Sara Gliedman
We moved to the area about 6 months ago from New York – one of the things we have missed most is the pizza. This hit the spot! Oh my goodness, it’s perfection. This tastes like home. Wow. We are blown away and will be making this a regular stop. The crust is perfect, the texture is perfect – seriously, so happy!
… moreElle G
First time at Lombardi’s and we tried a veggie pizza and the lemon pepper wings. The pizza toppings and sauce were good while the crust/bottom could’ve been more crispy as it was a bit dough-y.
Not a bad pick for a pizza & wings night.
… moreDarrin (Deadtriology)
This is the closest to actual NY style pizza I’ve ever had. Loved it. I tired a slice of cheese, sausage, and pepperoni all were great tasting. My wife tried the Cuban slice and was fan as well. We also ordered one of the rice balls, which Ive attempted to make on my own once prior to find this place and they put mine to shame. We had prompt service the employees were young and very nice and did a great job. If your looking for an authentic NY style pizza place give this spot a try.
… moreCoach HOF
Always a great slice of pizza!…and I mean CONSISTENTLY great pizza. It’s a big letdown at some pizza joints when the pizza you order isn’t what you expected, or isn’t the same consistency as previous purchases. You NEVER have to worry about that here….it’s ALWAYS the same great slice of New York style pizza. Staff are all friendly and helpful…always a good selection of slices, and getting a whole pie is also a great option….and the prices are very reasonable.
… moreAlex Velazquez
This is hands down my favorite pizza parlor! You must try the Sicilian rice balls and their slice of the day is always a neat surprise! We make the hour drive if we are buying pizza
… moreJenni B
In true New York fashion, employees can be a little brusque. However, the pizza has the most perfect crust! My daughter loved the Nashville Hot. Unfortunately, the owner’s attitude does bring down the rating.
… moreRebecca Hattery
Slice of pizza made a great lunch! I had the flavor of the day – grilled chicken, spinach, and artichoke. It was scrumptious. Excellent lunch option – fast, affordable, and delicious. Customer service was friendly and efficient.
… moreEvan Worlds
Great food! Great music! The employees were so nice to me and my wife. The prices are GREAT!
Can’t wait to order more soon!
… moreJosh B
We just got back from a trip from New York, and I realized on that trip that New York style pizza was the best. I was very happy to find out that we had our own local New York style pizza here in town. My wife used to eat here when they were located in Henderson, and things have not change the pizza was amazing. The garlic knots were great, and who can be mad at cheesecake? We were able to get the pizza half baked so when we got home we could finish it off and add the ricotta to it which made a big difference given that we live 20 miles away. If you want a decent pizza in a style of New York, this is your place! We will definitely be going back again and again.
… moreJoanie Ellis
Take out | Dinner | $10–20
Tried this place for the first time and it did not disappoint. We ordered a pepperoni and sausage pizza with some bone in BBQ wings. The wings were whatever, we’ve had worse wings but we’ve also had better. The pizza, was great. They told us 20 mins, but we had to wait just a few minutes for it to be ready and the wait was worth it. It was hot and fresh with just enough sauce and cheese. I don’t think this is the best pizza in Evansville, but if you come here, you definitely won’t be disappointed.
… more