Dimitriy Dzyuba
First time eating here, ordered a Buffalo Chicken pizza and it was amazing! Asked for pineapple as an added topping and they had no issue fulfilling my request. Friendly staff and a very nice meal, hope to eat here again sometime!
(Will add that their drinking water is absolutely repulsive, though — likely not the establishment’s fault, but I recommend getting something else if you want a drink.)
… moreT R
I have been ordering pizza from them almost once a week for a month or so. It’s mostly been good. Tonight we ordered two steak bombs it was almost $50 by the time it got to our door. We only got one cold and soggy steak bomb and one Tuna sub. We ordered two steak bombs not a tuna sub. The one we did get was gross, soggy, and cold. I couldn’t even eat it. The Tuna went in the trash and we wasted $50. There’s no quality anymore. They don’t care enough to make sure it’s good or right. Unfortunately these days it’s hard to find decent food. I’m very disappointed we don’t have money to waste like this.
… moreTony Rea
Lake Pizza has a wide variety of great food to choose from including a wide range original recipes for pizzas, appetizers, dinners and salads with a friendly atmosphere. The wait staff are have great personalities, helpful and are courteous. They have a full bar and have to say make magnificent martinis. They have plenty of parking too with easy wheelchair access. It can get crowded on weekends as it’s very popular. They don’t take reservations. They have take out and delivery with DoorDash & Grubhub. They’re closed Sundays.
… moreJack O’Brien
Food is not as good as it used to be. This place is going downhill and has been for a while. They are very cheap with the amount of cheese and sauce they use for their pizza. They used to have the best buffalo calzone and now they don’t even bother filling it with buffalo sauce, every order is just a dry chicken calzone. It is safe to say that this restaurant is not in its prime anymore. The pizza is just cardboard now.
… moreJillian McMillen
Great service and friendly, fun atmosphere. Pretty good food but unfortunately the tap water they serve is undrinkable and the restaurant is ok with that. Would like to be able to eat here but can’t justify supporting a restaurant that has undrinkable water and doesn’t want to address it.
… moreMissy Hulse
Ordered take out, baked haddock was supposed to come with mashed potatoes, carrots and the soup of the day or side salad. When I opened the container no mashed potatoes, just a couple cold French fries, no carrots just coleslaw, no tarter sauce just ketchup and no soup. Paid over $20 for a couple cold fries, baked haddock and cole slaw. I moved away for 24 yrs and this place i used to love. I guess a lot has changed in 24 yrs.
… moreGeorge Baraklilis
The food is absolutely the best, honestly it’s the best pizza in Webster,John should be very proud of that. Strongly recommend this restaurant if you’re at Webster Lake or anywhere in Webster, very friendly staff!!
… moreSuzanne Miller
I did takeout. The person that took my call was very courteous. When I picked up my order, I was tended to immediately and both young men were professional and polite
… moreLaurel Wilson
Always Delicious food at Lake Pizza! Staff is friendly. The chicken wings are sooo good! Best pizza in town. So many selections . Highly recommend.
… moreLyman Green
Classic Webster establishment. Food is great. Parking lot kind of sucks but it’s not that big a deal most of the time anyway except in peak meal times
… more