Lelulo's Pizzeria - Plum, PA 15239 - Menu, Reviews, Hours & Contact

Purchased 01/30/2026: I bought a plain large pizza with sweet sauce and a large meatball hoagie with traditional sauce. The pizza was pretty good but, I think would have been much better with more sauce. There was a distinct flavor difference when I took a bite into a piece that had equal amounts of cheese/sauce. It was better (in my opinion). There wasn’t many of those bites. So, if you like just cheese pizza…you’d probably really like this. I did like it better next day cold, straight from the fridge. The meatball hoagie was just ok. Part of the not so good review can be attributed to the fact that I live almost a half hour from the shop. In that time things do get soggy etc. I think a bigger part is that it was wrapped in aluminum foil. Ok if I lived next door but not any much more time away. It traps moister and any crispiness that was there will now be moist and or soggy. Also better cold straight from the fridge the next day, because I expected the moister in the bread. Overall though, I would definitely eat the pizza again…I’d just ask if they could put more sauce on it. If I ate a hoagie again it would either be eaten there (if hot) or a cold cut to go.

… more

Nyla Wilson

We had just ordered and mind you I didn’t even want to have to write a review that’s why we called back but the manager was being weird about it but she was respectful and had an attitude at the same time. On the other hand when our food came we noticed the ranch was used and as you can see in the photo the food is untouched, one large pizza and 12 wings which in fact was perfect. We called just to let them know for another customer be careful and the manager sherry exactly kept repeating that she packed it herself and that the delivery driver wouldn’t do that and he didn’t seem like the person to however the ranch was used unfortunately we just hung up because she really wasn’t trying to resolve nothing. We may or may not order again but the food was bomb

… more

Samantha Nickoson

I crossed bridges for this pizza! If you know Pittsburgh, that’s a huge deal.

I’ve heard about Lelulo’s for awhile, it’s a staple for one of my coworkers (whose son also works here!) and had to try it when we were anywhere near.

I was surprised by how reasonable the prices are, knowing the quality and freshness of the ingredients. We picked it up and were helped by a very kind young man who handled everyone who came in with patience and excellent service, despite several to go orders and a full dining room.

We drove 40 minutes to get home, and THE PIZZA WAS STILL HOT! Fries were even still crispy! Everything we ordered was exceptional, fresh, and flavorful (why is it so hard to find seasoned, flavorful dough in Pittsburgh?). I cannot say enough good things – I don’t typically care for a sweeter sauce, but this was balanced so well. The only thing I would change is no sauce on the pizza fries, but that is purely a personal preference.

15/10 for Lelulo’s, we can’t wait to go back!

… more

ASHER TOKICH

I just ordered here for the first time and I must say im very disappointed after hearing rave reviews from other people in plum. Im pretty sure the breadsticks are deep fried as the ones I received were done so long they were hard and just pools of greas. The best way i can explain it is if you overcook and burn cheese sticks the outside of them are super hard while there is nothing left inside them it’s the same with the breadsticks I received. The pizza was okay my family and I like a sweet sauce and it may be personal preference but we didn’t care for the sauce. Overall just not satisfied and dont know if I would try it again seeing how the breadsticks served weren’t even edible yet still served to us.

… more

Larry Ulery Jr

My wife and I had lunch here back on 4/12/25 for the first time. We LOVED it. Large is the meat lover with traditional sauce (and no, it’s not burnt! We ordered it well done). The small is pepperoni, mushrooms, and banana peppers with the sweet sauce. Both were DELICIOUS! Quality toppings and as you can see, they are generous with them! We will definitely go back!

… more

Christin S

Our first time here and we loved it! The staff is friendly and helpful, the pizza and pasta were delicious! We were lucky enough to meet the owner, who is super friendly and a breath of fresh air. I love how much she cares about our community. Cannot wait to come back and support this restaurant again!

… more

Michael Visnick

The food is really good. Definitely better than most places. The problem is the wait times. I understand that there is a wait and the food is fresh. Give me a realistic time. This is the third time that I’ve been told 45-50 minutes. Showed up at 50 minutes and been told its still another 15-20 minutes. Just tell me that up front. I’ve worked in a pizza place. You should know how long an average order is and how long the wait should be. This might be the last time I order here. The great food does not overshadow the wait time. If this changes I’ll definitely update my review.

… more

Thomas Shirley

Went to Lelulo’s for the first time, let me say it was absolutely fantastic! Crust, sauce, cheese and toppings perfect. Plus the young person handling the counter was outstanding and so polite. I follow lelulo’s but never tried their food because we live in North Huntingdon But will definitely going there from now on!

… more

Sam Borgoyne

Extremely long wait times for pizza. It’s very good but it takes forever to get it. More than once we have gone to pick it up. We arrive and pick up time and then we’re told to wait another 20 minutes. I still ended up waiting 40 minutes. We decided to dine in once too, it was about an hour and 20 minutes between ordering and actually getting the food. Good pizza, but not worth waiting hours for it. And the fact that the owner just leaves snarky comments to all the bad reviews just shows that they don’t care. Good thing there’s plenty of other pizza places in the area.

… more

Kevin Geppert

Look no farther for the perfect pizza. This place has exceeded my expectations in terms of taste, quality, and friendliness. I was greeted at the door with energetic and happy people who were very helpful when ordering. I then waited for my food while playing some arcade games and pinball. When I got home and ate our pizzas, I simply couldn’t pick a favorite because everyone had its own unique greatness to it! We lastly enjoyed amazing cherry cheesecake cupcakes (they are a must try when available).
We will be coming back for more for years to come

… more

… View more

Lelulo’s Pizzeria

Hours

Address and Contact Information

Menu Photos

Order and Reservations

Photo Gallery

Related Web Results

Lelulo’s Pizzeria | Plum PA – Facebook

Lelulo’s Pizzeria – Plum, PA – 415 Unity Trestle Rd – Hours, Menu …

Lelulo’s Pizzeria – 415 Unity Trestle Rd, Plum, PA 15239 – Slice

Reviews

Leave a Comment Cancel reply

🍽️ List or Update Your Restaurant

Recent Posts