Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Mama Mia Pizzeria Baraboo | Baraboo WI – Facebook
Fresh New York-style pizza, homemade pasta, and hot garlic bread made fresh every day. 113 3rd St – Baraboo, WI (608) 355-0373 Order now, pick it up fast, …
Mama Mia’s
Mama Mia’s. Welcome to Mama Mia’s Pizzeria! open daily. Tuesday thru Saturday … Mama Mia’s Pizza – 113 3rd St – Baraboo, WI 53913 – 608-355-0373. Page …
Mama Mia Pizzeria Baraboo 113 3rd St | Toast
Mama Mia Pizzeria Baraboo 113 3rd St · 14″ PEPPERONI. $16.95 · PIZZA SPECIAL. 1 Large 18″ Pizza w/ choice of two toppings with cheesy bread or garlic bread and …
Reviews
Doc Wellington
Waitress gave us Spaghetti and meatballs instead of the Baked Ziti we ordered.
I had Lasagna.
Pepsi and a Lemonade for our refreshments.
Service was fast and courteous.
Food was Great.
We also ordered a Cheese, Sausage and Mushroom pizza to go.
Got to meet Husband, Wife and Son.
Very friendly.
Definitely would go back again.
Just got home, that pizza, we’ll, all I can say is “You gotta fricken try dis pizza”..lol.
Keep up the good work.
… moreI had Lasagna.
Pepsi and a Lemonade for our refreshments.
Service was fast and courteous.
Food was Great.
We also ordered a Cheese, Sausage and Mushroom pizza to go.
Got to meet Husband, Wife and Son.
Very friendly.
Definitely would go back again.
Just got home, that pizza, we’ll, all I can say is “You gotta fricken try dis pizza”..lol.
Keep up the good work.
Amy Jo Behling
A great finish to our walk around the town! Olive oil from the kitchen store next door made it a real Italian restaurant. We loved the Greek salad with spices and wonderful Kalamata olives and Greek dressing. We had to dip the beautiful bread into it to eat every drop.
… moreChar terBeest Kudla
Family run Italian local restaurant. We had Chicken Marsala which was good and Ravioli which was excellent. Their specialty is pizza. It’s a small space. Fast friendly service. We’ll return.
… moreJoe Burger
First time coming here and I will be back. It’s right by a bunch of thrift stores, game stores, great scenic routes. You definitely want to come here and eat after touring around. The staff are very happy and professional. The food had so much flavor and it brought me back in time. Go here and support these people
… moremegs-m2
Treated my mom to lunch here & we were not disappointed! Cozy atmosphere, attentive staff, and amazing food! We were already making plans to return while enjoying our Stromboli 🙂
… moreHonest Reviewer
Me and my boyfriend went here for a date. The people were super nice and we didn’t have to wait more than a few seconds to be seated. While my boyfriend was grabbing a slice, our pizza accidentally fell over and landed on the floor, spilling my soda. The people working reacted fast and quickly clean it up for us and made us a new pizza completely free along with our drinks. Although the experience was socially embarrassing, I’d recommend this place to anyone who loves authentic Italian food.
… moreElla Altreuther
The atmosphere feels incredibly authentic. The food is so delicious. I have now eaten here twice. Pizza is delicious. Pasta is to die for! I would recommend to try multiple dishes.
… moreJulia Silvers
Always great! They best garlic knots and huge portions.
… moreJeremy Gesicki
Absolutely fantastic spot for a meal with the family. The Pizza was great, we also enjoyed the cheese bread, breaded mushrooms and a Caesar salad.
The staff was incredibly friendly too.
Will definitely be back again soon. Highly recommend.
… moreThe staff was incredibly friendly too.
Will definitely be back again soon. Highly recommend.
Jason Stephens
I was shopping at the square in Baraboo last Saturday with my kid, when we became very hungry.
We popped in for lunch at Mama Mia without any knowledge of the restaurant. It was about 11:30 am and the dining room was nearly empty, which gave me pause – but the place was very clean and smelled amazing, so we stayed.
There was a pleasant young man who seated us and took our order – while an older employee milled about and chatted with the other customers. I think the “I’m not interested in small talk” vibes I exude were picked up on. Everyone is different, and I understand the intent was positive. I’m cool with servers asking if they can get me anything and if everything is tasting alright, but visiting with strangers isn’t for me. Still, not a deal breaker.
Mama Mia’s menu has some standard Italian options, but I can’t speak to their quality. The pizza is solid A tier, so I might expect the same from their pasta.
There’s nothing overly fancy about Mama Mia, and that’s perfectly fine. We ordered the smallest size sausage pizza and it was big enough that we took half home. The price, quality and flavor were such that I will definitely be back.
… moreWe popped in for lunch at Mama Mia without any knowledge of the restaurant. It was about 11:30 am and the dining room was nearly empty, which gave me pause – but the place was very clean and smelled amazing, so we stayed.
There was a pleasant young man who seated us and took our order – while an older employee milled about and chatted with the other customers. I think the “I’m not interested in small talk” vibes I exude were picked up on. Everyone is different, and I understand the intent was positive. I’m cool with servers asking if they can get me anything and if everything is tasting alright, but visiting with strangers isn’t for me. Still, not a deal breaker.
Mama Mia’s menu has some standard Italian options, but I can’t speak to their quality. The pizza is solid A tier, so I might expect the same from their pasta.
There’s nothing overly fancy about Mama Mia, and that’s perfectly fine. We ordered the smallest size sausage pizza and it was big enough that we took half home. The price, quality and flavor were such that I will definitely be back.