Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Craving a taste of the Big Apple? Lucy’s New York Style Pizza brings the authentic flavors of a classic pizzeria to the heart of Idaho Falls. Our dedication to quality begins with fresh, house-made dough, hand-tossed and baked to perfection. Each pizza is crafted with the finest ingredients, ensuring every bite delivers the genuine, savory taste of a true New York pie. Experience a slice of tradition and savor the difference that fresh preparation makes.
Unassuming local chain eatery serving up thin-crust pizza, plus calzones, subs & salads.
Hours
| Monday | 10:30 AM–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 10:30 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 10:30 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 10:30 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 10:30 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 10:30 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 108 W Main St, Rigby, ID 83442
Phone: (208) 932-1058
Website: https://www.lucysnypizza.com/
Menu Photos
Related Web Results
108 W Main Street, Rigby, ID – Lucys NY Pizza
Order Online from Lucy’s NY Pizza. Get the best prices and service when ordering directly.
Lucy’s New York Style Pizzeria – Rigby | Rigby ID – Facebook
Lucy’s New York Style Pizzeria – Rigby · Details · Links · Contact info. . (208) 932-1058. Photos. See all. Posts. Lucy’s New York Style Pizzeria – Rigby. 1d …
Lucy’s New York Style Pizzeria
Lucys NY Pizza Locations and Hours. 108 W Main Street · (208) 932-1058 · 108 W Main Street, Rigby, ID 83442. Open now • Closes at 10PM. All hours. View menu.
Reviews
Max Elder
Really solid food. We got the calzones and the cheese bread and both were phenomenal! Tatum was excellent and took care of everything we needed. My one complaint is that full pizzas tend to be a bit on the price side but as long as you order by the slice you can’t go wrong here. Glad to see Rigby had another unique place to grab a bite.
… moreSteve Minten
Its a great New York slice. Great crust, perfect amount of cheese, big pepperoni, everything you want in a quick slice. The sauce is the secret. I’m detecting San Marzano tomatoes which are the certified tomato for any pizza competition. The atmosphere is cozy but industrial. The service is kind and very family run. They serve beer and the game was on – everyone was in a happy place.
… moreJa Bow
We ordered a pretty generic pizza- and got something outstanding! Ingredients were fresh, crust was tossed, cooked perfectly. The cheesecake – I haven’t had a better piece outside of NYC. It’s smaller, but the flavor is homemade.
BTW- the staff is relaxed and nice. The place is spotless. Happy to have a great place in Rigby.
… moreBTW- the staff is relaxed and nice. The place is spotless. Happy to have a great place in Rigby.
Houston Fallis
An intruder came in my house good thing I had this pizza! I through it at him and it knocked him out!
… moreEmily Holmes
We are so exited to have this restaurant in Rigby! Prices are unbeatable. You can’t get an amazing meal like this for under $30 anywhere else. Servers are actually NICE + efficient, and the managers are hands on. Atmosphere and layout is comfortable, and clean. This will be a regular stop for us.
… moreLogan k Smith
This place is fantastic. My son has celiac , and they have a gluten free menu. But not a celiac safe menu. They allowed us to bring in a certified gluten free cooked pizza from home so my son can eat out with us. Amazing staff and they care so much! You guys made my day with the kindness and understanding !
… moreKristen H
Ordered from the new location in Rigby. Our pizzas were really good! Delivery was on time as they projected. Will be ordering again in the future!
… moreTrent Childs
This new Lucy’s location has somehow outdone the others! The same awesome food! Great service as always & a great atmosphere. First class people from top to bottom
Well done Lucys
… moreWell done Lucys
Denny Dark
The food at this branch of Lucys is awesome, the pizza tasted great and the wings looked delicious. However, im not sure if its growing pains only being open a few weeks or just something else. But some of the servers were not very great. We tried to wave down our server a few times and multiple times she was just standing around looking…confused. when she was helping us, she did everything good. Wait times were a bit intense for our food as well, but it was busy, so I’m willing to give it a pass. If you don’t mind waiting for your food occasionally and aren’t just stopping in for one of their ready made slices. The food is worth the wait and its awesome to have a lucys closer.
… moreJohn Adams
Eat here once a week since you opened in Rigby!! Absolutely love it. Staff is amazing, food is always amazing, the restaurant is amazing!! Best thing that’s happened to Rigby!!
… more