Social Profile: ![]()
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Cozy decorated restaurant in New Windsor NY business district that offers a wide variety of delicious choices. Specializing in American & Italian cuisine using fresh ingredients with friendly professional service. Top notch burgers, pasta, wings, empanadas, hot heros, cold subs, fresh salads, paninis, and wraps. Plenty of parking available. Over 25 specialty pizzas. Serving brunch daily from 10:15-2:15.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 318 Blooming Grove Turnpike, New Windsor, NY 12553
Phone: (845) 568-3375
Website: https://www.mammamiacafepizza.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Mamma Mia Cafe & Pizzeria: Home
Mamma Mia Cafe & Pizzeria, located on Blooming Grove Turnpike in New Windsor, is a delightful spot for Italian cuisine lovers.
Mamma Mia! Cafe & Pizzeria – New Windsor, NY – 318 Blooming …
Order Hours About. 10:15 AM-8:45 PM; Shop address is 318 Blooming Grove Turnpike, New Windsor, NY 12553318 Blooming Grove Turnpike, New Windsor, NY 12553 …
Mamma Mia Cafe and Pizzeria | New Windsor NY – Facebook
Dine in or take out 318 Blooming Grove Turnpike New Windsor We deliver New Windsor, Cornwall & more ☎️(845) 565-3650 Gift Certificates available HV Business …
Last Updates
Reviews
Joe Digregorio
Went here for the first time for breakfast, food was good BUT upon receiving the bill the prices were considerably higher than menu price… I was told “prices were subject to change” by our server. The place only has 5 tables how hard would it be to print menus with the correct prices.. also charging $15 for an omelet is sinful… Do better, and buy the plywood now.
… morenicole parks
This personal pizza (that was the same size as a fork) cost $22. I’ll pay extra when it’s warranted, but there was nothing special about this paper thin teeny tiny pizza.
… moreRamon Gillian
If you’re looking for the perfect neighborhood pizza spot, Mamma Mia Pizza is it! From the moment you walk in, you feel the warmth—not just from the ovens, but from the incredible staff who treat you like family. The food is absolutely amazing: every pie is fresh, flavorful, and made with care.
What really sets Mamma Mia apart is their customer service. They consistently go above and beyond in ways you don’t often see anymore. I’ve had several last-minute situations where I needed food fast, and they pulled through without hesitation. That kind of reliability means so much, and it’s clear they truly care about their customers.
This is everything you could ask for in a pizza shop—delicious food, friendly faces, and a team that takes pride in their work. Supporting local businesses like this is easy when they deliver (literally and figuratively!) at such a high level.
Highly recommend Mamma Mia Pizza—you won’t be disappointed!
… moreWhat really sets Mamma Mia apart is their customer service. They consistently go above and beyond in ways you don’t often see anymore. I’ve had several last-minute situations where I needed food fast, and they pulled through without hesitation. That kind of reliability means so much, and it’s clear they truly care about their customers.
This is everything you could ask for in a pizza shop—delicious food, friendly faces, and a team that takes pride in their work. Supporting local businesses like this is easy when they deliver (literally and figuratively!) at such a high level.
Highly recommend Mamma Mia Pizza—you won’t be disappointed!
Danna Gardner
This place is great! I can’t believe I’ve been living less than a mile away for over a year and haven’t gone here before now! The owner is super friendly and helpful, and the food is delicious. And apparently they do pancakes?! We’re absolutely coming here again. My fiancé and I are on the larger side, so the chairs were a little uncomfortable…but that’s probably an us thing. They were very sturdy regardless! We’ll just stick with carry out in the future. Definitely check them out. I had the House Stromboli. It was delicious. Next time I’ll be trying the Tre Colori Stromboli
… moreM L
Recently ordered a drunken chicken sub it was pathetically small for a 15$ sandwich the bread was beat up and was chewy. I held a 16oz soda next to it and it was smaller can the soda bottle. It did however taste decent. I also ordered the loaded cheese fries. The fries were soggy and oily and not cooked very well. The fries were also far from “loaded” there was barely any cheese or bacon. For an all together 35$ lunch it was definitely not worth the cost. They also wanted $9 for an small piece of pecan pie.
… moreShannon Carton
The food is amazing! So many options and homemade delights. Best panini I have ever had, hands down. Absolutely must try for New Windsor.
… moreJulie Donato
Just had an amazing brunch with a friend! I had the Monte Cristo sandwich, with powdered sugar added by my request! It was excellent!! My friend had the breakfast plate, and exclaimed “fresh potatoes!” When her plate was put down! Our food was just perfect! My favorite part of our visit today was the service! The owner, Pilar was talking to me about a fun tea I recently discovered I like, called a London Fog. She took it upon herself to attempt to make it, and it was delicious!! I was so touched by her thoughtfulness, and I can’t wait go back for brunch and a London Fog!!
… moreCharlie Roberts
I ordered from them on GrubHub two days in a row as the food was so good! The bacon cheese fries were out of this world with the chipotle sauce and the seasoning on the fries. Then they had the tasty cheese bacon and onions. The turkey club wrap was a good size and the lettuce tomato all tasted fresh!
… moreDonna Scott
Great lunch. Big heros! Will return for dinner sometime. Service was great. Looking forward to trying some of their pizzas the choices look amazing. Don’t skip dessert!
… morejosh shapiro
Pilar runs a great restaurant. My daughter loved her pepperoni pizza, wife loved her caprese salad and I really enjoyed the sausage and peppers. Will definitely be back!
… more