Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Made the Right Way. Every Day. There’s a reason our bagels taste different–they’re made the traditional way. At Manhattan Bagel, we give each bagel a dip in a kettle of boiling water, then bake them fresh each morning. That’s how we get our authentic shiny bagels with a crispy, golden crust on the outside and that soft, satisfying chew inside. No shortcuts. Just real, authentic bagels made the way they were always meant to be. We kettle-boil our bagels to lock in that shine and crunch, then bake them fresh daily for a chewy, golden bite. No shortcuts, just the classic NY method – done right, right here, every day.
Counter-serve chain specializing in NYC-style bagels & coffee, plus salads, soups & sandwiches.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 860 Fischer Blvd, Toms River, NJ 08753
Phone: (732) 929-3998
Website: https://www.manhattanbagel.com/?y_source=1_ODk5MjM5Mi03MTUtbG9jYXRpb24ud2Vic2l0ZQ%3D%3D
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Toms River – RT 37 – Manhattan Bagel
Manhattan Bagel located at 14 Route 37 E, Toms River, NJ serves fresh-baked bagels every day, made in store the classic NY-style way – boiled and baked with …
Shop Locator | Manhattan Bagel
Toms River-Fischer Blvd. Address: 860 Fischer Blvd Toms River, NJ 08753. View Page. Phone: +17329293998. Cherry Hill. Address: 190 Barclay Farm Cherry Hill, NJ …
Manhattan Bagel Delivery Menu | 10 Route 37 E Toms River
Order delivery or pickup from Manhattan Bagel in Toms River! View Manhattan Bagel’s March 2026 deals and menus. Support your local restaurants with Grubhub!
Reviews
Stanley Steel
I ordered a pork roll egg and cheese on a bagel. The bagel was small,but the pork roll was laughable. 3 paper thin slices. I’ll never buy anything from this place again. Joe’s bagels is so much better than this amateur bagel store.
… moreShannon Pring
Always such a nice staff coming in to greet us! The only Manhattan Bagel location me and my bf actually like cause the drinks & food is always yummy + FRESH! Thanks for the daily brunch bites guys!
… moreblizardofozzy
The hours are incorrect. The first time I came here I ordered a bagel egg and cheese . I was going to take it to go and was waiting for my order (around 1:50 ish). There was still a customer in there eating. I sat down just to wait for my order and the worker was already locking up and said we’re closing. I wasn’t going to stay. I was just waiting for my order. I went there a second time at exactly at 2pm and they were already closed. Both days were during the week. Update your hours on Google!
… moreMario Tridente
Hardly any chicken salad on my bagel. Barely one scoop. The other side of it was barely half covered. Cole slaw was just a little over half full. Tasty but not worth the money.
… moreDina Badawy
Love this Manhattan bagel! I come here very often and this location is far superior. The food is always delicious, consistent and fresh and the store is very clean and well kept. They’re very accommodating, letting you customize your order to your liking and the staff is super friendly and helpful. Great experiences overall.
… moreJess L
5/12/24 Another HORRIBLE experience in store. The manager is beyond USELESS and non professional. This is not the first bad review, second or even third time going back to give them another chance at this location. You can tell that the business does not care about or look into reviews or even care much about customers in that matter. Any other business, the manager would have been replaced by now with the amount of complaints against him.
The girls at the front are also very immature, liars, and they make the customers tend for themselves and fight w one another because the front staff can NOT do their job correctly, even with only having 3 customers at the register at the time of the incident (myself being 2 of the 3).
When I addressed this with the manager, the managers response, “it’s best for the customers to say something to another customer because they’ll take it more seriously than from our staff”. WHY can’t the staff say something as simple as to tell the other person that had walked up to the counter, was taking money out of her purse to hand to the cashier, and all while she was standing directly next to my child while she was placing her order. WHY should the customer need to say that?! USELESS And NON PROFESSIONAL. The girls at the front were also giving not so nice facial expressions. They kept denying it saying that’s the way they look. They kept saying things behind the counter to everyone and I told them to stop talking about it as I was hearing everything they were talking about, while I was complaining to the manager only 8 ft away. This started when I asked for one of their names, so I can address her by her name and also so I could post a review about the experience with her.
When I asked the manager for his first name and the staff members first name, now in order to file a legal health and safety complaint about this experience, and past experiences, which I informed him of the purpose, he had said to me “I am NOT INTERESTED in giving names”. As a customer, I have the right to know for this purpose.
First review was posted 7 months ago, about the manager as well. That time was about the food health and safety. I posted pictures of what looked like plastic toy food. The manager was basically the same way but with a different situation. Even with the pictures as proof, he didn’t care. I received a reply that it was being looked into but it never was. So I just deleted the first review to post this most recent one.
… moreThe girls at the front are also very immature, liars, and they make the customers tend for themselves and fight w one another because the front staff can NOT do their job correctly, even with only having 3 customers at the register at the time of the incident (myself being 2 of the 3).
When I addressed this with the manager, the managers response, “it’s best for the customers to say something to another customer because they’ll take it more seriously than from our staff”. WHY can’t the staff say something as simple as to tell the other person that had walked up to the counter, was taking money out of her purse to hand to the cashier, and all while she was standing directly next to my child while she was placing her order. WHY should the customer need to say that?! USELESS And NON PROFESSIONAL. The girls at the front were also giving not so nice facial expressions. They kept denying it saying that’s the way they look. They kept saying things behind the counter to everyone and I told them to stop talking about it as I was hearing everything they were talking about, while I was complaining to the manager only 8 ft away. This started when I asked for one of their names, so I can address her by her name and also so I could post a review about the experience with her.
When I asked the manager for his first name and the staff members first name, now in order to file a legal health and safety complaint about this experience, and past experiences, which I informed him of the purpose, he had said to me “I am NOT INTERESTED in giving names”. As a customer, I have the right to know for this purpose.
First review was posted 7 months ago, about the manager as well. That time was about the food health and safety. I posted pictures of what looked like plastic toy food. The manager was basically the same way but with a different situation. Even with the pictures as proof, he didn’t care. I received a reply that it was being looked into but it never was. So I just deleted the first review to post this most recent one.
B
While many of the Manhattan bagel locations vary, the one in the ShopRite plaza in toms River excels. I have seen the same owner / manager for many years adventure to say have never had a bad experience. The staff is usually smiling, the food is warm when you get it, and the quality and quantity are very fair for the price. I don’t know if all locations are as good but this one is worth the trip.
… morecassie mcshaffrey
Closing time posted is 3pm and they randomly close early ALL the time. This has been a repeated issue. Either change your time or stop closing early, it’s unprofessional.
… moreJoseph Lynch
Today is 4/27 I stopped in to bye 3 bagels there was 4 people ordering food. It took 35 minutes for me to place my order. Two people got there orders and sent them back made wrong. My order I ask that the bagels be toasted they weren’t I wanted chives cream cheese on one and onion and chives. The woman calling out the orders when done did not speak English well and nobody could understand her. So people are standing there waiting to get their food and leave.
… morePatti Kidd
A great smiling staff no matter what time I come in. Always fresh made!!!!
… more