. The slices are huge and tasty and I was craving their classic ziti slice. My car battery died down the street, so the owner took me to my car and gave me a jump. Now that’s service! Thanks Mario’s
… moreMichael Nebel
Nice place, great people, lack of attention to detail.
Pizza was good, broccoli bites were undercooked and raw on one side. Three went to the birds. Maybe a bad day but they weren’t busy.
… moreKevin O
Don’t live in NJ anymore but me and the boys were nearby and wanted some good NY style pizza. Stopped in here by chance and it was excellent. I got a pepperoni and sicilian slice. Buddy got a chicken calzone of some sort I think. I tried his too and it was excellent. No frills classic NY-Style pizza joint. Amazing pizza!
… moreDrew Rowley 973
Mario’s has some of the best pizza in Bloomfield I ordered a half plain half pepperoni pie, vodka pasta, chicken parmesan and a salad. The pizza is delicious and cooked to perfection. It’s nice and saucy and the vodka pasta was great as well. The chicken parmesan was pretty good however the salad was pretty bad but that’s usually how it is at pizzerias. My experience was great and I will be ordering my pizzas from here in the future.
… moreD. Goodson
This place is slow, especially the gray-haired older dude with glasses. His customer service was horrible and so was his attitude. I called ahead but my food still wasn’t ready after a 12-minute wait. In fact, a guy came in after me and ordered two slices from what was on display and the gray-haired dude served him, warmed his food up and he was out of there before me. As a result, my garlic knots were burnt on the bottom! I even had to ask him for the receipt twice for which he gave me more attitude. I may be wrong but I got a vibe that he had some type of issue with serving me. I wouldn’t recommend and now I see why several co-workers stopped patronizing this place.
… moreCierra R
This is a very no-frills pizza place, but it is my absolute favorite. I did the same pizza every time; a cheese pie with extra cheese, and it is delicious. I no longer live in Jersey but every time I come back I make it a point to get a pizza from here.
… more … View more