Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 5758 Telephone Rd, Cincinnatus, NY 13040
Phone: (607) 863-4434
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Magro’s Italia Pizzeria | Cincinnatus NY – Facebook
We are a family owned restaurant that has been serving Cincinnatus and surrounding area… See more. Italian Restaurant · $$ · (607) 863-4434.
Magro’S Cincinnatus Menu (Latest Dishes & Updates 2026)
Magro’s Cincinnatus is a welcoming spot in Cincinnatus, NY, offering hearty meals, friendly service, and a genuine small-town dining experience worth revisiting …
Magro’s Italia Pizzeria – Cincinnatus – MapQuest
Get more information for Magro’s Italia Pizzeria in Cincinnatus, NY. See reviews, map, get the address, and find directions.
Reviews
Kris Balser
The food is very good. The pizza and bites are super yummy. The ordering can be a little slow but worth the drive and the wait. Support local shops great food.
… moreKara Maclaury
I love there pizza and wings they are my favorite and the service is good but sometimes they get ready buys and might take ur food a little bit longer to get done
… moreWilliam Kisner
Okay so I’ve been eating here for 16 years, definitely has deteriorated in quality ( probably since covid)
… moreKeith Lowery
Awesome small town pizza shop. Highly recommend if you are passing through or down in the area.
… moreCharlene Reardon
This is the second time in a row had a party and everyone complaining about thin crust and barely any cheese and the buffalo was dry not sure what is happening because I always have loved their pizza. I never have left over and I had most of it 2 sheet pizza 70.00 wasted
… moreBrittany Casterline
Food is always good, convenient when not feeling like cooking, close to home and staff is always friendly!!
… moreSam Tsepelis
Absolutely love eating here! They need to update the hours, online says closed certain days and on Facebook it says open. the food never fails, i’ve been eating here for 4 years now and it never disappoints!
… moreMike Harlost
Couldn’t have a better experience or better pizza!
Service: …
… moreService: …
Kenneth Taylor
The reason for my review fully stems around the fact that covid is not 100% gone get I was a first-time customer and observed that with every pizza prepped to go into the oven in order to get it off the wooden padel and into the oven they lift the edge of the dough and blow air from their mouth so it doesn’t stick with no way guarantee their not spitting at the same time plus no one was wearing hair nets or gloves when prepping the food which when paying almost $80 for 2 large and 1 small pizzas enough said!!!!
… moreJimmy Trosper
I have been getting pizza and wings at this place for about 11 years. It may not look like much, but is a great place. The service is great, and they aim for quality and happiness. Thank for serving the community
… more