Jordan VandenHeuvel
Some restaurants serve great food. Some give great service. Maiden Lake Supper Club somehow delivers both at a level you rarely see anymore.
We were there celebrating a family birthday with a large group that included several young kids, which usually means a little chaos. The staff handled everything effortlessly. At one point a drink got knocked over at our table and before anyone even had time to react, a server was already there resetting the space and keeping the night moving without interruption. That kind of awareness and professionalism says everything about how well this place is run.
The Ribeye Gorgonzola was outstanding and cooked exactly right. Easily one of the best restaurant meals I’ve had in years.
The entire experience felt relaxed, welcoming, and genuinely cared for from start to finish. This is exactly what a supper club should be. We’ll absolutely be coming back.
… moreCraig Rose
We had a very nice experience at the Supper Club. The food was excellent. The ribeye was especially good and cooked perfectly everyone was happy with their meals and we especially loved the liver pate appetizer that they give you for free. The Lakeview is a definite plus and we have cocktails out on the water while we waited for a table. Highly recommended
… moreDon S
Delicious food paired with a beautiful view of Maiden Lake. The walleye was top-notch—perfectly cooked and full of flavor. Service was equally impressive: polite, friendly, and attentive without being overbearing. A great spot for a relaxing, quality meal.
… moreJeff Bricco
This supper club is by far our favorite! Staff is amazing and management treats you like family. Beautiful views of lake inside and out. Food is to die for! Would highly recommend to anybody looking for a top notch supper club visit.
… moreL Roehrig
Stopped in with family group of 9 and didn’t have to wait long for a table. The bartender kept us quenched while waiting. Waitstaff was quick to take our orders. We had veggies and dips at the table while we waited. The soups and salads were delicious. Our entrees were generously portioned and delicious as well. We elected to take dessert to go. Beautiful scenery enjoyed throughout the evening.
… moreMary Jane Sanchez
What a place! This is a must stop but expect to wait a long time during their busy hours (like 3 hours of wait) however it is well worth it!
I came here to check out their Bloody Mary for @WiscoMary but I was super impressed with their food and the location. Lucky me I sat at the bar and I was served immediately I had a lemontini and their deep fried Lobster I would have that again and again it was that good. I did order Bloody Mary but gave it to my new friend sitting next to me but I did taste it and it was delicious. Thanks to Zach for his great hospitality!
… moreHaley Schmitt
Maiden Lake Supper Club is a gem of a classic supper club. The old fashions were delicious. Traditional ordering at the bar, relish tray, crackers, soup, and salad all included in the meal. Our group enjoyed steak, stuffed shrimp, and prime rib. After dinner drink options, including ice cream drinks were boozy and delicious. The service and views were excellent. A must stop supper club!
… moreMike Taylor
There’s no other supper club in the area that compares to Maiden Lake. Great food, great views, great deck. We have come here for years and have never been disappointed.
… moreBob Smith (Darkwing Duck)
Awesome super club! We were blessed to have Zach as our server. He was very friendly and super attentive, thank you!!
… moreMel Brousseau
This supper club is an absolute must when you are in the area and reservations are needed due to it’s popularity, although the large bar is a fun spot to just sit and have a drink or two. There is plenty of parking, and the beautiful lake view is visible from both the back patio and the wall of windows in the back of the restaurant. The pâté on the starter veggie/dip tray is one of my favorites, and I recommend the cheesy cauliflower soup which pairs nicely with the complimentary loaf of bread for the table. The wagyu beef burger was perfectly cooked and topped with melted butter, enhancing the rich flavor. The lobster served with the well-priced steak and lobster dinner was also prepared perfectly and worth a mention. Everything is delicious here and worth a try, and the staff work incredibly hard to attend to everyone in a timely manner with an impressive table turnaround time. This is a spot I will keep going back to!
… more