Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Hours
| Thursday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Sunday | 12–8 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 217 Grant Ave, Auburn, NY 13021
Phone: (315) 252-6262
Website: https://facebook.com/pages/category/Pizza-place/Mamma-Maria-New-York-Pizzeria-396086617842278/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Mamma Maria New York Pizzeria | Auburn NY – Facebook
Mamma Maria New York Pizzeria, Auburn. 4529 likes · 4 talking about this · 313 were here. Pizza place.
Mamma Maria NY Pizzeria Menu, Auburn, NY – MenuGuide
Mamma Maria NY Pizzeria’s menu in Auburn, NY has NY Style Pizza – Wings – Pizza Slices – Garlic Knots – Calzones – Eggplant Parm – Subs – salads …
Order Mamma Maria New York Pizzeria – DoorDash
Get delivery or takeout from Mamma Maria New York Pizzeria at 217 Grant Avenue in Auburn. Order online and track your order live.
Reviews
R. Wood
Good people, great food.
I can’t keep the five star rating, though, due to some weirdness I faced over the past week.
I was overcharged by one of the younger staff members and didn’t catch the mistake til half an hour later or so. The girl on the phone, who had originally taken my order and quoted me differently, answered and fixed the issue pretty quickly by putting credit in my name. I visit enough that I was fine with that. Well, today I went to use it and was told someone else had somehow done so. They fixed this mistake after a few minutes, but the entire situation had been handled so poorly that it’s hard not to wonder what the heck is going on.
Still good noms, but make 3x sure you’re paying the correct price first or the follow-up to fix it might get a little outer limits-y.
… moreI can’t keep the five star rating, though, due to some weirdness I faced over the past week.
I was overcharged by one of the younger staff members and didn’t catch the mistake til half an hour later or so. The girl on the phone, who had originally taken my order and quoted me differently, answered and fixed the issue pretty quickly by putting credit in my name. I visit enough that I was fine with that. Well, today I went to use it and was told someone else had somehow done so. They fixed this mistake after a few minutes, but the entire situation had been handled so poorly that it’s hard not to wonder what the heck is going on.
Still good noms, but make 3x sure you’re paying the correct price first or the follow-up to fix it might get a little outer limits-y.
Nicole Gabriel
It’s located in a a shopping plaza. They have ample parking.I’ve walked in here a few times now before and grabbed a slice. They always have a wide variety available to choose from. Everything always looks and tastes so good. Lots of different kinds of toppings on the slices they have available. They heat it up pretty quickly for you. They always seem to have a steady stream of traffic of people dropping in to get a slice to go.You can also it in.
… moreSTU SOURA
Great service, great food, excellent atmosphere. Also, met a very nice person Chelsea was able to not to assist with a friendly attitude but also went above and beyond put of her way to help a gentleman who had lost his way where he had parked his car in their parking lot so she went outside to assist him and help him out.
Great place with amazing people who are here for the community and great food.
… moreGreat place with amazing people who are here for the community and great food.
Eric Charette
The place is small but very clean and has tables set up for indoor dining and outdoor dining. The staff were very pleasant, cheerful and helpful. The food was amazing one of the best pizza places I have gone to and the prices were great for the quality of food. We had a bunch of different kinds of pizza, pinwheels and bread sticks all were great perfectly cooked.
… moreJed Godfrey
I arrived in Auburn and went straight for a slice. Great char on the undercarriage. Sausage mushroom and hot honey pepperoni slices were bangin. Had a garlic knot too like a real fat kid.
… moreSerenity Wellness Wellness
Always amazing food and service. From one small business owner to another passion anyways shines through when your passionate about what you do. Zahara today provided outstanding customer service and my pizza was phenomenal
… moreWilliam McDermott
All I asked for was a garlic half baked with mozzarella and that’s exactly what I got. It was perfect. I topped it and finished it at home. They pulled the pie exactly when it was ready to travel. They were busy, happy, organized and helpful. The pizza was inexpensive and delicious! We’re going back again tonight for another!
… moreHoward Perkins
The best pizza in Auburn by a long shot and probably the best slices I’ve ever had. All the staff are fun and friendly, it’s an awesome place to go sit down and have a slice, and they’re not overpriced like every other pizza place seems to be nowadays.
… moreAlexi Moutafis
This pizza place is very good. I don’t know if I would have given it 5 stars in a major metro area but it is very difficult to find decent food in Auburn. I have really liked all their pizza. Its not too thin, crunchy on the bottom, fluffy in the center. I like the sauce, not sweet maybe just a little spicy. The meats and veggies are of good quality. Food is hot when you get it. The people at counter are friendly and helpful. My in-laws, for some ungodly reason, order Mark’s. I have begun refusing it after finding this place. The pizza is a little pricy. I paid $31 for a lg cheese and a small pepperoni. Worth it if that’s what it takes to get decent food in Auburn.
… moreLens & Lore
Closing time or not, the attitude was awful, the place unsanitary, and the pizza old. Next time, this won’t just be a review—it’ll be a report to the health board. When kids are left to run a business without oversight, things go downhill fast.
… more