Carla Champion
After a very stressful and draining couple of days, I sought out Pizza, one of my main comfort foods. I was just up the street and the ratings were enough to make me drive 5 min in the opposite direction. Am I glad I did!
Tony was gracious and accommodating. He provided suggestions, but allowed me to take my time and figure out what I wanted.
Pepperoni Trio with added Feta was so delicious. He explained the baking instructions and I had a hot delicious pie in 10 min. I eyeballed the Chicago Deep dish with 1# of chee but I didn’t dare trust myself with that much food all alone!
Will be going back for it later… Saw a lot of regulars picking up as I waited, definitely give this place a try, support local, support family
… moreJohn
WOW!
Got a garlic butter base, pineapple and feta cheese pizza and tiramisu. Hands down the best tiramisu I’ve ever had in my life. Pizza was incredible. Topping coverage was perfect, sauce was balanced and flavorful, cheese was excellent. I will absolutely be eating here every time I am in Columbus. If I could give 10 stars I would. AMAZING
… moreSharon Pinion
This is a favorite of ours for many years now. Everything is so fresh and the “take and bake” pizzas are made to order. I was skeptical at the idea of baking at home, but it’s definitely worth a try if you haven’t already. SO TASTY!! The employees also help make this an easy place to support.
… moreMRBARBQ 1
Decided it was a takeout type day and it would be a Mama Mimi’s Take N Bake pizza time. First the guys (Hunter and George) working there are way cool and super helpful. Wealth of knowledge. Decided on the Pepperoni Trio-Three kinds of pepperoni, fresh garlic, parmesan & fresh basil. Looks delicious. They also threw in breadsticks with Parmesan cheese sprinkled on and sauce for being first time customer. They explained all the cooking instructions and tips. Again they are super helpful. Decided to start with the breadsticks first. Unwrap the package and preheated the oven to 450 degrees and baked them for 6 minutes on parchment paper provided. Boy were they delicious, they provided some nice chunky dipping sauce. Just right amount of spice. Directions for cooking are super simple, allowing the pizza to sit out for around 40 minutes and cook 8-10 minutes on the parchment paper provided. How easier can it get. The pizza crust is very thin, the sauce has a little spice to it. A lot of cheese covers the three types of pepperoni. I would cook it just a little bit longer to crisp it up. Not a bad pizza.
… moreLisa B
I had put in a large catering order and did not give much lead time. I arrived for pick up and Jeff was extremely courteous and busy! He let me know it would be a little longer but I can tell you he was prepping the food with care and extreme efficiency. Everything turned out great! I will be back to this location.
… moreKim Bushrow
Amazing pizza! I never thought take n bake pizza would be this good but it exceeded all my expectations… definitely a must when visiting family in Columbus. Staff was super friendly and helpful when picking up the pizza.
… moreRebecca Dragin
It was a lazy Sunday and cooking wasn’t in the cards. Mama Mimi’s lasagna is delicious. Pre-heat the oven and an hour later your dinner is ready. The dinner pan is ideal for two hungry people or four people with a salad. Well done Jeff and his team!!
… moreMia Berg
Was recommended Mama Mimi’s by a coworker and it did not disappoint! The crust was a great balance of puffy and crispy on the bottom, and it baked SUPER fast!
It also reminded me how nice take-and-bake style can be — my order was for a get together and it was fun to serve pizza fresh from the oven.
… moreBrian Deasey
Nothing better than fresh baked pizza at home. I wish there were more “take n bake” places. This is definitely one of my favorite pizza places in Columbus. Gourmet. Quality ingredients. Fair price. It’s not delivery, it’s Mama Mimi’s.
… moreElias Elias
The pizza bakes so nicely. Very unique flavor combination to some of the speciality pizza
… more