Taylor Gilbert
We have been wanting to try this place and finally stopped in today. First of all the restaurant is clean, cozy, and welcoming. We were greeted by the owner with a friendly and helpful demeanor, and he helped us navigate the menu and make choices. We decided to try the nachos, a steak torta, and tacos. All of these dishes blew us away. The meat was delicious, the veggies were fresh, the bread had the perfect mix of crunch and soft, chips were homemade, and the tortillas were amazing. We couldn’t get over how great everything was and will definitely return to try the pizza. Great little spot, 5 stars overall.
… moreBarry Hopfel
New owner is much better. Best Grandma pie ever had. Fresh herbs, chopped garlic, even sauce got a thumbs up from my Italian wife! Didn’t even have crust left over for our dog.
… moreFrank Emanuele
I know when it was Jacks Pizza and then the second owners the pizza wasn’t the best but the new owner and the main man behind the counter flipping pizza are aces. I’ve eaten a lot of pizza in my day and it’s now my favorite spot in Flemington (which says a lot since you can throw a quarter and hit a pizza joint). So far my favorite is the grandma pie but I haven’t had a bad pizza yet. Try the sesame crust!
… moreRob Lopshire
Looks like it’s under new management/owners (No longer Jack’s Pizza).
Very happy with the service, very attentive staff. Had to try a slice with peppers & onions (true pizza place test). It was great, no over-sized pepper chunks like most places. Onions and pepper are thinly sliced like they should be.
Walked down few days later to try the tortas (awesome).
Ask for the house hot sauces if you’re a fan of the heat.
Looking forward to trying entrees next.
On the new side, I think they opened pretty recently.
… moreAlyssa Anderson
Amazing spot! I tried their Margherita slice with the sesame-seed crust, and I’m not exaggerating, it was one of the best slices I’ve ever had in my life. It was full of flavor and the crust was unique. I also had the carne asada burrito, which was definitely worth trying.
The owner was incredibly friendly and welcoming, which made the whole experience even better. Truly a five-star visit. I’ll absolutely be back!
… moreChris Czarnecki
This is my 5th time ordering from Main St. Pizza and Tacos and they have been consistent in the quality of their ingredients and how it’s made. The pizza is always crispy and sauce to cheese ratio on point. Ordered a lg pie with pepperoni and hot honey today delivered thru the slice app. Great pizza every time I’ve placed an order so far!!
… moreAndrew Collins
Went to Main St Pizza and Tacos last night. We used to eat here when it was Original Jacks. The pizza was excellent with a thin crust that hits all the right notes. This place will now be our go-to for pizza. We love very thin crust and they deliver that.
… moreTilak Patel
Ordered food from here and tried their carne asada tacos—they’ll definitely make you want to come back for more. The tacos were delicious, flavorful, and very filling. The restaurant is spotless, and the service was impressively fast. I also met the new owner—he’s friendly, helpful, and a fellow local from Flemington. Overall, a great experience!
… moreGalen Rice
Cozy little former pizzeria is now a pizzeria plus authentic Mexican fare, including street style tacos with a side of lime, radish, and verde sauce. In one visit we got a slice, a plain pie, and some tacos de pollo. You’d think places that mix two distinct kinds of menus in one location end up suffering somehow, but I think the slices are better than many of the other pizzerias in town, and the tacos rival those at nearby authentic Mexican restaurants (though I do wish they would use just a single soft corn tortilla for the wrapping instead of doubling up, but of course we can take those off if we don’t want them). Loved it, will order again.
… moreChristopher Gacos
Amazing pizza and super friendly staff. Gotta try the pizza atleast once and the tacos were amazing!
… more