Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Hours
| Wednesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Mama Pepinos: Experience the Best Pizza in West Newton
Location & Contact · 110 W Main St, West Newton, PA 15089 · (724) 872-0338.
Mama Pepino’s | Pizza, Pasta & Subs in West Newton PA
Mama Pepino’s at 110 W Main St, West Newton—your hometown favorite for fresh pizza, hearty pasta, and Italian-American classics made with love.
Mama Pepino’s Menu (Newest Menu Update) – Restaurants Info
Welcome to Mama Pepino’s, where home-cooked flavors meet warm hospitality in West Newton! Join us for a delightful dining experience! More Foodie Finds. Leo’s …
Reviews
Maggie Hanbury
We moved to the area in November and although we’ve always heard how good the food was we finally tried it! Everything was amazing every time.
Today was a long day between work and doctors appointments so we decided to order their delivery. Wings, breadsticks (quite literally the best ones I have ever had) and Hawaiian pizza with green peppers- when the order arrived it didn’t have the peppers. I was hesitant to call, not that it was a huge deal and I’m not a complainer. I own my own business so I get it. But I am 5 months pregnant and it’s just something I wanted… badly When I called, and explained- I told them I was going to eat it anyway because hello, tired- pregnant- hungry, and just asked for a credit next order. Instead, they told me to keep the one I had and that they were going to send me a new pizza over as well! Not only was the order correct but they also gave me a medium instead of a small like I had originally ordered. Both delicious, but this is truly how good customer service works. They’ll always have my business as long as we live close!!
… moreToday was a long day between work and doctors appointments so we decided to order their delivery. Wings, breadsticks (quite literally the best ones I have ever had) and Hawaiian pizza with green peppers- when the order arrived it didn’t have the peppers. I was hesitant to call, not that it was a huge deal and I’m not a complainer. I own my own business so I get it. But I am 5 months pregnant and it’s just something I wanted… badly When I called, and explained- I told them I was going to eat it anyway because hello, tired- pregnant- hungry, and just asked for a credit next order. Instead, they told me to keep the one I had and that they were going to send me a new pizza over as well! Not only was the order correct but they also gave me a medium instead of a small like I had originally ordered. Both delicious, but this is truly how good customer service works. They’ll always have my business as long as we live close!!
William Ruffing
The first time we went they burnt our pizza. They were new and no big deal. Next time our pizza had very little sauce. We could hardly taste it. Tonight I ordered a pizza and just asked the girl to make sure it has some sauce on it. They charged me for the sauce. Then cI was told it would be a couple minutes. After over ten minutes we asked if they lost our pizza. They said they ruined it and it would be another 20 minutes or so. No one bothered to tell us. We got our money and left
Terrible service. (We really like the sauce) Probably won’t be back
… moreTerrible service. (We really like the sauce) Probably won’t be back
Michelle Hughes
I work at local campground and got food delivered from here .This was my first time ordering for them . i used to work in a pizza shop for almost 5 years so i know what is expected .The person on the phone was very nice , the delivery time was right on point! The sicillian pizza was the best i had in a long time. i dont know whether it is the sauce or the dough but the garlic taste was so good ! This place will be new take out place while im at work . The price and portions are very reasonable. if you get the chance to check them out please do you wont be disappointed!!
… moreNikki Steban
Refused to deliver. Insisted it was too far. I have ordered many times and never had a problem. They have lost my business
… moreMarlene
I ordered an Italian calzone. Menu states meat/cheese lettuce tomato onion and dressing. I asked to have some banana peppers added in. Not many places make a calzone just like the hoagie (a fav of mine from long ago) Delivery was speedy. Driver was very kind. Food was piping hot.
(Steak hoagies were also ordered)
I was so excited for my long-lost love,
The Italian Calzone.
It was beautiful..and HOT
But as soon as i ripped a piece off-
I felt ripped off (not really bc i did get good, hot food delivered) but this was NOT what was presented on the menu. The “dressing” was pizza sauce.
No lettuce. No tomatos. No onions.
No banana peppers.
Meat, cheese, and pizza sauce.
Super bummed. ☹️
It’s just not what I ordered.
… more(Steak hoagies were also ordered)
I was so excited for my long-lost love,
The Italian Calzone.
It was beautiful..and HOT
But as soon as i ripped a piece off-
I felt ripped off (not really bc i did get good, hot food delivered) but this was NOT what was presented on the menu. The “dressing” was pizza sauce.
No lettuce. No tomatos. No onions.
No banana peppers.
Meat, cheese, and pizza sauce.
Super bummed. ☹️
It’s just not what I ordered.
Lisa Michaux
WONDERFUL PIZZA, THE BEST I’VE EVER HAD. WE TRAVEL ALL THE WAY THERE FROM FALLOWFIELD TWP. WE ABSOLUTELY LOVE IT. THANKS TO MAMA PEPINO’S…..
… moreBoosted Rooster
Truck driver here. Called at 8:40 pm on 8/6/25 and was told they were closed. Please update open times. Id much rather support small businesses than big chains but stuff like this makes it difficult. The locals here said yall had some good food and really wanted to try it.
… moreCheyenne Fackiner
The person answering the phone is the most cheerful, happy voice & always so friendly. We had a pickup order mishap & instead of us having to drive 25 minutes back, he took our address & very quickly had another pizza delivered! Absolutely top-notch customer service!!! And the best pizza around, well worth the travel.
… moreDebbie Dillard
They were very busy on a Saturday. Very good pizza, nice folks!
… moreGary Glass
Ordered for the first time last night and my sons keep talking about it being the best pizza in the area. We have tried them all. The prices are low compared to quantity and quality of the food. Will definitely be ordering again.
… more