4.3 – 1,940 reviews • Pizza restaurant
Counter-serve pizzeria dishing up slices and pies with a variety of toppings.
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
slicelife.com
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Little Italy Pizza
Discover the best pizza restaurant in town! Order pizza online from Little Italy Pizza and enjoy fast delivery from the top pizza places near me.
Last Updates
Reviews
Wet Sofa
Stopped by Little Italy pizza looking for a quick bite to eat and left extremely satisfied. There was a line when entering but it moved quickly and efficiently. Ordered one of the thick square Sicilian slices with red sauce and cheese. Despite the simple ingredients and presentation, the pizza was crafted perfectly, with a flavorful red sauce mixed with the gooey cheese and the thick and crispy crust. The slice was so good, I ended up going back in line just to get another. Definitely an excellent spot to get a slice of pizza for a decent price.
… moreSte
Visited in Decemeber following a long day exploring.
Good selection of pizza / slices to choose from.
Plenty of seating inside.
Our pizza thoigh was nice and decent size for the two of us sharing.
… moreCharity Ann
This was the first time I’ve ever had NYC style pizza. Their veggie pizza and Grandma slice were delicious!! I’m from IL, it’s saying something when I say NYC style is better than Chicago deep-dish! The guys were friendly. Great spot for a quick lunch!
… moreshrouk ahmed
Wow! Honestly, this is the best pizza I’ve ever tried in New York! The flavor is just perfect — crispy, cheesy, and full of taste. The team there is super friendly and welcoming, especially the Egyptian staff — you guys are amazing! Thanks a lot for the great service and good vibes. Highly recommend Little Italy Pizza! ❤️
… moreVince A
I was there mid July 2025 and it was smoking hot in Manhattan that day. So my experience very s windily. Pretty good joint to grab a quick bite if you’re in a hurry. I should have picked another Pizza slice rather than pepperoni because it gave me the most worst heartburn I’ve had in a long time. The pizza place was super hot inside and air conditioner inside could barley keepup! I spent $9.50 on a slice and Gatorade bottle. Vince
… moreInstagram: 2wentyThr33
You pick your pizza, they toss it in the oven, and boom—hot, cheesy magic. The food was soooo delicious with a huge variety to choose from. The place was packed and there was nowhere to sit, so we grabbed our pizza and took the party back to our room (no regrets).
… moreSamantha Courtois
I could tell walking in this pizza was going to be good. There was a long line and it was freezing cold out. It was worth the wait! They were fast with taking orders and getting it in the oven. By the time I paid the pizza was ready. It had a perfect crispy crush without being burnt. The pizza was probably one of the best I ever had. We tried a few flavors and loved every single one. I stayed at the hard rock so we went out of convenience but I’d go out of my way to get this pizza again. I’ll definitely be back!
… moreYeen noemi Briceno melean
Amazing authentic New York style gourmet pizza!! Was not our first choice but Joe’s line was around the corner so decided to go somewhere else and ended up here! Totally worth it!! The place is small and not very appealing if u what to eat out but the food is GREAT! We took it to go and ate at the comfort of our hotel room Lots of different flavors and can be sold by the slice which gives u an option to try all u want in 1 pizza!! We tried cheese (real mozzarella melted chunks ), mushrooms and meat! They were all fantastic!! Highly recommended!!
… morePatrick Kelly
Stopped in at Little Italy Pizza before headed back to our hotel across the street. It was fast and easy and the staff were great. I picked up two cheese slices and a Hawaiian and it was a good 7 out of 10 pizza. Didn’t take more than 20 minutes to order check out and get our order to go.
Would definitely come back and grab another anew York Slice of Pizza.
… moreRob H
If you’re in the mood for a satisfying slice in Midtown Manhattan, Little Italy Pizza delivers. Their crust is thin and crispy, providing a delightful crunch with each bite. The sauce leans towards the sweeter side, complementing the cheese and toppings well. The pepperoni slice stands out as a fan favorite, offering a generous amount of flavorful pepperoni.
The establishment is known for its fast service and reasonable prices, making it a convenient stop for a quick meal. While the seating is limited, the quality of the pizza makes it worth the visit.
Whether you’re grabbing a slice on the go or sitting down for a meal, Little Italy Pizza provides a dependable and tasty option in the heart of the city.
… more … View more