Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 2424 E Main St, Bexley, OH 43209
Phone: (614) 929-5000
Website: http://www.kittiescakes.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Kitties Cakes
… bexley café. 2424 E. Main Street Bexley, Ohio 43209 614.929.5000. Open Daily: 7am to 4 pm. worthington café. 693 High Street Worthington, Ohio 43085 614.992 …
Kitties: Home
Breakfast. Shop Now. Pastry. Shop Now. Kitties. Sign Up. This form is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.
Kittie’s (@kittiescakes) • Instagram photos and videos
M) 2424 E Main St. Bexley • 7-4 693 High St. Worthington • 7-4. @kittiescakes …
Reviews
TXExplorer
This is a great little coffee shop, with a decent selection of coffee, tea, and some food. Good without being pretentious about it.
The staff was friendly and efficient.
Only thing I would say is it’s quite small, even accounting for the outdoor patio.
Be prepared to make a quick exit to the bookstore it adjoins to find some breathing space
… moreThe staff was friendly and efficient.
Only thing I would say is it’s quite small, even accounting for the outdoor patio.
Be prepared to make a quick exit to the bookstore it adjoins to find some breathing space
Justice Glenn
I’ve been wanting to try this place for a long while and I’m glad I finally did. I had the seasonal Honey Caramel Apple Cider and the Sweet Potato Maple Sammie. I can’t wait to go back and the try the cinnamon roll and other drinks! The customer service as well as the playlist inside were great, I definitely recommend!
… moreA Freeman
This is a cute little bakery. I came for a cinnamon roll but they were out, so I got the chocolate silk danish. I loved it! Tasted just like a piece of chocolate silk pie. I also got the egg nog cold brew (no picture), which was amazing! Kids got the Micky’o oatmeal cream pie, and an egg nog latte. They really enjoyed them. The table area is very small but it still works. Love that the wall opens up to the book store next door. Will be back to try different pastries, and get another egg nog cold brew!
… moreMelody White
This is a great lil business that offers wonderful products, but seems to have lost focus on overall quality. The bathroom was dirty, and there was a sign encouraging us to inform staff about any issues, but there wasn’t any immediate issue(s), like a clog, or missing supplies. Rather, it was more of the general look of neglect, as if it hasn’t been cleaned for at least a week; a buildup of shiny, dried, sticky spots all over the floor, debris on the edge of the bowl and seat, crusty faucets, etc. At this exact time, there were 2 employees at the bookstore register chatting to each other, with ample opportunity to “check the bathroom”, as it’s truly their job to do so.
I found the cleanliness lacking throughout the diner as well. The tables weren’t wiped down, inside or out, the counters, both where the food is prepared and where food is served, likewise were full of food debris because no one was taking the time to clean up, and it was attracting files. Acknowledging that I was there during one of their busiest times, Sunday lunch, but also, and I can’t stress this enough, throughout my visit, there were many opportunities for the staff to remedy these issues. Five employees standing behind the counter, chatting to each other, while 3 of them worked, and they were tripping over each other to stand behind the counter to chat, and no one taking the initiative to clean the food prep area, much less the tables. So, I want to emphasize, it wasn’t that they couldn’t clean, it was that they didn’t care enough to clean. Being understaffed is one thing, but having the staff who just don’t care about their customers enough to do it, is altogether a completely different issue.
Employees were friendly, pleasant, and very kind, but lacked supervision, direction and the thoughtfulness needed to provide an overall high quality of service. Truly caring for your establishment and your customers, by keeping things tidy, is a minimum in any food & beverage retailer. Sad to see a place with the ability to ‘hit it out of the park’ fall so short, barely making it to the ‘so-so’ mark.
… moreI found the cleanliness lacking throughout the diner as well. The tables weren’t wiped down, inside or out, the counters, both where the food is prepared and where food is served, likewise were full of food debris because no one was taking the time to clean up, and it was attracting files. Acknowledging that I was there during one of their busiest times, Sunday lunch, but also, and I can’t stress this enough, throughout my visit, there were many opportunities for the staff to remedy these issues. Five employees standing behind the counter, chatting to each other, while 3 of them worked, and they were tripping over each other to stand behind the counter to chat, and no one taking the initiative to clean the food prep area, much less the tables. So, I want to emphasize, it wasn’t that they couldn’t clean, it was that they didn’t care enough to clean. Being understaffed is one thing, but having the staff who just don’t care about their customers enough to do it, is altogether a completely different issue.
Employees were friendly, pleasant, and very kind, but lacked supervision, direction and the thoughtfulness needed to provide an overall high quality of service. Truly caring for your establishment and your customers, by keeping things tidy, is a minimum in any food & beverage retailer. Sad to see a place with the ability to ‘hit it out of the park’ fall so short, barely making it to the ‘so-so’ mark.
Ben Perlmutter
This place was cute. Service was fast and friendly, atmosphere was average cafe vibes. The food (I got a cinnamon roll, which was almost out in the display at 9am), was disappointing. This roll was entirely one-note. Gooey, sweet, and soft. No caramelization of sugar, no crunch, and no structure. They microwaved it in the bag, and the bag took off half the topping, which while not a big deal for flavor, was a detractor for presentation.
I don’t think I’ll be back here for the pastries though I may try out their sandwiches at some point.
… moreI don’t think I’ll be back here for the pastries though I may try out their sandwiches at some point.
Amber Foppes
Such a cute spot attached to Gramercy Books, staff is always friendly and everything is delicious. I LOVE that they have vegetarian sausage!
… moreD F
I’m not kidding when I tell you that I just had the best breakfast sandwich I’ve ever had. I ordered the sausage, egg and cheese breakfast sandwich on a cheddar jalapeno biscuit. A bit pricey but you get what you pay for. The caramel latte was also perfection.
… moreCandace Jones
I went in this morning of all days 01/27/2026. They were not only open but the service was exceptional. I had their breakfast oatmeal which was FABULOUS. Some of the best oatmeal outside of my own that I have ever had. And I had a hot chocolate with a toasted marshmallow. If you are wanting good food with GREAT service, stop in, you won’t regret it.
… moreTay
I decided to just stop by on a whim to this cute little bakery/cafe and I’m so glad I did! The staff was friendly and helpful with suggestions. The coffee was frothy, creamy and delicious! If you’re thinking about getting the jalapeño cream cheese on your sandwich and you’re on the fence about it, just do it! The best part was while waiting for the food, there is a bookstore next door you can browse. Definitely recommend trying this place! ❤️
UPDATE: Been coming here for the last 2 years after making this review and I’ve become a regular whom the baristas always recognize and they always make me feel so warm and welcome! They always show extra love to my drinks! Such a great staff and location LOVE YOU KITTIES
… moreUPDATE: Been coming here for the last 2 years after making this review and I’ve become a regular whom the baristas always recognize and they always make me feel so warm and welcome! They always show extra love to my drinks! Such a great staff and location LOVE YOU KITTIES
Jason Landis
It’s connected to a book store which I thought was nice. Cozy atmosphere. Great food and coffee. I got a breakfast sandwich on a fresh baked sweet potato biscuit. Good seating availability.
… more